bredburd•

I feel the community will have hysteria when we get a card that actually makes some fucking sense

17
WERE_CAT•

The whole expansion is consistent...

​

Consistently stupid.

12
crunchybonezz•

Jesus, are you guys just basing cards off memes now?

9
Ava_Vispilio•

Is it me or is the art for these cards getting weirder and weirder...

6
WERE_CAT•

Does that mean it will force a lonely opponent on the back row to go back and attack the opponent base ?

That would be both stupid and hilarous. It would probably be op with push mechanism.

4
StrikerEureka96•

Confused units con only move forward or sideways. They can't go backwards.

4
WERE_CAT•

Yes, but this is not confusion. The card read : force the target enemy unit [...] to attack a random bordering enemy. Taken Literarily (enemy base is considered 'enemy', see needle blast for exemple), this means an enemy near the enemy base will have a chance to attack it, and will automatically attack it when also not bordering any other enemy unit.

5
SargonTheOK•

Dear God that would be terrifying. I certainly hope not. For 3 mana, that seems wildly overpowered - you could just use it to nuke most zero-move units that were played on the first turn, AND deal their strength in base damage???? For less mana than Execution?

Say it ain’t so, Paladin, this needs serious clarification.

2
karbonbasedlife•

I'm not sure how I feel about the subversion of the confusion mechanic here. Confusion is already divisive enough, this card shortcuts the random effect of confusion and goes straight to running the target into a friendly unit. A little OP, and what if there isn't a friendly unit nearby?

Instead, I'd like to see this card inflict confusion on the target and then force the target to move out of turn. It adds the fun and balancing chance that the card works against the caster and allows the target to gain ground if the forward option is rolled. If played on a friendly target, might gain you ground, might not.

Edit: Clarification.

2
WERE_CAT•

Being able to play that on a friendly unit would make it a random herald hymn available to all factions. Not sure we really want that.

2
karbonbasedlife•

Only a 33.3% chance of that at best and for only a single unit rather than up to 4. That's only... *does the math* 8.3% as dangerous as the best Herald's Hymn and 33.3% as dangerous as the worst.

Edit: Minus the strength bonus imparted by HH, one could argue that the percentages are lesser yet.

2
WERE_CAT•

Your math are wrong. If there is only one enemy it will attack it, so your 33% is off. HH is usually played with 1-2 units, so your 4 factor is off too.

It would be played on border columns, so 100% chances to attack the base if there is no other unit around, 50% if there is another. So around 75% on average, divide it by 1.5 to account for the loss in targets and you have something half efficient.

Half efficient for half the mana seems good. Ok, no bonus attack, but this is also a defensive card. Plus it would be neutral... I maintain that it would not be healthy for the game.

0
Ben_Adaephon_Delat•

The math does check out just fine. Based on the above suggestion it would appear your math is off. The suggestion above is for the spell to confuse a target unit below X strength instead of forcing it to attack something. It moves one unit as opposed to 4 from hymn(25% as much), and it only moves forward 33% of the time in the standard case. 0.25 * 0.33 = 8.25%. Again this is the standard case where both sides are available.

But the exact numbers aren't the point here. The point is this card would be much more interesting if it was able to confuse a target unit as oppose to subverting the brand new mechanic and jumping straight into making enemy units attack their fellow units.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ecifice•

For reference, 3 strength is how much level 1 execution does. Yowling Weavers and Harpies seem to be the only level 1 cards immune, but once you reach 4 or 5 mana cards then you can't convert them any more. This also does double value like a shadowfen card, so its max is 6 at level 1 for 3 mana. It seems like a card that can counter early aggro. Downside is you get no board presence, but if you just want to stall then it seems fine.

1
Astrid101Tribes of Shadowfen•

Is the cucumber referring to something specific cause it seems like a random detail

1
limmyfox•

Google cat cucumber

1