The Yellow Turbans are in a weird spot.
I have really mixed feelings about the Yellow Turbans.
I like that they have different units and not just generic militia, medium, heavy units. Many named units with special abilities and special roles on the battlefield. We need more of that for the other factions, based on location or faction.
I like that they do many things different even though they are not better in itself most of the time. For example I like that they have a bit different buildings but sadly they have even less branching then the main factions. I like that they have different generals but sadly the stats and color coding don't make any sense for them. I like that the rech tree is different even though it's not better than the original one.
The problem is they lack behind in some very important points. The best parts of the game are the deep politics and all the characters. Sadly you can't really be part of that as the Yellow Turbans. Politics are very limited until late in the game, you have only very few unique characters that you can possibly get, only 3 general classes and no family tree to manage.
On one side the campaign feels fresh because you finally have different units, buildings and techs but on the other side many things are stripped from it and it feels like 3K light.
Maybe they should change some things about politics and characters for them.
First tidy up the character classes. Why does the healer need instinct (except for He Yi)? Why do the unit colors not fit the general colors? Maybe add a fourth class.
Then add something similar to the family tree. Let the player manage the hierachy in the rebellion, let us decide who is the "heir" or vice-leader or however you want to call it. Maybe add something like "sworn brothers" instead of the family tree. Maybe even add babies, no need for official marriage to add babies.
Enable the possibility to recruit the other characters. Not like the other factions and all the time but maybe with special events under specific circumstances unique characters can convert to the Yellow Turbans and change their general type accordingly. Not that it should be very often but that you have like one or two characters covert in a Yellow Turban campaign. Just give the small possibility and not lock out the Yellow Turbans completly.
Add a second way to unlock diplomacy or replace the way you unlock diplomacy. There should be a way to unlock diplomacy with near factions earlier. Since you are at war with most near factions anyway you could add a mechanic like "recognition" or "acceptance". They are at war with you, naturally, you are just a pesky rebellion after all, no way these noble lords would engage in diplomacy with you. Right now you have to grow and suddenly all of China recognises you as a legitimate faction simultaneously, it would make sense that some factions do that earlier. I suggest that you can't negotiate for just "peace" with factions that don't recognise you politically, you have to negotiate for "recognition and peace". This "recognition" unlocks diplomacy with that faction and would make "recognition" from factions friendly to them easier. It would make sense because at the moment they sign peace they admit that you aren't just a rebellion to which the only answer is war, they admit that you are a thing politically. It would not only give you a way to engage in meaningful diplomacy with some factions earlier in the game but also give you a better sense of progession because right now you only stack points until you unlock diplomacy, before that you just defend against whoever is attacking you and you attack whoever is next to you. If you play other factions it matters what the AI does and who wins even if you are not directly involved, as the Yellow Turbans it doesn't really matter since basically everybody is the enemy. Convincing one lord after the other that you are actually a legit thing would give you an incentive to find a balance between war and diplomacy, right now it's either total war or you hide in the south.
What do you guys think about the Yellow Turbans and my suggestions? What would your suggestion be to make them better?
Posted Jun 13, 2019, 10:50 AM UTC
I agree that there is something off about the YT factions. I enjoyed my 2 He Yi campaigns (recruited Huan Shao early on etc.) but they do feel like a more barebones version of the default factions. I used to really love the Ikko Ikki faction in Shogun 2, and I feel like some of the things which are missing in 3K, namely Religion and Agents (divisive topic I know..) are costing the YT factions a lot of their potential depth.
Edit: I forgot to mention.. I got the YT DLC as FLC because I bought the game early.. so I'm not too irked by it.. but if I had had to pay money for it, I would review it negatively for sure.