Advice: Upgrade Micca MB42X and Lepai 2020 to SMSL SA50 and Polk S10 or Q Acoustics 3010?

I currently use a Micca MB42X and Lepai 2020 combo on my desktop, along with a Dayton Audio SUB-800. I'm happy with this combo at relatively high volume, but I rarely listen to it loud. In most cases, I'm listening at low to medium volume (just above the level of conversation), equally at my desktop and from other places in the ~300 sq ft room.

The setup sounds good in general, but I feel like the detail at lower volumes is a little lacking, even compared to a 10 year old Sony soundbar with a sub I use on my TV. It also doesn't do much to fill the room unless turned up really loud. I use Noaudiophile's DSP correction on my Lepai/Micca setup, along with a mildly upgraded power supply on the Lepai.

I'm considering replacing the amp, the speakers or both, and am wondering whether I'm likely to hear an audible improvement by replacing components. I was looking at the SMSL SA50 as an amp replacement, as I don't necessarily need USB audio or Bluetooth. I was also looking at the Polk S10 or the Q Acoustics 3010 (or possibly the on sale Wharfedale Diamond 210), any of which should fit into the existing space.

My question to you fine folks is this: Am I likely to hear an audible difference on my desktop at low to medium (or even high) volume by replacing just the amp, replacing just the speakers or both? Same question with filling the room a little better.

I'd be open to other recommendations for amps or speakers, considering that I can't fit most 5.25" speakers on my desk. Budget for speakers is $200 or less and I'd like to stay under $100 for the amp.

Thanks in advance!

Posted Jun 19, 2019, 5:12 AM UTC · edited

26
jfunnybuckets•

I'd keep the Lepai and maybe try something like the Wavecrest HVL-1 bookshelf speakers from ascend. I've used the Lepai in a living room and was able to push to about 50% volume and it got pretty loud.

4
jfunnybuckets•

buy from ascend to save $

But at low-medium volumes, I don't think an amp upgrade is necessary yet

5
TroubledMang•

You sure you cant fit some regular bookshelf speakers? You'll get fuller sound, and it will be a noticeable improvement. Same for amps though that SMSL could be all you need.

Price wise, those Dayton's are like $50 a pair, Pioneer BS22 go on sale for $70 a pair, NHT Superzeor 2.1 are $50-$60 each on sale and are smallish, then there are several other better speakers in the $100-$300 range. Kef Q150's are on sale for $300, ELAC B5 are $200, etc...

You should go audition various speakers, and hear which ones you like. Better than asking people because you might not like what someone else does.

2
blackjakals•

For low to medium volumes, I would look into a speaker that is a little more on the bright side like the Klipsch R-15M.

2
ArmscGood sound makes everything better•

The amp usually makes the most difference when you're pushing it hard. If all you need is 3 watts for the volume you're wanting then I don't know that you'll hear too much difference. If you're using a sub you should have plenty of bass so that's not the issue. The MB42X are good speakers but they aren't great but I do know they like to have some power behind them. A lepai is a decent desktop amp but it's not killer. I would look at something like this SMSL AD18$145 of if you have space an AVR. A refurb AVR will not cost much more and it will allow you to hook the sub into it so you can xover the mains and adjust the sub level. You would be surprised what it can do for you sound having better control over the speakers. Something like this Denon S540 refurb $160 would do you just fine. You'll need a subwoofer cable for the Dayton. I think upgrading to an AVR will really help you out.

​

If you want to upgrade the speakers you have options too. Either one you mentioned would probably be an upgrade. I would also consider the Boston A25 $150 on sale.

2
cncOP•

OP here following up on this thread. I ended up buying the Q Acoustics 3020 ($199) and a Klipsch Powergate ($199). The speakers are SO MUCH BETTER than the Micca MB42X speakers that it's kind of unreal. Unlike the other speakers I was considering, they have 5.25" drivers, but they still (barely) fit on my desk.

​

The Powergate has some issues with heat and the auto shutdown "feature", but it measures as a very good amp and I couldn't go with anything full-sized due to space. I stayed away from the SMSL stuff because apparently there is no warranty on it, and service is impossible to get. I also considered a Topping MX3 and a Dayton 120. The Dayton I ruled out due to balance issues at low volume, and the Topping was a close second, but I went with the Powergate because the amp portion, which is all I cared about, is supposed to be better and it has more usable power.

1