Turtle Formation overpowered?
So I know this might get a bit of hate, but I would like to hear the opinions of others on this as I am a bit back and forth with it.
On one hand, Archers are incredibly powerful in this game. Excessively so, especially in the early-midgame. Not to mention towers, which while relatively easy to take out and I personally think they are perfectly balanced right now, they are definitely unit killers still. So the Turtle formation gives a viable counter to those units, especially given that it is very easy to bait out the AI's ammo with the archers, and currently the way the towers work is once they target something, they usually don't change target unless they lose line of sight. (And yes I know that they will not initially target a unit in Turtle formation, however you can still bait this out by switching them in and out of the formation to get the tower aggro and waste archer ammo).
On the other, 100% reduction might be a little too strong. Coupled with the charge defense it gives, they are literally invulnerable units to anything but massed infantry or trebs. I feel like even with the formation, with enough massed fire, we should still be seeing some casualties. That way you can't expect to just waste the opponents ammo for free without sacrificing a significant portion of your men, leaving you vulnerable to cavalry attack.
I would definitely rethink my strategy if I risked losing all, or most of, my spears before engaging at close range in exchange for nullifying their archers. A single well used shock cavalry unit can potentially wipe an entire infantry line if given the opportunity. And the AI has managed to do it a few times while I was focused elsewhere too..
So, thoughts? The ability is rare and difficult to get only being available with the Military Expert follower, but it is my bread and butter once I do manage to get it. Makes town & city battles a cakewalk since I can just ignore towers entirely.
Posted May 29, 2019, 3:51 AM UTC