I will most certainly miss the upcoming AMA, so please someone ask this
"How effective do you feel the reporting system is in Heroes of the Storm?"
Posted Jun 11, 2019, 9:03 PM UTC
"How effective do you feel the reporting system is in Heroes of the Storm?"
Posted Jun 11, 2019, 9:03 PM UTC
I can swear I've answered this question for a 1000th time (the answer was the saddest face of course) and nothing changes, and nothing will change in the foreseeable future - maybe remove this question from the list?
I stopped answering it.
If anyone from Blizzard sees this... honestly, it's such a nuanced question, to have to answer it with emojis is an insult. You're asking the question because you know what the answer is. Personally, and truly, how can I know how effective the reporting system is? I don't have the data you have. Is it only perceptions you're looking for? I shouldn't get ahead of myself; I understand the value of perception based questions and have used such data for technical information as well, so maybe there's value to Blizzard... but I don't feel like anything has changed. The conversation that needs to be had, I don't think you can explore through simple survey.
Frankly, they should consider having an AMA specifically concerning the reporting system. Or maybe it would just be a bunch of complaining and it would be beyond derivative to have it only be about that subject. I don't know. I just report people when I see extreme offenses, and I make sure to include details when I do so. But I feel like I'm bound to see jerks no matter what, given the general territory of MOBAs. And my frequency of playing isn't consistent either, so it's implicitly a little more difficult to objectively gauge what I think about the reporting system. I genuinely don't know what to think about it, although I suppose lean more to the negative at the end of it all.
If I were a part of HotS team I would run the opposite of AMA (ie question the community directly) - but only when the timeline for the reporting improvements is somewhat clear. AFAIK that’s not how Blizz usually do, but that may serve as another confirmation they are not planning any improvement about it in the foreseeable future
Perceptions.
My perception is that I have no feedback whatsoever on my reports, so I vote 1 star every time it comes up.
The thing is, there shouldn't really be a reporting system at all. User reports are unreliable and are there only to make you feel better, just as this question is (it may have worked for a while on some people when it was new, like, 2 years ago).
There are 3 types of actionable misconducts in a MOBA:
According to Blizzard, (1) and (3) are already acted upon. People have been banned for insults. Disconnects/leavers get rank point deductions.
(2) has the problem that being mismatched MMR-wise, being thrown in an unfavorable game, being in over your head, can look the same as feeding or losing intentionally. Except when you are running into the opponent team over and over, resulting in 15+ deaths, it is hard to decide if you are feeding intentionally.
The situation is and always was very simple for Blizzard. Watching games and deciding on a case-by-case basis whether one game was indeed a violation of conduct rules or only incompetence is not a good use of their staff's time. They won't hire people for this, and I know of no MOBA that does. On the other hand, user reports are based on all sorts of things, Murky picks, Falstad picking the wrong ult, Greymane being afraid to jump in, Abathur being AFK. Not picking a healer in Ranked.
To make reports work, they need AI to recognize true feeders from analyzing their stats, without people looking at the games and without relying on reports (at all). And they will still not have a simple court case if one of these people is a whale who has spent 1000$ on their account and sues them afterwards.
So they do what they can and no more. And this will not change now, of all times. The report system is one area where expectations were always very close to unrealistic, where Blizzard was expected to solve an unsolvable problem. And of course they can't admit this. They are always trying, always improving.
And at least LoL has exactly the same problems. In winter 2018, I tried playing LoL again. I got immediately insulted, people were trying to take my lane, because they wanted to be mid, even if I called it in Blind Pick. It was still much worse than your average HotS game. I don't know LoL any other way, though, and this is something everyone can deal with in the end. It's just the irrational expectation that Blizz can make this go away in their game that irks me.
When is it?
Asking the real question!
I would like to hope for an answer, but something tells me this question will be skipped. Much like any question regarding the smurfing issue happening in SL.
I’m afraid so too but worth a try I guess? At least I’m not sure I’ve ever seen it asked
On a scale of 1 to 5.
I think they dont want the system to work because they need more players. Maybe put some effort on marketing hots instead of putting all the money on hearthstone, so we get a bigger playerbase and they start to punish those specimens. My thoughts
Edit: I know North America and Korea has many players but South America is overpopuled by league of legends players, some by choice, some by potato computers and a lot dont even know what the hell is Heroes of The Storm
I think they dont want the system to work because they need more players
Madness.
If you let bad apples roam free, only the bad apples will stick around.
:\