Help with block touch rule

Blocker goes up to defend an overpass (really an intentional overpass), and the setter is swinging/dinking, setter whiffs, blocker contacts ball, ball comes down on blockers side, blocker passes. Is this a double contact?

FWIW (I don't think it should) this is BB sand 4s

Posted Jun 4, 2019, 1:47 PM UTC

332
MiltownKBs6'2" Baller•

As long as any part of the ball entered the vertical plane of the net, it is a legal block and the blocker can hit it back up.

Was the ball in the plane of the net?

What call was made during your game?

3
tarbender2OP•

He definitely called a double contact. There was no question about interference. He is the type that would be quick to call an interference so I was playing it conservatively.

2
MiltownKBs6'2" Baller•

Yeah, that's not a double contact as you describe it.

2
Beardoom•

Yeah, this seems like it should be more a question of whether or not the block was a legal block more than a double contact.

3
MiltownKBs6'2" Baller•

I suspect that there is something else going on here. I dont think we have a complete picture. OP says the ref knows his stuff. So if we go by that, then this is an easy call as described by OP. Ref should not get that wrong.

1
Beardoom•

Did you contact the ball while the ball was over the net or on your side?

2
FredB856'2'' 189cm OH•

Actually the rule is that part of your body has to be over the top of the net. The ball can actually be below the net. Here is the definition from the official FIVB rulebook (emphasis mine):

14.1.1 Blocking is the action of players close to the net to intercept the ball coming from the opponent by reaching higher than the top of the net, regardless of the height of the ball contact. Only front-row players are permitted to complete a block, but at the moment of the contact with the ball, a part of the body must be higher than the top of the net.

http://www.fivb.org/EN/Refereeing-Rules/documents/FIVB-Volleyball_Rules_2017-2020-EN-v06.pdf

1
CanadianGandalf•

Let's consider an extreme case... (didn't happen, but theoretically could...)

Say I'm a middle and am super late, so I go up in place. Attacker's insane cut catches me in the foot while I'm mid-air, blocking, hands over the net. Ball is up though- am I legal to make the next touch?

The rule seems to say yes, but that seems quite silly.

2
Beardoom•

Well, I’m saying more for the sake of the overpass/attempt-but-fail-to-attack.

If the ball is still on their side of the net and is unsuccessfully attacked, I would think that’s the first point of criticism. I’m actually a little unclear on the rules for whether or not an unsuccessful attack on a ball (the setter’s whiff) plays into the interpretation. If it’s settable and the ball is blocked before a successful set, that’s where I’d initially think that it’s an illegal block.

1
MiltownKBs6'2" Baller•

That wording is there because you can reach over on anything that is an atrack hit. An attack hit being any ball, if untouched, would land in your court.

If the second contact, intended to be an attack, were missed, then you cannot block it unless the first contact were also considered an attack hit. Meaning it would fly into your court if untouched. You just cant reach over on something that is essentially an attack fake.

2
tarbender2OP•

If the ball is blocked on their side of the net its likely interference or a kill. Its nearly impossible to bring a block back on the blockers side. There was no question about interference - he thought I was too far off!

1
Beardoom•

Yeah, this is only a question of interference to me.

1
tarbender2OP•

I definitely had my hands over the net. I thought it didn't matter where the ball contacts me in relation to net height? I asked him if he called it because he thought I was under the net, but all he said is I was off net (but I didn't want to break the plane and interfere with his possible set or possible touch off the net). If it was the 3rd hit I'm throwing it back in his face no questions asked. The guy knows his stuff and is a good player, so I grilled him because I honestly wasn't completely sure what he was calling.

1
Beardoom•

I’m talking more in regards to where it was in terms of sides, not height. If he doesn’t have an opportunity to set a settable ball, it’s probably not a legal block. If it’s an overpass and the ball has broken the vertical plane: no question, it’s legal.

2
MiltownKBs6'2" Baller•

Remember, ANY ball that, if untouched, were to land in your court, that would be an attack hit. You can block it, even if it was the first contact and the setter may theoretically be able to touch that ball.

1
Beardoom•

Most definitely. But it’s hard without a ref to judge the path of the ball. I think this is a player vs. player call? In no way can I see a double called in what’s been described, though.

2
tarbender2OP•

It was not close to interfence. Really it was the opposite accusation - that I was too far off and I could have passed it with my hands, or at least that was my perception of what his argument was. In retrospect, his overs on two were getting roofed and maybe he was just trying something. I believe he refs some high school level stuff so I wanted to be sure.

1
Willemvk•

The interpretation of 'close to the net' is the real question.

As a ref I interpret this rule as follows. If a player can touch the net, he is close enough to block.

1
Beardoom•

So you made contact with the ball on your side? But your hands were penetrating?

EDIT: I guess it doesn’t matter. It’s just not a double contact. Especially in any BB sand ball. Where do you play?

1
ForcefulPayload•

Anytime the ball enters the plane from the opponents side, it’s considered an attack. All blocking motions and block touch rules become applicable.

2
FredB856'2'' 189cm OH•

No, providing the blocker made contact with the ball when any part of their body was over the net (this is what constitutes a block). In that case, what you've described is a legal block and pass.

2