r/cars•
iceag

Engine Oil Interval: 5000 miles vs 7500 miles

When do you guys change your engine oil? I've been doing 5000 miles with full synthetic but after doing research online and looking at engine oil analysis reports it looks like 7500 mile intervals are fine for city/highway mix driving. This would be significant because it using the oil 50% longer, so then if you chang the oil over a 100,000 mile period, with 5k you would do 20 oil changes over that time, with 7.5k only 13, a significant decrease, for the same engine protection. Anyone else have any opinions or oil analysis reports regarding this?

Posted Jun 1, 2019, 5:12 PM UTC · edited

1168
Matt_OPEC2018 Subie OB 2.5•

I change my oil every 800 miles and use 1 quart bottles of each synthetic oil manufacturer

​

Subarus 2.5 liters are so fragile that if I were to stretch it any longer I'd likely throw a rod and blow a head gasket

58
iceagOP•

Are you memeing lol

24
[deleted]•

[deleted]

16
ashowofhands15 Accord 6-6 coupe, 08 Outback, 97 Miata•

There's a difference between an old beat-on performance car and a 1-year-old Outback that probably still smells like a new car. There's no reason why a base-model regular Subaru should ever need anything beyond what is outlined in the severe conditions maintenance schedule.

There's also a difference between changing your oil every 3000 miles (already excessive, especially when running full synthetic) and changing it every 800 miles. I mean come on, that's an oil change every 2 tanks of gas. Who would ever think that's necessary? That oil's practically coming out cleaner than it went in. I'm all for being cautious but that's just wasteful.

Thrown rods are a turbo motor issue and head gaskets are an EJ25 problem. The non-turbo, FB25 in a 2018 Outback is not susceptible to either of those things. I have no idea why either one of those memes continues to live on.

And besides, if I thought a brand-new car was so "fragile" that it required an oil change every week to keep the engine from grenading itself, I just wouldn't buy that car, and neither would any person with common sense. There's no way somebody actually thinks that's a normal way to maintain a regular car.

1†
Rucifel12011 WRX protuned @ 260whp/264wtq•

It was just a joke my dude.

9
Signs802005 Land Cruiser•

Subaru owners coping hard

1
Juicy_Jambon•

Do you find that the amsoil quart tends to help the most?

8
Matt_OPEC2018 Subie OB 2.5•

No the extra quart of warrens I add is the one that helps it from giving me the low oil light at 700 miles

7
xPalito2016 Nissan 370z Nismo tech, bmw e36 compact 318ti•

800 miles? How many miles do you do every day? For me that would be a change every month. Isn't that a bit too much?

5
ashowofhands15 Accord 6-6 coupe, 08 Outback, 97 Miata•

I think it's satire

I drive 800 miles in 8-10 days. I'd be changing my oil 3-4x a month

18
ZanicL3Scirocco GT•

you'd be paying more for oil than gas then

/s

7
ashowofhands15 Accord 6-6 coupe, 08 Outback, 97 Miata•

Hardly even /s. Most places in my area are around $80 for a full synthetic LOF.

Assuming an average 25mpg, gas would have to be $2.50/gal to go 800 miles on $80. And gas was under $2.50 for quite a while....go back about a year to when $2.30-2.40 range was common, and you would literally be paying more for oil than gas if you were doing a full synthetic LOF at a shop every 800 miles.

As a side note, having a long commute was a lot more palatable when gas was cheap. I've found like the one gas station on my route to work that is still under $3 and it's the only place I fill up any more

7
sentientdoganus•

Nice try OPEC

2
HarvickAudiFordfan2017 Audi A4 Quattro Premium Plus. Porsche/Ford fanatic•

I literally drive that much every month.

0†
Intense_introvertBMW driver that uses his turn signals/indicators•

Man. Sounds like Doug DeMuro needs to update his list to crown the Subies as the best cars to never own. As a former BMW V10 driver, the rod bearing issues (and for the BMW V8's from that era) are mostly overblown.

-5
ZanicL3Scirocco GT•

how much are we looking at repairs for the rod bearing v10 beemer?

3
Intense_introvertBMW driver that uses his turn signals/indicators•

Mine never broke and it was under an extended warranty either way. People who buy a car like this for "a great deal" and don't even have $500 saved-up for emergencies are the idiots who don't plan for things to go bad.

6
ashowofhands15 Accord 6-6 coupe, 08 Outback, 97 Miata•

What does the owner's manual/manufacturer maintenance schedule say?

11
TheHeadless1•

I do 7500 mile intervals and have engines well over 250000 miles with no issues. I use Mobile 1 but will switch to Lubrication Engineers on my next change.

10
iceagOP•

Sounds good. What car?

1
TheHeadless1•

Mazda 3 that I sold to my mechanic but I still keep tabs on because I was amazed by how well it works. My Nissan Navara is 150,000 with the diesel Mobil 1 as well.

