***Spoilers*** Advances, None Miraculous. Where the movie may have fallen short of complete satisfaction.

Spoiler

I believe most fans would agree that the movie was very, very satisfying. However there are issues inherent with trying to tie up loose ends from a long-form meticulously-paced series in just two hours.

Posted Jun 2, 2019, 1:20 AM UTC

014
camipco•

To me, there was too much catharsis here. The series ends with Hearst getting away with murder because he's rich and powerful, which is realistic to life in general and the historical Hearst in particular. Watching him get beaten in the street and ending in jail was satisfying, sure, but for me it undermines the power of the original ending. Similarly, the movie was too generous to Al. Look, obviously we all love Al, he's one of the greatest characters of all time. But although there are moments of softening in the show, it still ends reminding us that he is a murderous pimp. Him leaving the Gem to Trixie and generally being nothing but decent all movie to me felt like it cheapened the character some by letting him off so easy.

I'm not saying I didn't cry. I totally cried.

8

Didn’t have any issues necessarily, and I enjoyed almost everything they did.

I would’ve liked to see more of Wu/Al and more EB, but that’s personal preference.

The only glaring question was how Doc had survived ten years and seemed to be completely cured of his ailments.

6
CorrectWolverineOP•

I saw a review that noted >!therewas not a lot of plotting and planning on the part of Team Al. It’s the movie form, where there wasn’t time to plot, plan and scheme I suppose.!<

Also Jane and Joanie. >!It was such dance, them coming together in the series. A nuanced back-and-forth as Jane would approach, feel vulnerable, then pull away harshly. But then to return. It was beautiful study of love and care and vulnerability.!<

In the movie it was kind of, >!”What the hell is going on Joanie?!?!?” And then, with very little discourse, it became “Kiss me, you fool!”!<

Again, I realize these are limitations of time. And they did a ridiculously good job compared to how GoT was ended. I am really appreciative of the movie.

5
CorrectWolverineOP•

!I believe they tried to leave open the possibility of a 2nd movie, potentially produced based on the reception of this movie.!<

!That made the resolution of this movie fairly soft. !<

!Is Al dead?!<

!Does it mean anything to incarcerate Hearst (again)?!<

!In addition we just get small tastes of many characters. Farnum, Nutall, even Dan.!<

What are issues, if any, that you may have seen in the movie?

3
usposeso•

Not taking away from the film, because I absolutely loved it. Much to be pleased and satisfied about. However, several issues I have include : A) the lack of Dan’s role. He’s virtually a non factor. Johnny was more of a focus than Dan was. B) it was never explained why Alma was back in town. C) Jane has apparently been gone quite a while but when Bullock sees her for the first time in the movie he simply asks her to be on the lookout for Charlie, ignoring the fact that he hasn’t seen her for how many years? D) It just would have been nice to get a better sense of Cy’s demise, as well as Richardson and Blazanov. E) Yes, Hearst being locked up in small town jail is hardly a resolution in the least. Also the two sheriffs from the neighboring towns backed down inexplicably easy, either as a simple matter of convenience to the plot or indicating Hearst uncharacteristically failed to think through his plan. Either way, that was a bit thin.

Additionally, Seth’s accent somehow gained a noticeably Southern twang that threw me off and just felt forced as hell.

7
TigsKC•

Minor sins, none mortal

9
Skip-7o-my-lou-•

Alma’s presence in town was specifically addressed-she said that she was there to check in on her bank, which was expanding to new locations.

8
usposeso•

Missed that.

5
ca14129•

Of all thing the a point was most glaring to me; Dan was visible a bit but silent for the most part... ?

7
usposeso•

Right? Demoted from henchmen to mute errand boy by the writers.

5
bigblueballz77•

I was surprised I didn't see more comments regarding his accent. I noticed it immediately and it felt so ridiculous. I was racking my brain trying to figure out if it could possibly be a thing over time, but they are in South Dakota.

The Jane thing didn't make a lot of sense, either, and was forcibly tried. I wasn't mad about the characters that died in real life because they really had no time to address those stories. I think a lot of Deadwood fans have rose colored glasses because of their love of this universe and are disregarding the quality of this as a movie.

5
MadRiverSJ•

What was the Jane thing that didn’t make sense?

The movie is certainly flawed. But quite frankly I’m surprised I found the movie as satisfying as I did considering the amount of work the movie had to do.

1
toodrunktoocare•

My only real complaint is the pacing of the third act. The end of the movie took me by surprise, not in the events which occurred but the speed of their arrival. It was all so quickly wrapped up which I think leads to the sense that there are a lot of loose ends. From the wedding of Sol and Trixie it rushed to get to some kind of resolution, nothing was explained and nothing was expanded on. It was a bit like "and they all lived happily every after".

That's not to say I didn't love the movie, it was great to go back to Deadwood and the movie was far better than I hoped. But I don't think there will be a second movie. I think we got both of the movies in this sitting and that's why it felt rushed at times. Between the scheduling difficulties and Milch's illness I can't see it happening.

4
CorrectWolverineOP•

!I kind of see this when Hearst runs in with two marshals to try and arrest Bullock. The marshals came a long way to overstep their jurisdictions, only to say nothing when Bullock confronts them. It was almost, “You’re arresting me? On the contrary, I am arresting you. And the other marshals just stand there.!<

!Also, if Bullock was going to arrest Hearst, I would have thought he would have been a little more proactive about it, rather than waiting for Hearst to come to him.!<

Again, was incredibly happy overall.

6