r/Coffee•
-jcs

Grinders

Really short one, do you think it's a better but to get a £50 electronic grinder (probably second hand, relatively low end I guess) or a £50 hand/manual grinder. Also, recommendations?

Posted Jun 18, 2019, 8:12 PM UTC

34
AnomanderBack on my baristashit.•

Better how?

You’re going to get better quality grind; you’re going to have to grind by hand. The improvement in grind is not necessarily ‘worth it’, depending on exact grinders and how much you value not needing to supply the power.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
-jcsOP•

I hardly ever serve coffee for guests, my friends and family don't really like coffee (gasp) so a little (or a lot of) work isn't an issue when grinding. I definitely would like the flexibility you mentioned from a hand grinder. My only issue would be spending say £35 on a hario slim grinder rather than biding my time for a good deal second hand Baraza encore (like I've seen 2 times recently but not bought). I have a nice roastery nearby however the cost of buying that coffee is mounting so I am going to start buying the majority of my beans from the single origin range from Taylor's of Harrogate who, to my knowledge, are fairly good for a relatively large scale company. I have an aeropress right now and a v60 in the mail so those are my main priorities however I did recently get a home espresso machine so to be able to cater to that is obviously important (otherwise it would be completely obselete) sorry if I was a little vague earlier, I wasn't sure what to include. I'm leaning towards a hand grinder, especially considering I'll be travelling fairly soon so I may end up needing one anyways.

1
_FormerFarmer•

If you're trying for espresso, especially with an unpressurized portafilter, it's an awful lot of work with any of the "reasonably priced" hand grinders, not very workable at all with an Encore. Worst issue with the Encore is that it lacks the precision adjustment needed to dial in a shot. But to get a hand grinder that will easily produce good grinds for your espresso machine, you're looking at a couple times your budget, at least.

A pressurized PF, on the other hand, will not be as good quality an espresso, but will be functional with either of your choices. When I went from a pressurized to an unpressurized PF with my first pump machine, there was an immediate difference in flavor depth and clarity. Then, when I upgraded my grinder, there was another jump in quality of the output.

There really is a difference. But that being said, budgets are there for a reason, and I'd not want to blow a budget because I was getting a better grinder. YMMV

1
ref_•

How are you making coffee?

1