1
eliterofler'11 Crz•

I change my oil when my car tells me to.

I usually get between 6000 to 8000 miles before it calls for an oil change depending on the weather conditions and city/highway split.

5
War-of-AnnihilationGLE 500e // Germany \\ Z1000 SX •

Once a year. Currently thats around 7500 miles.

Back when I was driving much more I did it every 25k miles in my e92 335d.

5
notrewoh•

Holy shit 25k? Did the engine last? What was the recommended interval?

2
Lemforder4 wheels and an engine•

It's common for European cars. I know it's not quite 25k miles, but my dad has an E39 530D that gets serviced every 15-20k when the service light on, and it's on the original turbo/engine at 270k miles.

4
Ewan_Whosearmy•

It's common for European diesel cars. Most gas cars recommend oil change after 15k or so (10,000 miles ish).

5
fghddj406 Coupe, C4 Coupe, A6•

My 2008 petrol Citroen has the same interval as my diesel Opel. Recommended 30k km (or 15k km severe) service interval. I change it once a year. When I drove it a little more that was about 20-25k km, now it's around 10k km. It's 11 years old now, no problems.

1
War-of-AnnihilationGLE 500e // Germany \\ Z1000 SX •

258k miles in 6 years. Car was stolen in 2014. The intervall is based on driving style. 20.000km - 40.000km (12.500 - 25.000 miles). Apparently my long distance driving was liked by the system despite driving quite fast.

1
LuckyCheetos•

i do it every 3000 miles personally, even tho it says it’ll do 10k i just personally can’t handle going past 3k especially with how hard i drive

4†
Automaticsareghey•

I do 10k with synthetics. Never had an issue, on anything.

For older flat tappet v8s I use rotella w some zddp additive

4
Darkfire757'18 Suburban Premier, '12 Q7, '11 Outback•

I do full synthetic at 5k miles. I could probably go to 7500, but I do a lot of city driving so one extra oil change per year is cheap insurance.

4
HarvickAudiFordfan2017 Audi A4 Quattro Premium Plus. Porsche/Ford fanatic•

10k miles on Castrol 5W30.

3
iceagOP•

If you could could you do a used engine oil analysis and post results here and to bobistheoilguy.com? That'd be useful info on 10k changes.

2
HarvickAudiFordfan2017 Audi A4 Quattro Premium Plus. Porsche/Ford fanatic•

I might do it down the road. My car has about 26k miles so it’s probably not going to much in terms of wear.

1
Red_Swingline_'10 Tacoma DCLB, '01 MR2 Spyder, '83 GMC C1500•

I usually change mine somewhere between 5 and 7k in my Tacoma.

The play cars get changed at the start of each summer, they don't see enough mileage to matter beyond that.

2
[deleted]•

The only engine oil report that matters is the one from your car. Driving pattern and environment differs significantly. I stick to manufacturer recommendation for warranty purposes.

2
0_1_1_2_3_51994 NSX (rebuilding engine) | 2003 540i•

I use Amsoil ZROD high zddp oil in the NSX and Amsoil states to change it every year or 5000 miles whichever comes first so that’s what I do.

In the 540i I use Mobil1 0W-40 and change every 5000. I get Blackstone reports after oil changes so if they indicate that I could go longer I’ll start stretching it out.

2
NovusJazz2011 WRX STI Hatch•

Every 3000 miles, full synthetic Motul oil. Most Subaru tuners recommend a 3000 mile interval, especially for tuned/modified. And my car has 129K miles, so better safe than sorry.

2
Cozmo85•

7500 on our outback. 10k on my gti, once a year on my miata

1
MOOVA'93 MR2 G-Limited•

Every 6 months or 7000kms with synthetic.

1
DartzIRL•

"Eventually".

It's supposed to be every 5k. Ends up being closer to 8.

Usually because the weather on the weekends is shite - or I'm tired or whatever.

The car still tolerates it. Being used daily is probably better for it than being pampered.

1
Bamfor07•

I follow the manufacturer recommendation so that’s every 12,500 miles or once a year.

1
Fekillix•

Follow the manual. My car is 18000 miles or two years. So for me that equals about 12000 miles per oil change.

1
iceagOP•

What car is that

1
Fekillix•

Most non-turbo petrol VWs. In my case a Mk5 Golf.

1
iceagOP•

Your oil change intervals are too high. VW recommends every 9300 miles or 12 months

1
Fekillix•

You need to look at the longlife service routine. It is a flexible indicator.

1
Kinky_Stara•

Manual says 7,500 miles or 7.5 months on conventional, but after a couple of analyses I do 9,000 miles / 12 months on synthetic.

1
Lordofwar137997312014 Camaro 2ss/RS•

Every 5000 with Mobil 1 for me.

1