Your Whole Baby Billboard
Your Whole Baby is raising funds for a billboard in New Orleans. I thought this was a great idea and wanted to share.
Posted May 30, 2019, 9:15 PM UTC
209
Your Whole Baby is raising funds for a billboard in New Orleans. I thought this was a great idea and wanted to share.
Posted May 30, 2019, 9:15 PM UTC
The AAP has been picketed and demonstated against for at least 30 years . It has not done a bit of good. This billboard will not work either.
The AAP is a trade association. They represent the business interests of doctors. Doctors make money from doing circumcisions. They are not about to stop as long as third party payers will continue to pay for circumcision.
Only shutting off the money will work as we have seen in England, New Zealand, and Canada.
FickleCaptain,
I love and up-vote all of your post that I encounter, but I am going to have to disagree a little here with you.
This problem is a multifaceted problem. Only focusing on cutting out funding at the government level will not get it done. Change in government is slow, expensive, and requires constant vigilance to maintain it.
Bringing awareness and educating people to the truth has been effective in saving many babies. There are many single moms in the US that will make the decision on their own, or despite the father. I think many of these will see this, investigate and make the right choice. I have heard of stories where the mothers have changed the mind of the father into making the right choice because she researched it and came to the truth.
We cannot know the full extend of the benefit, but for everyone that we know it helps, I like to think that there is at least one other one that we don't know about that has been helped too.
Sure, there are some that cannot be reached by any means, but some can and I do not want to leave those behind.
We need to push on multiple fronts to take down the beast because it is being supported by multiple sources.
Thank you for your efforts.
I hope you are right and I am wrong.
Your point is well taken, and I agree with that this billboard will not make any significant changes to the AAP as a whole. However, I have heard of some doctors leaving the AAP on their circumcision stance. And I agree that it would be good money well spent if there was a campaign to place billboards will they will be seen by more of the populace. Getting parents to say no, I think will be where the most effect comes from, but we still have to try all sources.
Pressuring insurance providers to drop the procedure is the way to go. The average American doesn't want to listen and American doctors are on a completely different wavelength from a normal person. You've got to hit circumcision where it hurts: the funding. People have been protesting this issue on the streets for about 40 years now and look how far that's gotten us, a half-step forward maybe.
I agree. This is truly an age of information, and there are definitely people who have changed their minds and refused circumcision after doing some (now much easier to acess) research. When you're fighting something that is so entrenched that most do it without thinking and just assume it to be a settled question that it is good, necessary, or mandatory, there is no amount of awareness that isn't to your benefit!
I agree with you, yours seems to be the only logical conclusion. Cut off the insurance coverage for circumcision and then you will see a decline, although that will be much more difficult for the US because of the decades of propaganda and anti-foreskin pseudoscience but it can probably be done. Protesting doctors will do nothing because they are not on the same wavelength as you or I, they are utterly desensitized to the pain they cause and very much dogmatic about what they were taught in medical school which is invariably that foreskin = bad and here's how to cut if off.
Getting insurance providers to stop paying for it is the only way to make a change because that is the only way there was any change in the other Anglo territories. There was not some great awakening of the average person or a wellspring of doctors that suddenly figured out what ethics was, it all came down to the money and the sudden lack of coverage for the procedure that resulted in its significant decline. People are wasting their time with street protests for the most part, most laymen on the street don't take the issue seriously, 99% of the time an American doctor does not even consider listening, and foreign doctors already agree with us most of the time. Pressure insurance companies to drop it because it's an unnecessary and damaging procedure instead, that's the only way.
have to admit, you're right
if we can de-fund unnecessary genital surgery then parents will question if it's worth spending $500 for their baby to "look like them". Even though a baby's penis will never look like an adult's penis, mutilated or intact.
require the purchase of "circumcision insurance" that covers any and all restorative procedures, current or future, with no lifetime time or dollar limits