(SERIOUS DISCUSSION) UNPOPULAR OPINION: akali is still absolutely fine post-nerfs
I've been maining Akali since she was reworked, and I've absolutely fallen in love with the champion. a lot of people here hate the slow-burn duel style of assassination, but I think her gameplay (trading AND managing losing lanes) has a ton of room to put your skills and style on display(probably the only champ that you can actually have a style with). I think that nerfing her to make her skill ceiling a little more in line is totally fine, but changing her kit too much to increase her skill floor to pump up her 'overall win-rate' would do a disservice to her gameplay fantasy of being an awesome and insanely skilled ninja assassin.
The fact is, Akali right now is an extremely high skill ceiling champ, which means that the best players will do much better on her. there is NO WAY to do logic gymnastics around that statement. A lot of you guys crying for buffs need to take a step back and look at the bigger picture. The only way to nerf her without decreasing her skill ceiling is just straight up nerfing her numbers until she isnt busted in high tier play, but a lot of you guys hate the number nerfs and complain about low win rates, regardless of the fact that high tier players and long time mains still do well with her.
The option now lies between gutting her kit to make her ceiling lower and lowering her numbers (which they have already chosen) to make high tier play more balanced. (unless you are still caught up on hidden REVERT AKALI option 3) There is no way around it. Riot isnt going to let a broken champ (face it, Akali was pretty busted, and still is post-nerfs, if you're really good at her, don't try to pretend she isn't) run rampant in high tier play.
Unpopular Opinion time: I am of the mind that the current state of akali is absolutely fine. When similar champions like Azir, Ryze, and Kalista come into mind, their kits are on the same level (massive skill ceilings that require them to be heavily nerfed to not be busted in pro play), but they feel a lot different to me than Akali's does. Akali is a Ninja, not a mage, emporer, or ghost. I feel like the 'crazy skill ceiling' fantasy SHOULD apply to Akali, where it is a little more questionable on the other three. She should be crazy difficult to play, because it feels good when you master her. It feels incredibly satisfying when you outplay people, dancing around teamfights, baiting skill shots, dodging through attacks, etc. It might be a little unfair to players who like the fantasy but don't have the ability to play her at a super high level, but there are pros and cons to both routes Riot can take.
I'd love to hear some serious discussion and opinions from you guys. Are you okay with the current state of Akali? Do you think Riot should re-work her kit so that her skill ceiling and floor are a bit more manageable, or do you also think she's in a fine position? This is a discussion about current Akali, so please don't bring up revert memes.
Posted Jun 14, 2019, 3:51 PM UTC
She is fine, true, but people are mad for a reason tho.
Winning with Akali right now require much more effort than any other champ. You are not allowed to make mistake and fall behind with Akali, on the other hand take any meta champ and you would be able to win with less effort.
That’s bothering a lot of people, it’s like we need to play perfectly just to stay relevant, other mains can make 1000 mistakes and still be huge in games, shit like Riven, Fiora, Renekton and Aatrox are stupid strong and like 10x easier to play than Akali right now.
What happend to me is that I got oneshotted by a 1/6 Riven, champion that I killed 6 times in lane, oneshots me in a single rotation 10 mins later.
I completely agree with you, winning with Akali takes a lot of effort, but (in my opinion) that fact only serves to make her wins more fulfilling and satisfying. If you have to play perfectly to win, then its easier to see as her what you did wrong in fights and in lane, and that makes improving your play even easier. getting hit by a big skillshot or CC and dying makes me think 'Oh! I could have ran a different direction in W or casted R sooner and lived!' instead of 'fuck'. Each game is a new step of learning if you make it.
On other champions like when I play Annie mid, it seems like her kit is so binary. Most of the micro decisionmaking is positioning in teamfights and lane, so when you lose or die it feels like it was out of your control (even if it wasn't). With Akali, it's rare when I lose and don't instantly know what I could have done better, which doesn't happen for me that often with other champions.
Yeah I get your point. But isnt it like a really cool thing that a champ exists, on which you can really show off your skill (or not). I mean she is still a good champion, if you are able to execute on her correctly. And yes most of the playerbase just isnt able to do that, but I dont think that is a bad thing. Its really cool to have a few champs like that in the game, because you can really see a huge difference between skill in those champs. And also you can see your own progress when playing these champions and how you are getting better each game.
I personally always liked hard champs, even when I was silver I played a ton of Azir and it felt really good getting better on him and starting to win some games.