Parents Offered to transfer home ownership with some strings.

Housing

So my mother and her husband have made an offer to transfer their property entirely to my name. Due to recent health issues my mother will need a home that is more wheelchair-accessible and their current house just wont work, So they plan on building a second house at the back of their property (about 10 acres) and signing the entire property into my name. Whereas they would on paper be renting their house from me, they would in turn pay their portion of the new mortgage for their house, and I would be paying the remaining mortgage on the old house (along with any additions i would like to make).

My issues with this is we have had a strained relationship in the past, to which she has made efforts to make amends in the passing years, she is just very controlling and invasive. It would also turn my 10 minute commute into an hour long commute. However I currently pay $1000/month in rent, and their mortgage is currently $750 including all related fees/taxes etc. And there are of course many positives to being in a home rather than renting. All in all my personal problems with her seem to be dwarfed by what I see as the positives on a personal level.

Financially it seems to make sense, and shes offering this as a way to help repair my credit my increasing my equity as I have terrible (600) credit. My mother has stated that as soon as I get my credit up to 640 they are ready to go forward.

​

I however am looking for anyone with more knowledge on the subject as to what vulnerabilities this leaves me open to. They already own the property, and would be putting the land in my name as well as the new home being built and the existing one. The home is valued at $400k and they currently owe $170k. The property is valued at well over that, as it is near two rapidly expanding cities and has rocketed up in recent years.

I dont know enough about real estate to know if this is just as good an offer as it seems, or a way to mitigate responsibility and fault. Their credit has been destroyed by financial issues due to her medical expenses(spinal injury that caused 1.5 million in hospital debt) and they seem to be nearly reliant on me agreeing to this to be able to build the second property. My credit is nothing special however so I'm not sure how I could exactly help them, I am just wary of this situation because it sounds too good to be true. I make ok money but I know I wouldn't be able to afford 2 mortgage payments.

Posted Jun 27, 2019, 7:43 AM UTC · edited

310
PARA9535307•

So to clarify, they would be transferring everything over to your name, including land, both houses, and both mortgages? Or you would be a co-borrower with them? On one or both? How will that work (I couldn’t tell precisely from the post)?

If you’re going to own everything, including all the mortgages, then no, I wouldn’t do this. You’ve had a strained relationship in the past, and they’ve got health issues. So:

  1. What if they stop paying on “their portion” of the mortgage in your name? Whether out of necessity or strained relations. If everything is in your name, you’d be left holding the bag - and either have to go through the process of evicting and suing your parents, or just be stuck having to cover the total payment yourself.
  2. What’s their plan long term? If this is the beginnings of an attempt to offload assets in order to qualify for Medicaid down the road, then be aware that could be considered fraud, and they have a five year look back period.

And even if the mortgage/land you’ll own is just your portion, and they’re attempting to gift you their equity in it, and not entangling it with the new 2nd house or that land:

  1. The number 2 bullet above still applies.
  2. Are you sure you want to live so close to, and be so enmeshed with, someone you’ve had a strained relationship with in the past? What happens if things go south again?
  3. An hour commute is a lot to sign up for. It will get old, pretty fast. Besides the obvious time drain, it can also be expensive, as you’ll have extra fuel costs, more maintenance costs, and likely increased insurance costs due to the extra mileage. This could wash out any cost savings involved, potentially plus some.
  4. What does it cost to maintain that house and all the land? And how much effort? Do you have any equipment needed to do this? How much would that cost to buy or rent? Is that how you want to spend your weekends?

Also, if they want to clarify who gets what, inheritance wise, their best course of action is to have wills drawn up that specify what they want to happen.

Another question to ponder, why aren’t they just selling the house/property to someone else? Take your relationship out of the equation, for a moment. Do they not need the money? Is the house/land really worth what they’re telling you it’s worth? Are their restrictions/issues with and property? Are they having, or do they anticipate having trouble finding buyers? Are they hoping that “gifting” whatever equity is involved here will result in you feeling obligated to take care of them later, physically or financially? How would you feel about that?

Regardless, if you do this deal, you need to work with a real estate attorney and a CPA to ensure your interests are being protected. And go very, very slowly through the process. Take time to read and re-read through every document. To have all of your questions and concerns fully addressed to your satisfaction. And understand fully the implications of what you’re signing up for here, both legally and relationally.

4
OG_BigboreOP•
  1. This is a major concern, I am able to cover what would be my portion but it would basically put me back below the poverty line if i had to pay for both.
  2. This is the largest deterrent to me, as she was extremely manipulative and invasive. She has changed a lot since suffering her spinal injury but I am always worried she will return to her old ways that left her alone and me suicidal.
  3. this is the least concern to me, ive had long commits before only recently have I been spoiled by a 15 minute commute, part of living in Texas.
  4. the equipment needed is all there and would be shared between us. I am not exactly thrilled about mowing 8 acres.

