Correlation Between Progression Fantasy and Self-Published/Webnovels?
I've recently gotten into progression fantasy, starting with Arcane Ascension last year, and finishing all six Cradle books this year. The quality of Cradle was a huge surprise—I never would have expected a series on Kindle Unlimited to make it into my top five, but it did.
Now, I've just started Mother of Learning, and the quality here is even more surprising considering it's a free web novel.
Now I'm curious, why are so many of these either self-published books or free webnovels as opposed to being traditionally published?
Sure, there are some traditionally published books that fall into the progression genre like Stormlight Archive, but the progression element here is just one of many subgenres IMO. You could also say that most magic school books have some progression element (Name of the Wind, Harry Potter, Book of the Ancestor) but these are notably different from the books listed above. The characters do get stronger, but it's usually more the result of practice than anything tangible or quantifiable.) Even if we consider these part of the progression genre, they still seem to make up a small percentage when compared to their self-published counter-parts.
Is this because the progression genre is new, and industry editors and agents haven't caught on yet? Maybe they consider the 'harder' progression novels (especially litRPGs) too niche to appear in book stores? Are authors even submitting books of this genre to agents/editors, or are they going straight for the webnovel/self-published route?
Posted May 28, 2019, 10:26 PM UTC · edited
Traditional publishing provides a gateway to entry by filtering out books which would not be considered well-written in a traditional sense, taking into account primarily things like characterization, prose, and theme. Fantasy authors and readers often consider several other factors to be important as well (escapism, likeable/self-insertable characters, worldbuilding, magic systems, action scenes, witty banter, etc.), and so those traditional metrics are not as crucial as they might be outside the genre. But from what I have seen, I would conjecture that litRPG and adjacent subgenres are overall much more extreme in their disregard for the "traditional standards of quality" than the rest of the fantasy genre, and so self-publishing is a more natural route to follow.
This is incredibly tactful, well done.