r/Fantasy•
DavidMusk

Correlation Between Progression Fantasy and Self-Published/Webnovels?

I've recently gotten into progression fantasy, starting with Arcane Ascension last year, and finishing all six Cradle books this year. The quality of Cradle was a huge surprise—I never would have expected a series on Kindle Unlimited to make it into my top five, but it did.

Now, I've just started Mother of Learning, and the quality here is even more surprising considering it's a free web novel.

Now I'm curious, why are so many of these either self-published books or free webnovels as opposed to being traditionally published?

Sure, there are some traditionally published books that fall into the progression genre like Stormlight Archive, but the progression element here is just one of many subgenres IMO. You could also say that most magic school books have some progression element (Name of the Wind, Harry Potter, Book of the Ancestor) but these are notably different from the books listed above. The characters do get stronger, but it's usually more the result of practice than anything tangible or quantifiable.) Even if we consider these part of the progression genre, they still seem to make up a small percentage when compared to their self-published counter-parts.

Is this because the progression genre is new, and industry editors and agents haven't caught on yet? Maybe they consider the 'harder' progression novels (especially litRPGs) too niche to appear in book stores? Are authors even submitting books of this genre to agents/editors, or are they going straight for the webnovel/self-published route?

Posted May 28, 2019, 10:26 PM UTC · edited

1217

Traditional publishing provides a gateway to entry by filtering out books which would not be considered well-written in a traditional sense, taking into account primarily things like characterization, prose, and theme. Fantasy authors and readers often consider several other factors to be important as well (escapism, likeable/self-insertable characters, worldbuilding, magic systems, action scenes, witty banter, etc.), and so those traditional metrics are not as crucial as they might be outside the genre. But from what I have seen, I would conjecture that litRPG and adjacent subgenres are overall much more extreme in their disregard for the "traditional standards of quality" than the rest of the fantasy genre, and so self-publishing is a more natural route to follow.

15

I would conjecture that litRPG and adjacent subgenres are overall much more extreme in their disregard for the "traditional standards of quality" than the rest of the fantasy genre

This is incredibly tactful, well done.

11
JohnBierceWriter John Bierce•

So as a progression fantasy author:

I didn't even try to go the traditional publishing route. Part of that is the money thing- it's easier to make a living self-publishing these days, frankly- but part definitely has to do with the genre thing. Self publishing is just much friendlier towards hyperspecific subgenres than traditional publishing, and progression fantasy is pretty damn specific.

To be clear, I think that the growing specificity of subgenre is actually a consequence of self-publishing, not just something correlated. People like being able to hang out in their very own hyperspecific niche, and they're going to reward authors who scratch that itch for them in a much more immediate way than in traditional publishing. You see this across the board, but especially strongly in SFF and romance. (There were, of course, plenty of quite specific subgenres before the rise of self-publishing, but self-publishing has added so much in that regard that I believe this is a legitimate case of quantitative change significant enough to count as qualitative change.)

There's another part, though- one (fairly legitimate) criticism of progression fantasy as a genre (even before Andrew Rowe named it) was that its focus on characters growing in power often supplanted them actually growing as characters- who they are as people often hardly changes from the beginning of a progression fantasy story to the end. A lot of critics see progression fantasy as juvenile power fantasy, and for a lot of stories in the genre, they're right. That's certainly not true of all of them- Arcane Ascension and Cradle both have plenty of character growth, for instance. (I aim to include that as well.) I think this might make the subgenre a little less attractive to some publishers, and I think that- or at least the perception of it, whether or not it is true- has discouraged some progression fantasy authors from submitting traditionally.

Finally, well... there are a lot of works in progression fantasy that just wouldn't make the cut in traditional publishing. They don't usually tend to do very well in self-publishing either, but that's the nature of the game- the stinkers just don't tend to be visible in traditional publishing, because they don't get published. Hell, countless really pretty good novels don't get published at all going to traditional route. (And a few stinkers do get published traditionally, of course.) In self-publishing, these works are all just a hell of a lot more visisble.

12
SalarisStabby Winner, Writer Andrew Rowe•

Hiya!