In regards to selling the house, part of the agreement on the property is it is offered to family members first and foremost. They have NO intentions of selling the land as it is his families property, they would like to keep it in the family.

I think I have a lot to speak with them about, and I absolutely will require a real estate attorney present to protect myself. Honestly I think it sounds like a good idea in theory but logistically its going to be locking me and my wife down in a time in our life where thats the opposite of what we want right now, we want to move around and live in various places before settling down. And i feel like this would essentially lock us in place especially because there is no indication my mother or her husband are going anywhere anytime soon (both of our families have a track record of living into the 90s lol)

1
PARA9535307•

Yeah, I wouldn’t do this if I were in your shoes.

The only real upside I see here is that you might gain some equity. I say might because it’s only worth what it will sell for, and either by family obligation, or possibly clouding of the title, you can’t easily sell it. And if you can’t sell it, the equity is effectively worthless. Leaving you trapped in a house and mortgage you can’t easily get out of.

Everything else presented here are downsides. This is like the family equivalent of buying a house next to a sewage treatment plant. You risk spending your days hoping the smell of their drama and toxicity doesn’t waft over as badly today as it did the day before. That’s no way to live. I would actually pay money to avoid that possibility, and instead seek to maintain healthy boundaries and preserve some physical distance between this and my happy nuclear family life.

2
CPA_MAc•

I think there are some issues that would prevent the transfer from happening.

The first issue is that your mom and her husband will not be able to transfer the land without the mortgage lender’s approval. Typically, mortgages have a “due on sale/transfer” clause. You also cannot just takeover your mom’s mortgage without getting the mortgage company involved. You’d likely have to apply for a mortgage with that lender (or apply for a loan elsewhere and payoff the original lender) so that you could remove your mom and her husband from the loan and also transfer title of the property.

The second issue is that your mom and her husband will have a difficult time getting a construction loan if they transfer the title of the land to your name. Even if you complete an easement agreement allowing any future owner of the second home to access the land, a lender will hesitate on giving a construction loan for a home built on land owned by another entity. (I assume that your mom’s second home is built on the land they want to transfer to your name). One solution could be to subdivide the land so that the land that the second home is built on is in their name.

Many of these issues would be solved if no lenders are involved, if there’s a large amount of cash available to float, or you can get some type of non-conventional financing.

If you have already solved these issues could you please update? Decades ago, I worked for a bank and did some mortgage/heloc lending, so things may have changed.

3
SmibsRule•

Money aside the real tangible in your face upside is that you have a chance to make things right between you and your mom. When your younger, yes, money is a focus but you will learn in your later years that the only real things in life that matters are your relationships with those around you. This is your chance to get close to your mom. Best of Success to You and Your Family

1
Mombo_No5•

At least they are building a separate home so you will have a bit of privacy. It's good to be close by though, as she is less able to move around and she is getting older.

Looking at it from a money standpoint, perhaps she wants it to go directly to you instead of you dealing with her estate along with her husband in the future.

1
OG_BigboreOP•

Thats basically what theyre trying to avoid. Right now its split between her husband and his brother. His brother has one half and a house on the other end. totally ~30 acres. Once one dies the rest goes to the other sibling and then to their children, Neither brothers have any next of kin, so this they see as a clean way to resolve where the property goes. As it is frankly unlikely his older brother will outlive him, they anticipate to leave the entirety of the property to me. It does make me a bit uncomfortable knowing there would be drama once that day finally came, but I dont mind dealing with it if it gives my mother and her husband peace of mind in that regard.

1
bitterbeerfaces•

Relationship issues aside, this might be a good idea. If the property is in your name for 5 years before your mother or step-father would need nursing home care of it protected from the "look back period".

I moved into to help take care of my grandfather when I was 22 years old and I moved out at 27 when he needed more care than I could provide. If we had put his house in my name or my mother's name when I moved in, we would not have had to sell the house and our family would have gotten a 150k assesst, instead of nothing.

0
OG_BigboreOP•

What is a "look back period"

My mother suffered spinal injuries but is far from needing nursing care, she is only 54, and in other-wise fantastic health.

1
bitterbeerfaces•

Most people have to bankrupt themselves for nursing home care. The look back period prevents people from transferring their property/money, instead of selling/using it to pay for care.

So the government established a rule, where they look at your financial transactions for the past 5 years to see what you did with your money. They can require the person to come up with that money before they pay for nursing home care.

If you transfer your property/money 5 years before care, they government ignores it.

It's not even large amounts- if a Grandpa gives his grandson son $1,000 for finishing high school, then needs to go in a nursing home care. The government will ask for that $1,000 back.

1