Why are there only so few unique character portraits in game?
First I though it must be only fanboys complaining that certain characters are not in the game but I have drstically changed my mind.
As an explanation, I don't know the story and characters and I have only played records mode yet. I'm about 130 turn into a Cao Cao campaign.
At the start of my campaign I had the options to get a few named characters but not really anymore after 50 turns. Diplomacy is just a bunch of generic characters at this point. Everybody is the same and of the initial leaders only Liu Bei and Zhang Yan are left, Zhang Yan is just a two settlement vassal. Now, it's not the problem that the initial leaders die but that all named character die that fast and no new ones come in to replace them. They are all replaced by generics at this point. There are characters in game that are not just generic but they have no unique portrait, one example being Cao Pi, the person that is naturally Cao Cao's heir and that will lead the faction in most campaigns at some point. I don't get that decision. Why have characters, that will lead a main faction in most campaigns, no unique portrait? I really like the character management in the game but it loses it's appeal later on when you only have to manage people that look the same. With characters being a focus of the game, with important semi unique characters already in game and with the low effort it would be to add some more character portraits I don't get why there are only so few character portraits in game. It really would be low effort compared to how much better the game would feel. I mean mods will add that anyway but that can't be CA's plan, right?
Posted May 28, 2019, 11:00 AM UTC
CA will definitely release DLC in the future which adjusts the starting year along with faction starting locations, territory and the roster of generals in their court.
I imagine when that happens generals who are more prominent in later years (such as Cao Pi) will get unique models, face and items.
For their initial release they have focused on characters who were prominent in 190 but eventually the cast of characters will grow.
I do think that there should be more variety in generic general faces and more items to make them feel a bit different, even if they have the same stats just appearance to add variety.. but i think that is something the modders will need to add.
I really hope it grows but I can not approve of the decision to tie that to DLC. For the gameplay these heirs are just as important as the initial leader if not even more important. I get it that they were not as important in the novel but I played with Cao Pi as a leader just as long as I did with Cao Cao (he died of natural causes). Cao Cao will not be relevant for two thirds of my campaign but Cao Pi was the heir from the beginning and will probably be the faction leader until I finish the campaign, at least he shouldn't die to natural causes.
"for the gameplay" unique portraits and models don't affect your gameplay
Maybe not directly but to dismiss them as having no affect on gameplay is arrogant.
Having unique portraits and models will affect the way you play and perceive the games, especially for a Total War game which is diplomacy focused, with the introduced mechanics of managing relationships with other characters.
You want these characters to feel alive, not General Generic.
Ideally, everything would be in the game
In real life, decisions have to be made and features prioritized.
You can argue that these portraits are a higher priority than other things, but you have to concede something else. Time (delay the game), a different feature, etc.
If the base game was missing any sort of characters, or otherwise not as feature rich, I would be more symphatetic with your viewpoint, but as the game stands DLC seems like the logical way of doing this.
Paid DLC nearly always comes with FLC though.
I imagine, new factions/units etc might be paid, whereas new portraits/cosmetics for existing characters might be something that arrives through FLC.
Also, CA tend to leave the really indepth history nerd stuff to the modders. You'll get your custom portraits that way even if CA decide to never touch 3K again.