Question from A British Con

I'll preface this by saying I wasn't alive when the UK had the death penalty and have always been on the fence about its viability as a punishment.

From both a legal/societal and religious viewpoint, what are the arguments for still having it/reintroducing? (No requirement to not have it after Brexit)

Posted Jun 6, 2019, 8:52 AM UTC

02
CapitalGGeekVery Right•

Im ny mind there are three requirements for punishing criminals.

RESTITUTION-The victim must be made whole/have property restored

RETRIBUTION-Society must feel like the criminal was punished

RECIDIVISM-The punishment should deter others from the same crime

Executing murderers is the only possible punishment that comes close to meeting any of these. Especially in a society where a 'life' sentence means parole in 20 years.

1
thatrightwingerFeatured on IOTW•

There are a couple reasons:

  1. It makes an example by society that there are crimes so bad, that there is no solution to end the life of the criminal. It's a warning to all that, though you might be imprisoned for most crimes, there are a few where the only suitable consequence is forfeit of life. Think hard before going through with these crimes.

  2. It makes sure that a select handful of people are completely removed from society and will never threaten humanity. These few are such a danger that we can't risk escape or even future release by a more lax society in the future.

Check out this article for more information.

0