Creating a Eldritch Knight in a high-powered campaign, need help choosing spells

Hello there folks, normally I would just read a guide or do some research of my own about creating a character but this particular campaign has some homebrew rules that made me want to reach out to people more familiar with 5e. (The last DnD game I played ran on 3.5 and even then that was well over 8 years ago.)

The first and most significant thing to note about this campaign is the homebrew ruling the DM has graciously allowed me, the level 3 eldritch knight, to have. That being if a spell only takes one action to cast and tells me to make a melee attack in its text with a melee weapon, I can incorporate that melee attack as part of my attack action once per a turn. For example, at level five when I get my extra attack, I can make one of those attacks be Green-Flame Blade and the other attack be a normal one. The trade-off being that EK's War Magic no longer gives a free attack whenever I cast a cantrip and instead increases the limit to two spell-buffed attacks at level 7 and three spell-buffed attacks at level 18.

​

The next major ruling is how generous our base ability scores are. Starting at level 3 I already have 16 STR, 14 Dex, 15 Con, 16 Int, 14 Wis, and 15 Cha. (Str would have been 18 if I went with another race besides Protector Aasimar but I wanted to be the caring glowy angel man for RP reasons). Also to note, our base and unbuffed Ability scores are capped at 25 and not 20.

The third and probably biggest homebrew rule come build wise is the ability to pick both a feat and ability score increase simultaneously. Not much else to say here.

Another ruling that is probably less significant is that short rests are only 10-20 minutes of downtime, presumably because the encounters are going to be tougher to combat how much power we are bringing to the table. Other rules are less combat oriented and more RP oriented (We're a group of roleplayers first so while combat is going to be flashy and fun, it will most likely only take up around a third of gameplay at most.)

So folks, any hints on spells I should pick up to help round out my magic swordsman? I'm more focused on hitting people with my sword than casting fireballs. Even though I only get two cantrips, I spent one on prestidigitation simply because I know how RP heavy our campaign is and the ability to be creative is bound to be rewarded. Should I do the typical thing with my limited spell selection and just get things to help me hit harder? Or should I trust that the ability to weave cantrips into my full-attack is going to cover me damage wise and go for some utility? In lieu of a wizard or sorceror, we have a Warlock that seems pretty damage oriented. So as much as I am not meant to be utility oriented, anything I can give to help ease the party's adventures is going to go miles.

Thanks in advance!

Posted Jun 19, 2019, 3:36 AM UTC

215

Haste and shield are must have. After that blink, storm sphere, lightning bolt.

7
SunderiousOP•

So focus more on combat despite how RP heavy the campaign is going to be? Or do these have some utility I don't know about? (Haven't played a spell caster before)

2

Oh yeah sorry, feather fall is hugely helpful.... And booming blade.

2

EK's normally only get abjuration and evocation spells but I guess with all the homebrew stuff to make you guys more powerful maybe that rule got axed.

2
ronlugge•

EK's normally only get abjuration and evocation spells but I guess with all the homebrew stuff to make you guys more powerful maybe that rule got axed.

A lot of people overlook that they do get a limited selection of 'general' spells -- one at 3rd, another at 8th, and so on.

4
SunderiousOP•

Oh no, it's still there. But I do still get the any school spells at the appropriate level.

1
axe4hire•

Shadow blade, hold person, shield, protection from evil and good. The first two spells can be taken at some level, like 4th and 8th and so on.

2
Trick573r•

Can you expand on the party composition? I know about the warlock, but are they hexblade or ranged? What party roles have been filled? It's a little easier for me to give suggestions if I know that along with the RP heavy and other information.

1
SunderiousOP•

Pact of the Raven Queen Warlock (I think that means ranged... not too sure)
Bard\Paladin Support\off melee
Longbow Scout Rogue

1
Trick573r•

So it sounds like you're the primary melee and the "tank" role. Green-Flame Blade is a good cantrip, primarily for multiple enemies, not so great for a single target. Booming Blade is better for keeping your enemy close, and punishing them if they do decide to move.