First off, thanks for reading my books, I appreciate it.

I see progression fantasy as having a few main roots:

  • General hard magic fiction, where clear description of abilities is an important element for making the story "solvable" by readers.
  • RPGs, which popularized the concept of having clear, quantified power levels in Western culture.
  • Shonen battle manga/anime, where clear power differences, training, tournaments, etc. are major hallmarks of the genre.
  • Xixanxia and xuanhuan fiction, where progression is a major focus of the protagonists of the story and power levels are often clear and story relevant.

Similar stories have evolved independently of these factors, but I think a lot of what we're currently calling progression fantasy comes from these roots. Some of our stories are inspired by some styles more than others.

For example, my Arcane Ascension books are a love letter to JRPGs. In writing the books, I tried to take RPG tropes and build them into the universe of the story in a coherent and internally consistent fashion. For example, things like character classes and levels exist, but viewed through the lens of people living in the universe (attunements and attunement levels). And, since people know these things exist, many people make it a goal to learn as much about them as possible and gain as much personal power as they can through varying means.

Notably, I also drew from inspiration from things like shonen battle manga as well, especially the ones focused on clever problem solving like Hunter x Hunter.

Will Wight's Cradle books draw more heavily from xianxia fiction rather than JRPGs, and thus, his tropes tend to more closely resemble those of xianxia stories. Like me, however, he also draws from a wide variety of sources in order to try to construct something unique - and also subverts some of the more traditional elements of xianxia style fiction.

Notably, stories like Will's and my own are more frequently self-published here, but stories in this general style are much more common in other markets.

One of the clearest examples of this would be the Dragon Ball franchise. I'll avoid getting into a rant on the lack of internal consistency in Dragon Ball, but it's ultimately about characters training over time and fighting stronger and stronger opponents, which is the crux of the progression fantasy genre. Many other shonen battle series - Hunter x Hunter, Naruto, etc. - would also fit the progression fantasy genre mold very well.

I think a big part of this is that manga has a history of long-running continuous stories with the same protagonists just living their lives and getting stronger. While we do have some very long-running series in the Western market, they'll generally either have periodic resets (Superman, X-Men, etc.), jump between different characters per mini-series (Dragonlance), or have a character that starts out powerful and generally stays that way (Taltos, Drizzt, etc.)

As we see successes with things like the Stormlight Archives, I expect to see progression fantasy getting more mainstream as well...but I think self-publishing will remain the dominant approach for a while.

As a self-published author, I suspect that going traditional would be a losing bet for me in most cases. Some reasons:

  • LitRPGs have been growing as a genre rapidly, and many readers of LitRPGs are used to low-priced Kindle books or buying directly through Kindle Unlimited. A traditional publisher may price a book too high for this crowd, and the LitRPG crowd is a significant chunk of the progression fantasy readership. (They're not the exact same thing, but LitRPGs and progression fantasy have huge overlap.)
  • Traditional publishers often take huge amounts of time after a book is finished to actually publish it. Every month they delay is lost sales from my standpoint.
  • I get a much, much larger % of the sale price when I self-publish.
  • When self-publishing, I get to retain all my rights to other forms of media, so I can do things like sell other rights independently if someone wanted to make a movie, a TV show, etc.
  • Also, I get to retain full control over my intellectual property, and how the book turns out in general if I self-publish.
  • Etc.

There are advantages to traditional (free editing and cover, wider distribution, marketing, etc.), but they're generally not worth it to me, at least at present. I suspect most self-published progression fantasy authors (as well as ones from related genres, like LitRPGs and GameLit) have gone through similar calculations.

8
32nd_freeze•

"For example, my Arcane Ascension books are a love letter to JRPGs. In writing the books, I tried to take RPG tropes and build them into the universe of the story in a coherent and internally consistent fashion."

I knew AA was inspired by Video Games and RPGs in general, but I didn't know it was JRPGs in particular. Selys had better watch her back come the final book in the series.

3
SalarisStabby Winner, Writer Andrew Rowe•

Good line of thought there. =D

1
DavidMuskOP•

Thanks for the reply! That's very helpful.

