Exchange Online Plan 1 user can access SharePoint

I have a test user and assigned them Exchange Online Plan 1.

I have Shared him a SharePoint online site, my expectation is he wont be able to access the site because he is lacking SharePoint license/feature.

But lo and behold, he can access it and document uploaded(Excel Online) is viewable and editable on this test account.

Is this something we expect to happen?

​

Thank you

Posted Jun 3, 2019, 7:49 AM UTC

411
MuchStormThenWish•

We had the same 'experience' last year when all users where able to use SharePoint functionality in Office 365 Groups and Microsoft Teams, and OneDrive For Business to mount these SP sites to their local computers. Even though we had disabled SharePoint and OneDrive licenses on all users.

Microsoft Support told us it was 'working as intended' and that it was 'known behaviour'. A quick search on various forums, reddit and technet revealed that this was not true. Microsofts reply to this was a link to an old forum post from 2016 where some random developer wrote that this was a side-effect from the implementation of 'guest' access to SharePoint, this was their definition of 'known behaviour'. Meaning that every time a user created a Team or Group it would be assigned a SharePoint site and every member would get a SharePoint license.

Their support offered a solution where they could disable SharePoint functionality back-end for ALL of our tenant. This would mean that NOONE could use sharepoint, not even as guests in a sharepoint site they were invited to from outside of our organisation, and it would NOT be possible to enable this on our tenant again ever.

So, now we have SharePoint ....

4
wataah3•

SharePoint Online looks for users in Azure AD and uses its own user profile store, so regardless of if you assign a license or not in the Office 365 admin center, the user can still be added as an "internal user" to a SharePoint site. So yes, what you are experiencing is expected to happen.

The user will not see ODFB or SP in their app launcher, but they can still use SP in [almost] the same way as a user with the licensed applied. Also, they will not be able to access their ODFB, but they can access other users' ODFB is content is shared with them.

So far the only downside I've noticed for an unlicensed internal user using SP, other than not being able to access the SP dashboard page, is that they cannot 'follow' sites. This becomes a problem when using the Copy To and Move To functionality. The site they want to copy/move files to may not be in the suggested list, and they wouldn't be able to manually add the site to the 'followed' list, so they wouldn't be able to use the built-in copy/move functionality.

3
MyBooleanOP•

Thanks!

​

Looks like what can I do prevent users from accessing the Office online in the Shared Sites is to enable the feature to Open Documents in Client Applications by Default.

1
trevorishere•

You still need to license them for SPO, though.

1
MyBooleanOP•

Nope. As long as they have the permissions they can access the site. And edit the document as well even without the office online license

1
trevorishere•

Wasn't my point. If they use content on SPO you must license them if they are users in your tenant.

1
Willz12h•

That user will be accessing SharePoint under the "guest" licenses.

​

For Every 1 license of SharePoint you have, you get 5 Guest Licenses. The guest license will let them view and not edit documents etc (or at least it shouldn't let you)

-1
lolidkwtfrofl•

In my experience, that never works. If you know the url, it won't matter what license you have.

2
MyBooleanOP•

That user is a user of the same tenant

1
Willz12h•

Yeah it still applies to internal and external users.

​

Their is a document online about this somewhere. Talks about the ratio and weather you should license internal users or not based on their use of sharepoint.

-1
trevorishere•

This is not correct. SPO doesn't do licence enforcement. Unlicensed users in your tenant using SPO is a violation of the ToS and you could have issues if there is a license audit. They are not guest users.

1