[IC] Update on SLA/Hotswap dactyl cases

Interest Check

I just wanted to follow up on the interest check that I started a month or two ago. Everything is progressing nicely and I should be ready to start printing orders in the next week or two. I will probably start a google form within the next week for people to place orders. Order fulfillment preference will be given based on position on interest check. Everyone who joined the IC should be receiving something similar to this post in their emails. For those who would like to sign up on the IC wait list you can do that here: https://forms.gle/cBpbvUjFeR12hnCb7.

​

This is a rendering of my initial plan for the case: https://imgur.com/Dcg6BMm. I will be making a few changes to the model but the concept should remain just about the same. I will try and build in a latch to hold the kalih socket in the cutout. Hot glue will still probably be a good idea.

Printer decision:

I plan to purchase a SLA (technically LED) printer this week. I am going with the phrozen shuffle XL .  My budget was several times the price of this printer but this fills my needs: large print size to print 2 top cases together, open systems that allow using materials from any manufacturer, dual linear bearing Z axis, LED technology to allow for quick printing, US based hardware support (they are based overseas but I will be purchasing through a US dealer I meet at a 3D printing conference). While I looked at printers like the form2/form3 the cost of consumables is significantly higher (2-3x the cost per liter for consumables and resin of the phrozen).  The increase in print quality for something like the form3 is little to non for this use case. I do not believe it justifies the cost increase that would be required.

​

Colors/resin

I will try and offer the case in two colors but generally speaking higher performance resins are not available in a wide variety of colors (generally its 1 color).  The resin will have properties similar to either nylon or abs(fairly robust and resistant to cracking(although still plastic so some care needs to be taken)) and will be UV stable (ie it wont be impacted by light as some resin can be). Black will for sure be an option.

​

Cost:

I am on track right now with my ~180 price point (this is about 1/3 -1/4 the price of a 3D printing service like shapeways or materialise).  The biggest impact on price will be with resin selection I go with. So the price may change but should not be anything significant.

​

Samples/timeline:

I will try and post samples in a week or two.  I anticipate I am about 2-3 weeks from being able ship.  I am not to sure what the output will be yet.  I am hoping to be able to ship to everyone within 2 months. 

​

Potentially Cheaper hot swap option:

- I have been able to print a dactyl with the Kalih Sockets using FDM.  The sockets sit on top  instead of on the bottom of the case.  This solves the issue of FDM not having the ability to print the kalih socket cutout upside down.   I do not like this solution as it requires hot glue (or other adhesive) to hold the kalih sockets in place when removing switches.  The way I am implementing this with SLA is the kalih sockets will sit between a piece of plastic and the switch.  Hot glue may still be needed to hold them in place however it wont be used to prevent the sockets from coming out when removing a switch.  This solution is also a bit harder to wire as the kalih socket solder points are buried under plastic.  The simple solution I have come up with is to solder a piece of copper wire onto the kalih socket before inserting into the keyboard.  It is also fairly brutal to remove the supports and print time is ~50% higher.  Due to this the price is probably going to be about 50-60% higher compared to the normal case.  IE ~120 for a dactyl case.

​

Gallery of FDM hotswap samples : https://imgur.com/a/6cyzwG1

Edit: although I don't specifically mention it the manuform will also be an option for this.

Posted Jun 11, 2019, 11:42 AM UTC · edited

2114
mechkbotMODConfirming trades since 2015•
  • Username: u/crystalhand
  • Join date: 2014-03-22 01:38:47
  • Link karma: 590
  • Comment karma: 1281
  • Reputation: 18 trade(s)

^^This ^^information ^^does ^^not ^^guarantee ^^a ^^successful ^^swap. ^^It ^^is ^^being ^^provided ^^to ^^help ^^potential ^^trade ^^partners ^^have ^^more ^^immediate ^^background ^^information ^^about ^^with ^^whom ^^they ^^are ^^swapping. ^^Please ^^be ^^sure ^^to ^^familiarize ^^yourself ^^with ^^the ^^RULES ^^and ^^other ^^guides ^^on ^^the ^^WIKI

1
cardiactuna•

Have you looked into Siraya Blu resin? It’s supposed to take alcohol dyes pretty well and be super resilient without being crazy expensive. I have a photon, so subscribed for more updates :)

1
crystalhandOP•

Ill check them out. It looks like they come in a decent array of colors. I am hesitant to use dyes of my own as it can get complicated. The chance of replicating a previously made color is almost non existent at the hobbyist level. So you would need to make extra for each order or keep a large inventory of pre made colors. Having a mis matched left and right hand would not be fun :p. I would consider dying for personal projects however.