Shield is an excellent spell for an emergency AC bump. Another good survival spell is Absorb Elements. Yeah.. it's only usable against an elemental type attack, but it straight halves any of that damage. Earth Tremor is a good save or suck spell, but with your spell DC, you might want to avoid save or suck spells, but up to 16 enemies, you're bound to succeed with some.

For your level 3 spell choices, I'd like to suggest Find Familiar. An extra party scout, advantage on attacks from the Help Action, etc.. Expeditious Retreat if you really want to be fast.

1
SunderiousOP•

Alright! Thanks for the help! Seems like picking up utility is best left to the Warlock and I just double down on being a wall.

1
Shazoa•

If you want more out of combat utility then you're going to want to get that via feats. Eldritch knights have precious few spells known and the ones they do get are typically going to be combat oriented. Their classic shtick is wading into combat and dealing damage while being close to un-hittable so long as they have slots for shield. Ritual Caster is a nice one and you'd be able to pick up rituals from the wizard list without impacting your EK spells. Another good one is Magic Initiate because you can get yourself an off-school spell in addition to the one you get at EK 3. Find familar is a premier pick there, and another is shield since that essentially nets you 5 casts of that spell a day without upcasting.

Sorcerers, in some ways, actually share some of the same woes because they have relatively few spells known. One way to compensate for this is to select spells that are versatile or have more than one use. For example:

  • Find familiar: Help action shenanigans, scouting and spying, and great RP rolled into a single ritual spell.

  • Enlarge / reduce: You can buff an ally, debuff an enemy, or even use it for out of combat utility when you need to squeeze through small entrances, or stride over large barriers. Grapplers also love this one.

  • Levitate: Exploration and movement, but also very effective CC against a melee target.

  • Thunder Step: Movement to gap-close or escape, with damage on top and the ability to transport allies.

  • Polymorph: Buff allies, CC enemies, and all sorts of out of combat utility such as when you need to spy on someone discretely as a spider, or when you need a swim / climb / fly speed to bypass an obstacle.

You are going to encounter a few hard choices, for sure. You only have

But honestly, these homebrew rules are a bit silly and completely unnecessary. I have to wonder why the DM is messing with balance like that. The main concern I have is that you're essentially being given more damage but barely anything for defense. At first glance this might not seem to be an issue, but to challenge you the DM is going to have to do one of two things:

  • Buff the HP of monsters.

  • Use higher CR monsters.

In the first case you make the new PC power redundant. The extra HP has canceled out the extra damage. The changes are basically for nothing. In the latter case you have a bigger issue, because you make monsters do more and more damage while the relative defenses of the PCs stay static. It is very hard to make pitched battles when you do this because everything gets incredibly swingy. Your wizard is suddenly more at risk of being one-shot, for example, because the average damage of the inflated CR monsters approaches their health pool, and attack bonuses get high enough that you're being hit more on average too.

You see this same issue when DMs are very generous with magic items. A DM might choose to give their player/s +3 weapons in the first tier, and then when everything becomes too easy they ramp up the CR to challenge the players. Suddenly a bad string of dice rolls is way more deadly than they would have been if the monsters been an appropriate CR.

1
TheCatGhostDotCom•

Look for spells that complement your fighter skills (extra attack, defense/tanking and action surge).

Things like enlarge/reduce, shield, false life can be great, especially at lower levels. Blur and haste are good for later levels.

Basically just bear in mind that you are mostly a fighter.

With the limits of action economy, you’ll want to focus on spells that don’t take an action (there aren’t many unfortunately) as you’ll probably want to reserve your action each turn for taking the attack action.

0
SunderiousOP•

ok gotcha. So maybe just forget about trying to snatch up things like feather fall and lean into my ability to hit things good?

1
TheCatGhostDotCom•

Yeah, utility stuff isn’t bad, but it may cost you a spell that’s better for combat. EK’s can make the tankiest tanks.

Heavy armor, shield, defensive fighting style and the shield spell gets you a 26 AC and at a pretty low level (as soon as you get your hands on the plate mail really)

For cantrips, the SCAG ones work really well, booming blade and green flame blade especially.

1