Can't wait for the next Arcane Ascension! :)

3
SalarisStabby Winner, Writer Andrew Rowe•

You're welcome, and thanks for the interest and support!

1
DireBare•

Just spitballin' here, but "progression fantasy" is a relatively new genre, and self-publishing is a relatively new phenomenon . . . that could be the simple correlation right there.

5
JohnBierceWriter John Bierce•

The genre's older than its name, but yeah, still pretty young for the most part, and the traditional publishing industry changes slower than self-publishing, so that's definitely part of it.

4
LOLtohru•

I think it's hard to have a discussion of this subject because it tends to inspire strong feelings and sometimes downvote brigades. I used to participate in discussions on the topic and after a while just felt worn down.

However since you're not getting any responses I'll try to say a little. I think that the genre is particularly suited to its online niche especially Kindle Unlimited and Amazon ebooks. Traditional publishing isn't necessarily a logical move for the genre and I'd guess that many authors wouldn't even be interested in making it.

3
Rune_of_Ilm•

What is this progression fantasy you speak of?

2
ConnorF42Reading Champion 2018•
2
Rune_of_Ilm•

That seems like normal fantasy to me. king Arthur pulled excalibur from the lake, Taran wandered to become worthy of Dyrnwyn, Hercules gained a useful boon after each labor, the hobbits grew in strength and wisdom with the fellowship, etc.

0
ProtoNeuromancer•

So fantasy with character progression? 😛

-1
tired1680•

LitRPG & Progression Fantasy author here.

Traditional publishing is slow. Very, very slow, especially compared to many of us indie published authors. For LitRPG, the best time to get in was from 2015-2017 or so. Around 2017 is when it really started getting known and a lot of writers started putting out their own work. Many of those works, as others have alluded to, were first books too, so the work was not as polished. But. The readers wanted the books and consumed them like crazy. If you published a LitRPG book in 2017, were readable and got involved in the various social media communities, you'd likely make more than the vast, vast majority of trad published authors with that first book.

As I understand it, it can take up to 2 years for a trad published book to get out. Months to find an agent. Months to get accepted by the publisher. Then multiple edits that take months each. At which point, you get inserted into their promo schedule.

And even then, as a small-medium author, I understand there's very little in terms of marketing help that they offer. In turn, you give up all your copyrights and a tiny royalty.

If, in my case, I tried to get my books into trad publishing the 'normal' way, my first book would release around now. At this point, the LitRPG market is incredibly crowded. I know a lot of authors who have released their books and struggled to do as well as they 'should' have considering the relative quality of their work.

That being said.

I know of at least one medium sized publisher who split off a division to jump into LitRPG. They announced their move nearly a year ago and their first books should hit the market in June. I know there are people trying to get into trad publishing (outside of above publisher), but if you have to shop a book around for 6 months to a year, that same author might be publishing other series in the meantime.

Long story short - there might be more trad published novels coming in the next few years, but it'll mostly be a self-published domain. If, as an author, you have to do most of the marketing yourself anyway, there's very little reason to give up an even larger % of your royalty.

2
ACCobbleAMA Author AC Cobble•

I imagine traditional publishers are already dipping their toes into LitRPG / progression novels, but their process is a long one. Not only can it take a year or more for them to get a book out, they're also slow to respond to rising sub-genres because they don't know if it's a fad or a trend. If it's a fad, and they can't get the book to market in two years, they won't want to move on something new... I suspect it's just around now that the people who watch this sort of thing at the big publishers are becoming convinced it is a trend, and not just a fad. So, yeah, we're likely to start seeing some deals in that space soon.

That's one half of the equation.

The other half is that frankly, the only thing the big publishers have to offer successful authors in the genre is bookstore distribution. And it remains to be seen if there are bookstore readers who will support the genre... Anyone who is at the top of the genre who signed with a traditional publisher is likely to lose significant amounts of money on their eBooks and audio. And an advance? Those take years to get paid out fully, and even longer to earn out if they ever do. If someone's already publishing books at a highly profitable rate, that traditional carrot trad pub offers isn't very compelling.

1