Why isn’t Garver playing more?

I do not know much about baseball strategy or management so I’ve got a general question.

What logic is there behind playing Garver and Castro in an equal number of games? Garver’s got an OPS of freaking 1.058, why have we only given him 132 plate appearances? If we don’t want to wear his knees out, I think we would stick him at 3rd and rotate out Sano. Even if Sano is probably a better bat in the long term than Castro, although they’re pretty equal right now, I think it’d be worth it to get Garver at the plate that much more. Or do people generally think this is fluky?

Posted Jun 18, 2019, 3:20 PM UTC

011
nowheresville99:cr: Cedar Rapids Kernels•

1 - Garver missed 3 weeks with an injury.

2 - Despite missing 3 weeks with an injury, he still has more plate appearance than Castro (132 vs 120) - so the premise that they're playing an equal number of games is false.

3 - Castro has an 875 OPS and is a better defensive catcher.

4 - Garver has NEVER played 3rd in the majors or minors, not even for a single inning.

5 - On a team with 2 excellent catchers, and a team that has a huge lead in standings, keeping both catchers as fresh as possible for October makes even more sense than usual.

15
OkaySweetSoundsGoodOP•

This is fair, I did not know how much time Garver has missed.

I’m curious, what supports Castro being better defensive catcher? Is he more likely to stop potentially wild pitches, throw out a runner, or does he call for better pitching? What statistics support this?

I’m not trying to shit on Castro by the way, I know he’s playing great too. I’m just asking.

-1†
sunderstormer•

Castro is an elite pitch framer. Remember this strikeout?

https://streamable.com/mdtq4

That framing job arguably won us the game there

8
gregorythegreyhound:ring: World Champs!•

Currently the Twins only have 2 catchers on their roster since Astudillo was sent down. That limits Garver to no appearances in the field/dh or pinch hit because teams do not burn their backup catcher in case of injury to the starter.

9
Hawkdagon•

why have we only given him 132 plate appearances?

He was also injured for a few weeks, so that cuts it down a little.

If we don’t want to wear his knees out, I think we would stick him at 3rd and rotate out Sano.

Excuse me? We like to bag on 3rd basemen for not playing a "hard" position...but, as far as I can tell with some brief googling, he's literally never played 3rd. No position is that easy.

8
OkaySweetSoundsGoodOP•

I find it surprising that he’s never played another infield position. I’m not saying that it’s easy, but I would guess that a professional catcher could probably do it.

-6
forester93•

Fielding a 100+ mph line drive is so much different than catching a pitch that you’ve called. Could he do it? Yeah probably, but it would take a while before he was doing it proficiently. Definitely not something you could just do in the middle of a season.

7
yankeesfan13•

Why do you think he can play third base? He hasn't played there at all as a professional. There aren't good college or high school fielding stats but even if he did play third there, that was 6 years ago in leagues with much lower standards. There's no way they'd throw him out there and just hope he doesn't make too many errors.

Plus, even if he could, that's not going to happen until September or when Astudillo gets called back up. They're not going to play without a catcher on the bench.

6
Kujo120•

One thing I’ve noticed a lot is that people take for granted how good Castro is defensively and how important that is for a winning team.

5
centuryofprogress•

Castro is hitting very well too (though less so recently.)

3
Kujo120•

You are not wrong with that, any hitting he does is just a bonus. No complaints from me hahaha.

1