Moaning sound, loudest in bathroom. How to pinpoint the source?

We've recently started hearing a frequent groaning sound, mostly only noticeable when in our bathroom (only one in the house, one story up). We also hear it very loudly outside, when near the part of the house where the bathroom is.

It's muffled when in the room adjacent to the bathroom.We don't hear it in the unfinished basement near the drains and vent stack. The house is old (1950s) and semi detached. I'm pretty sure the neighbors are gone for the weekend.

The sound is frequent, every few seconds for a while, but it stops occasionally too and it sounds like a Wookie, or like someone dragging wood furniture across a floor or a groaning door hinge.

We aren't sure where to go from here.

Is this likely to be a plumbing/vent problem? A structural problem with the roof (it's from 2011, we haven't noticed wall cracks or anything).

I'm trying to take notes on it, see if it's linked to household activities (water use) but yesterday we were outside for a few hours and no one was in the house and we heard it a lot.

Can anyone advise on what to do? What kind of professional should I be calling? Plumber? Roofer? HVAC?

Posted Jun 23, 2019, 6:34 PM UTC

213
KyouLine•

My house make a similar noise when it's really windy from the North. I think it's excess pressure building up in the crawl space then escaping from one particular area. I call it 'house farting'

2
AdolphEinstien•

Do you think an animal has gotten in the wall or perhaps in the ex. fan vent?

1
mtledOP•

Not sure what animal would make such a sound? I'm in Montreal, so racoons, squirrels? Sounds more like a cow mooing than noises I associate with those animals. For a while we thought it was someone in another house in the neighborhood using some sort of power tool.

It might be possible. There are trees with branches that overhang the house, none very close though.

1
CougarGold06•

Maybe ask the neighbors if they hear it too

1
mtledOP•

We've walked around the house, half into a neighbour's yard. We only hear it when standing in front of the part of the house where the bathroom window is. Even walking around the corner (to the wall side where the shower is) we can barely hear it. Can't hear it from the front of the house at all.

From what I can see, the vent stack is just a metal tube sticking up. It's not directly above the bathroom but more near the middle of the house. No whirlybird. There's also the roof high point nearby.

We do have terrible venting from a ceiling vent in the washroom. It was routed horizontally above the bathroom ceiling and out via a soffit. The sound does not appear to come out through the ceiling vent.

The noise is louder outside than in the washroom though.

1
Der_Missionar•

I think someone murdered someone and stuck them in the wall.

1
mtledOP•

Could be. Never did meet the previous owner's wife. Apparently she died, but we never got details.

2
iambic_court•

Is it windy? Do you have a whirlybird on the roof near the bathroom? Ours makes an awful sound when the wind is a particular speed. It needs to be maintained.

1
mtledOP•

Not particularly windy and no whirlybird. I've tried to see if the noise coincided with wind/tree branches moving, but it doesn't appear so.

1
ConfoundedOcelot•

Is it a steady noise or more choppy like there is a propeller in it?

​

An audio recording or video might help.

1
mtledOP•

More steady. Makes me think a lot of a wooden chair being dragged across a wooden floor.

I could try to record it. It's definitely in the attic space above our bathroom (or that roof area). We really don't hear it from any other parts of the house.

1
mtledOP•

Current hypothesis; the area where the sound is coming from is also the area where the phone line attaches to the house. It looks rather taut, and following the line back to the post we see a tree leaning on it! We suspect that tree movements (wind, squirrels; it's not a big tree) are causing the attachment to move and creak.

Of course, there's no sound at the moment, so we can't check if the movement matches. It's also not at all windy, so the hypothesis is still supported.

We'll see.

1
mtledOP•

Went into neighbour's yard, pushed on the tree. No noise at all (on a day when we really weren't hearing it).

So much for that hypothesis.

1