I guess we know where all of Windgrace's 'Lands Matter' cards ended up now... and the rest of the ninjas...
Posted May 28, 2019, 9:32 PM UTC
Posted May 28, 2019, 9:32 PM UTC
The cats deck had mirari’s wake and a bunch of equipment staples. Hammer of nazahn alone is worth that deck, off the many games it’s won me.
Oh yeah, I bought the vampire and dragon decks and am totally satisfied with the value. The dragons were pretty awful to play out of the box because of the awful mana base (Relatedly, Chromatic Lantern was reprinted shortly after in GRN, probably the reason why it was not included), but there were some good value reprints in there and some good value new cards in each deck as well.
Most years prior to 2018 were very fair to players and had good value as well as being reasonably playable out of the box. 2018 just didn't really deliver on value and a lot of new cards sucked (e.g. Varchild, Gyrus, Enchanter's Bane) or were dramatically overcosted (Saheeli's Artistry) to avoid them getting picked up in other formats.
It's not a black-and-white thing to say they're all bad or all good, but I do think they have a lot of room to do better this year.
I am just really happy to have [[Ayula's Influence]] in [[The Gitrog Monster]].
I have been a loooong time Gitrog player since it was spoiled. I was highly anticipating the Lands Jund deck, and was a little let down as many were. I have gone back and forth in my mind many times on whether or not I want to lean into Jund with it and put Windgrace at the helm (the thought of having Gitrog and [[Borborygmos Enraged]] out at the same time is very enticing)
Now with [[Throes of Chaos]] and some of the other new card spoiled, I am totally lost.
Windgrace, the commander, is fabulous and I highly recommend it if your budget can handle it (fast fetches are really important in that deck, etc - not a great deck to build on a budget imo). The long-running complaint is the quality of everything else besides the new legendaries in the C2018 products, which is valid imo.
#####
######
####
Ayula's Influence - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
The Gitrog Monster - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Borborygmos Enraged - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Throes of Chaos - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call
I ended up using Windgrace to make a dragon-centric deck that tries to combo out with infinite combat steps. He's a fine toolbox commander if you want to have a flexible deck that aims to ramp heavily. Hope your build goes well :)
Yeah, my version of Gitrog is a non-combo version, that leans on card advantage and attrition.
Swapping to Lord Windgrace might seem simple at first, but would require some fundamental changes.
They have said they've taken feedback onboard from C18 and hear us "loud and clear", so they'll likely be aiming at better reprints and power-level/value in general. Here is hoping, it's always a great time when the new decks come out regardless of how good they are.
Yeah, here's hoping. They have an unfortunate history of running popular products into the ground before they start listening to feedback, e.g. modern horizons vs the iconic/M25/ultimate masters end of the series. Hard to have nuanced conversation on Reddit it seems but that's basically what I wanted to talk about. I was just surprised how many cards that will be great for commander and would have greatly improved last year's release are showing up in this set, hopefully they give us something worth getting excited about this year :-)
Completely agree with you. I also don't think they should always (sometimes maybe, but not always) look at a card's value when considering whether or not to put it in a sealed product like Commander. People will rave about (and buy more perhaps) the decks if they include obviously sought-after cards.
They are entry level decks that are purposely built with several themes in mind. Can’t have your cake and eat it too.
I really doubt they pulled these cards from the Windgrace precon to put them into this set. Would've loved to have had a better set of supporting cards in C2018, but this feels a bit conspiracy-theory-esque to me.
It's not so much literally cut from the deck to put in MH as it is missed opportunities. They've talked before about how they spread relevant cards across sets up to a year before and after the release - see Azusa and Crucible of Worlds in M25 and C19, or Doubling Season and Arena Rector in BBD just before a planeswalker themed set.
It's not meant to be a big conspiracy theory or anything, they've discussed it in interviews and I think it's generally not a bad idea. You want players thinking about/trying other formats, and giving EDH players a reason to try out sealed, have packs they can be excited to buy, that kind of thing is all good as long as the base product is still a good value. I just think the precons need a bit more love than they got last year, and seeing all these great cards that could have helped deliver on the themes is a reminder that they can do better.
Oh, then sure. They've gone into some detail about how they view the 2018 precons as not great on reprints/non-commanders (though the commanders themselves are widely loved), and hopefully that'll be fixed this year.