morepowertoshields•

14yr old kid walks into recruitment tent.

Recruiter: "Age?"

Kid: "Uh, 20"

30
[deleted]•

[deleted]

22
LucettiOP•

Gotta put dem rocks in your pocket to make weight

8
bassxtrees•

I was told that if you were taller than a musket, you could fight.

3
Myflyisbreezy•

TIL 90% of civil war soldiers were born Jan 1, 1800

2
morepowertoshields•

That would make them in their 60's

0
Laughatme13•

Don’t tell tinder

26
LucettiOP•

It’s weird to think that physically speaking at least, an average modern college athlete would have been like a god of war in comparison.

The average weight of a United States marine in present time is 180 lbs.

20
Hyperdrunk•

The average NFL Rookie is 6'3" 247lbs.

Of course that includes the behemoth 300+ pound linemen, so the median is probably closer to 6'1" 225ish? Just a guess.

16
LucettiOP•

My hockey team is the capitals. Our captain is 6’3 and 240 lbs.

We are talking about a guy who is 7 full inches taller than the AVERAGE civil war soldier and with likely literally three or four times the muscle mass. He’s almost 100 lbs heavier.

It’s some David vs Goliath stuff.

10
bassxtrees•

Back then id rather be on the small side. With the firearms the way they were, being big just made you more likely to be hit. That, and a large portion died of infection, so just getting clipped by a round is rather lethal.

1
TacTurtle•

The reason people are taller and heavier is in large part because we are much, much healthier today. Add in a dash of germ theory, and a bunch of the shit (literally) you were most likely to die from instead of battles like tuberculosis and dysentery (insert Oregon Trails reference) become almost non-issues

5
Praise_Sithis•

It's harder to get shot if you're smaller.

Also I notice you didn't include a measurement for their massive balls

6
LucettiOP•

Being smaller has its advantages for sure. I’m watching the Ken Burns civil war documentary on Netflix which is what motivated this post, but before this I watched the Vietnam war one and they had a south Vietnamese guy who didnt like his American military advisor standing near him because he was large and Caucasian and thus a target for snipers and he didn’t want to be hit by a round intended for him.

9
Reoh•

Someone's gotta be in the front rank.

1
Fourlojko•

Not to mention riding horses faster.

1
aerossignol•

Significantly less at being hit with a Canon ball

4
Merobidan•

Not a lot of fat people back then ...

4
FireLordObamaOG•

Think of how much more difficult it was to build muscle in those days. Not to mention that genetically we’re getting taller as a species.

2
bolanrox•

not so much build but maintain it.

3
leobru•

And his rations were a mere fraction of what today's soldiers have to eat to be able to carry around an extra 50 pounds of flesh. How practical!

2
Flaxmoore2•

Wonder how much of this is because of the widespread malnutrition and parasitic infection in the South of that era. It would be interesting to see if there were a difference between Georgia, where it never really gets cold enough to kill hookworm in the soil, for example, with Maine where it does.

1
smagmite•

That's kinda healthy.

0†
LucettiOP•

It’s about 4 lbs inside the “healthy weight” spread for that height, so borderline underweight. And ideally your soldiers are robust and more muscled and thus heavier compared to the general population as well as for their height.

My source says 139-169 lbs is healthy for a 5’8 man.

The average civil war soldier was in the bottom 15% of that healthy weight bracket.

And keep in mind thats the average, so it’s likely 20-40% would be considered underweight for their height since the average is only 4 lbs over the threshold.

If you took the weight of an average marine today (180) and converted it into a height where you’re in the bottom 15% of the healthy spectrum if you weight that much (180) the average height would be like 6’6 or something.

7
smagmite•

Hence the "kinda". The average American nowadays is unfit for duty.

4
LucettiOP•

We aren’t comparing anything to the average American though. We are comparing civil war soldiers to marines in my example, using a graph I found on a health website about a range of healthy weights for height.

The average American doesn’t factor into any of our measures.

For the record, I’m an American of a healthy weight for my height according to the graph and I have 4 inches and 40 lbs on the average civil war soldier. That’s why the stat was interesting to me, because I’m a random American who is physically larger and presumably stronger than soldiers I read about or see on the history channel.

Generally people think large and strong, or at least “above average in physical fitness” when they think of soldiers, but in the civil war they were quite undersized, especially in weight.

The average modern marine’s loadout weighs almost as much as the average civil war soldier and that is interesting to me.

0
smagmite•

I believe the statistics do indicate that Americans are getting taller.

1
leobru•

A much more important question is, what was their body fat percentage. With that height/weight ratio, at 10-12% body fat the amount of muscle would have been impressive.

0