Redditch current circlejerking about Hong Kong's protests and police violence is rooted in imperialism and racism

Don't get me wrong, China is an authoritarian state, the violence against the population is unacceptable and they deserve the right to determine themselves freely.

But reddit's circlejerking about it seems incredibly hypocritical when similar violences happen in western countries and it's barely news or somehow justified.

In France, since last winter, people have been protesting every Saturday because of unjust economic policies targeting lower class people and favouring rich people and powerful corporations. Dozens of people lost eyes, hands, suffered injuries. Hundreds were injured or straight up gratuitously beat up, regardless of gender or age. An old lady looking at the protest in the street from her window received an anti-protest grenade and died.

For years it's been routine for journalists covering protests to be equipped with protection and clear identification but even that isn't enough to prevent some from being shoved around by the police. Some militant journalist are explicitly targeted, arrested by the police, their expensive equipment confiscated, their phone containing information protected by their journalist status handed off to prosecutors to be exploited.

Fucking high schoolers protesting asked to stay on their knees, hands behind their head, some facing walls, while the police taunts them: https://youtube.com/watch?v=TnOwLMdYBDs

Criminalisation of unionised action and anti terror laws used to prevent climate activists from organising.

It barely makes international news and the few Reddit threads about it are full of "wow the French sure know how to protest", guillotine jokes and both sidism.

Meanwhile someone in Hong Kong is injured by the police in a protest and their photo is on top of Reddit in an hour, thousands of comments about how Chinese Government = Bad. Another thread about journalists in protective gear. Another about people being sprayed. Shit all that happens weekly in France.

It's much easier for people to call out China or African or Middle Eastern countries because they're foreign and it's much easier seeing when they do bad things. When our own governments do it on our own population there's always a justification. After all we're the enlightened western world, beacon of freedom, there must be a good reason we brutalize our own population. But those other countries aren't as liberated, so there are no excuses, right? We really ought to help them, export our "freedom" because we're doing so much better here.

Imperialist and racist hypocrites.

Posted Jun 14, 2019, 11:31 AM UTC

812
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
lilganj710•

This is true. Doesn’t mean that China shouldn’t be condemned for doing what western countries do to its protesters

3
BreakTheLoopOP•

Clearly it should be condemned yes, I just wish there were as many threads about violence in western countries and that people called out the similar authoritarian mechanisms.

4
lilganj710•

Fr tho. I’m tired of seeing cop dog pictures on the front page. Cops use dogs to nullify the 4th amendment, as a fucking dog sitting down somehow gives them probable cause for a search. They also release dogs onto suspects, inflicting painful punishment onto those who have gone through no due process. Bye bye 5th amendment. This is also a violation of the 8th amendment - getting mauled by a dog is definitely cruel and unusual.

And shit, cops even violate the 1st amendment by arresting people for “disorderly conduct” which can mean as little as swearing or raising tone of voice. Cops often yell obscenities, but if you try and press charges on then you’ll be met with a fat Blue Wall of Silence

Then federal law enforcement violates more rights. The 10th amendment grants all powers not explicitly given to the federal government in the Constitution to the states. Meaning that states should have authority in drug enforcement. Yet in states where weed is legal, class traitors from the DEA are steady seizing weed and raiding dispensaries. RIP 10th amendment. The supposed justification for this is Congress’s power to regulate interstate commerce. But trying to use a right granted in the Constitution to deny another right retained by the people is a violation of the 9th amendment. Congress has the right to regulate interstate commerce, but those living in states that have legalized weed have the right to sell and use weed. Yet legal grow ops are routinely suppressed by the government. Bye bye 9th amendment.

The police state in America has obliterated nearly all civil liberties, and no one talks about it. It’s fucked

1
GodKingMussolini•

Naw everyone should be condemned for it

1
lilganj710•

That’s basically what i said lol

1
GodKingMussolini•

Yep

1
BreakTheLoopOP•

Of course I fuck up the title. Well then, keeping it like that.

2
MC_gnome•

I come from the town of Redditch, Worcestershire in England and I thought I found a local on here. Never mind.

2
trashmemes22•

Just searching up Redditch on reddit is my favourite thing seeing all the stupid spelling mistakes

1
UnpopularOpinionModsMOD•

Is this a Popular or Unpopular opinion? Please reply to this comment with either 'popular' or 'unpopular'

#Please do not vote on your own submissions.

1
alecd93•

I think... This is a popular opinion.

1
BGgungame•

In France, since last winter, people have been protesting every Saturday because of unjust economic policies targeting lower class people and favouring rich people and powerful corporations. Dozens of people lost eyes, hands, suffered injuries. Hundreds were injured or straight up gratuitously beat up, regardless of gender or age.

Well it's not like the yellow vests didn't spend a good portion of their "protest" vandalizing Paris, breaking windows and burning property. They weren't exactly peaceful protesters.

0