Just finished the whole Max Payne series and had a great time.

Technically, I beat MP1 a couple times back in the day before Steam existed, but this was my first time with 2 and 3. I'll do a breakdown of each game.

Max Payne 1

Since this game is almost legally an adult now it's obviously a little rough around the edges today. The Steam version doesn't work with W10 very well without some added mods and fixes, but it was nothing too difficult. Nevertheless, the story, narration, the graphic novel story delivery, and noir-styled theme still hold up pretty well. The gameplay is still mostly fine as long as you remember that cover systems weren't a thing back then. The game was harder than I remembered and sometimes not for the right reasons. There were quite a few times when enemies would lob a grenade in close quarters that was nearly impossible to anticipate and would insta-kill me. Enemies also become major bullet sponges mid-late game and every weapon was starting to feel useless until I got the M4 in the last act. In one particular level I was practically saving after every enemy (no checkpoints), and that felt a little cheap. Overall though, I enjoyed replaying this again.

Max Payne 2

Probably my favorite of the trilogy. It feels like a proper iteration of MP1 with small quality of life improvements, a bigger budget, and fewer cheap deaths. It was definitely a shorter game which was unfortunate, but that may be the only knock I have against it. Gunplay felt more satisfying, where headshots actually matter and every weapon is viable. Playing as Mona a few times was a fun switch-up too, even if she played identically to Max. The story wasn't as good as the first, but it was still decent. Overall, good times were had.

Max Payne 3

I was honestly really excited going into this one just to see what a more modern take on MP looked like. I understand this one was made by Rockstar instead of Remedy, so it was bound to feel different, but I think that may have done more harm than good unfortunately. After playing 1 and 2 it was nice to finally have a cover system, but some questionable controls and awkward movement made the whole thing feel a little janky to me. I know this is a common complaint with Rockstar games, even in their most recent release of RDR2, but I find it odd that something like Uncharted 1, which released 5 years before this, was a way better-feeling game to play. I was also surprised that they kept painkillers and didn't switch to regenerating health, but I think that was the right decision. The story was easily the weakest of the trilogy and felt largely disconnected from the first two games, minus the couple of flashback levels in Jersey. Despite my complaints, once I got used to the controls the game was still fun to play, and that's what matters most.

After the shitty life Max has had and a body count to rival Thanos, I hope the poor guy is retired for good now and found some happiness.

Posted Jun 18, 2019, 5:00 PM UTC

3313
dirtyego•

All the unskippable cut scenes in 3 really liked that game for me. Every couple minutes there's a momentum killing cut scene.

7
hyperlancerOP•

I hadn't noticed since I wanted to the see the story, but I could see that being a real Payne for people who like to do multiple playthroughs.

7
dirtyego•

I see what you did there...👏

Edit: also, it definitely was a bigger issue on my second playthrough.

1
Ausman101•

100%, it's got such good mechanics I think it might still be the best feeling 3rd person shooting mechanics i've played to this day, it's so good to play in the arcade mode but the cutscenes are brutal to sit through.

edit: added stuff

3
valhallay•

I played Max Payne 1 when i was a kid with my sister but never finished it as we only had the demo from what i recall. The game was awesome but it was also scary for me lol. Played Max Payne 2 and 3 in 2012 and loved it. Easily one of my favourites game series. I might actually start a playthrough from 1 this time all the way to the 3rd one. Interested to see the narrative as you claimed it the best. My favorite was also Max Payne 2 btw.

4
caninehereBurnout Legends•

Max Payne is just one of those series where it's consistently good all the way through. I do prefer the first game to the other two, but they're all a really damn good time.

The only really unfortunate thing about MP3 is that although they included modes that were meant to make the game replayable, the cutscenes were unskippable and used to mask load times. Nowadays that obviously shouldn't be a problem with more powerful PCs but you still have to sit there and watch them, which absolutely kills the game's replayability. Still, it's really fun for one playthrough.

3
Brizzendan•

I absolutely love 1 and 2 and was hoping they would become BC on the X1. Great stories love the winter atmosphere

3
OniKagura001•

MP2 is just a masterpiece of a game, easily the best in the trilogy and one of the best of the past decade.

3
gee_tea•

I'm in the same boat as you regarding 1. I played it on PC back when it first came out and hadn't played anything else in the series since. A few years ago, I replayed it on my Android tablet and although much of it aged - I still mostly enjoyed it.

I've never played 2 but I have 3 in my backlog due to a Steam sale. I don't know what to expect but I'm going to approach it as a totally different, new game so as not to come in with too many expectations. But your middling review of 3 may actually help me go in and hopefully be pleasantly surprised.

2
hyperlancerOP•

I'm curious if you had a controller or physical keyboard synced up to that tablet when you played 1. I couldn't imagine even attempting to play that with touch screen controls!

2
gee_tea•

I didn't. And it wasn't amazing to control but it got the job done. Thankfully that game didn't require absolute precision.

1
GarciasEUW•

I played the first one in May and just finished the second one three days ago. I'm having fun with them. Although they each have their own problems, I'm looking forward to playing through the third game next month.

2
Adamtess•

I always feel alone in saying, I really enjoyed Max Payne 3. Something about finally getting some closure on Max felt good, the music was great, the gunplay felt solid, the story was... well whatever. I was more interested in Max and less about the people he was trying to save, like why are you bothering dude?

1