1
cardiactuna•

Typically you can get relatively repeatable results if you dye by volume, and you measure the dye consistently. I make artisan caps and dye very small amounts of two part resin consistently. But yeah I see your point. Is this your first resin printer? If so, let me know if you have any questions.

1
chexxor•

I don't understand how the Kailh sockets stay in place in either of the designs you've showed here. The cheaper option you've showed real photos -- do these require hot glue? And the option which requires the new printer you are buying, does this design also require hot glue? I ask this purely in a non-vested curiosity and interest. I'm interested in seeing how you'd make it not require hot glue.

1
crystalhandOP•

Yes I am anticipating hot glue being used for both designs which I mentioned in my post. I think hot glue is an amazing tool. Its cheap, versatile, and it holds well. It is also fairly easy to remove as long as you dont go crazy. Hot glue is not meant to do all of the work in holding the socket in place. It is intended to support the other 5 3D printed sides holding the socket in place

​

​

The FDM solution:

 I do not like this solution as it requires hot glue (or other adhesive) to hold the kalih sockets in place when removing switches.

The hot glue in this situation is not just being used to hold the socket in place but to counteract the pulling force of removing a switch(you could argue that something similar would happen with the SLA design when installing switches. You would essentially be pushing against the kalih socket however its failure condition is a lot easier to deal with. In this situation the socket would be pushed in a few mm instead of pulling it out and potentially damaging the wiring). I do not think this is an ideal solution but there is no way to avoid this (that I have found) without something either extremely complicated and or impossible to print.

​

​

I will try and build in a latch to hold the kalih socket in the cutout. Hot glue will still probably be a good idea.

This will probably be some type of angled one way thing. one side would be sloped and the other would be a straight edge. I dont know about the viability of this yet.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
fratdaddyZC•

A bit late to the party, but I might have interest in new material for the dactyl. I'll be keeping an eye out on your threads and sample pictures

1
crystalhandOP•

Sounds good. Pictures should be coming soon within a week. The new printer was just delivered today :)

2
Necrolytus•

Have one of your earlier pieces, and thinking of buying more! Have you thought of introducing a lower profile design that can eliminate the need for an additional wrist rest? Can this be done with your new printers now?

1
crystalhandOP•

So this is something that could be played with a bit. You could lower the model in the Z direction (which is what I think you mean). The one caveat of that is the curves would need to change. everything is dictated by the lowest keys height. As long as that has room to be wired everything is good. The lowest key are the middle row columns 1, 3,4 (counting the outside pinkie column as 1).

I am also playing with the dimensions of the bottom case a bit with the new printer. I plan on shaving a few mm by making the bottom of the case a bit thinner.

PS: make sure to mention in your order that you are a repeat customer I give discounts for this.

1
Necrolytus•

Would you give discounts if ordered through Oh Keycaps? I see your latest form is that you don't offer any more prebuilt/assembly right, so Oh Keycaps is the best way for this now?

1
Necrolytus•

Got it, yeah I see. The other sacrifice might be to rotate a little, but bad for wrist pronation. Cool just curious and thanks for the multi-line discount!

1
lisinges•

I'm interested and have filled the form. Eager to see pics of the finished case.

1
crystalhandOP•

Hopefully I will have some pictures next weekend. Currently fine tuning the printing profiles of one of the resins. After that is done I will be able to do a full sized print.

1
lisinges•

Great to hear you are making progress. Looking forward to it!

1
spiderman1993•

Do you have the .stl of the dactyl with the hot swappable keys up somewhere? It's open source so shouldn't it be released?

1
crystalhandOP•

So there is lots of confusion among people about how the license for this works. This license only requires the source code to be shared when it is accessible over a network/internet (ie an online app/customizer tool in this case). Feel to read the full license located here: https://github.com/adereth/dactyl-keyboard/blob/master/LICENSE.

The code will at some point be posted online as my past changes have been. However I have a ton of time and money tied into this project . I don't think it is unreasonable for me to recoup the money and pay myself a dollar or two an hour for the time invested before sharing.

If people are working on the clojure code and have any questions about how I made changes please ask. I am totally willing to answer them and chances are you will also get code segments out of me.

​

​

Edit: grahmar is hard

2