Trust Issues

So I've just spent a good 30 minutes in Valentine, trying to give away a cougar to help with today's challenge. I managed to bag both of mine pretty quick so when i came across a 3rd i thought I'd stow it as a gift. I'm assuming some had probably already filled their quota, but i had a good 10-15 players either stop look then ride off or just straight up run the opposite direction, like "IT'S A TRAP!!!" I finally managed to get a player to take it but what a struggle. Trust that not all of us are kill-crazy madmen..

Posted Jun 27, 2019, 1:00 PM UTC

5233
AccidentalPerson•

yeah, but, let's face it, most players are.

if there are 5 player blips in valentine, at least one of those is going to fire on me unprovoked. every time.

that being said, you are a kind and generous player, and i'm sorry that your better instincts weren't better received.

44
Fire_DemonOP•

I'm actually more surprised that no one did take a shot at me to be honest. I even had a full posse ride by without stopping, like i was some street beggar! Ha ha thankfully someone eventually took the chance though.

7
Abex81•

I don’t know what people fear honestly. It is a freaking digital avatar. I don’t like griefers, but i am not riding away from anyone because I fear to be shot.

It is an online game that encourages interactions between players so I am always curious to see what other people are doing. Always give the benefit of the doubt.

If they kill me for no reason... Shame... Loads explosive ammo

26
Fire_DemonOP•

It was quite comical at first to be fair. I was trying to find the lowest level there but everytime i ran towards them they'd run away. So I'd run back to my horse, stow the cougar and try to catch up with them, whistling all the way!

5
Abex81•

I hear you. Back during the Beta, i was always in surplus of Herons (when they gave 3 feathers each) so i often ran to the closest player to give them away.. but most of the time things took a dark turn so i gave up lol

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
xOstravaOfBoletariax:collector: Collector•

Just use Repeating Shotgun, one hit kills on even passive mode players

-1
xTheBlackKnightx•

Ineffective if player fortified cores and extended ring, and remains defensive without during the first shot. This includes full face headshots. Social retards constantly try to goad defensive players to shoot first for a reason.

3
xOstravaOfBoletariax:collector: Collector•

The first bullet at point blank normally kills them instantly if it doesn't, the second bullet sure as hell will. Unless they got slow and steady, but you ain't killing somebody with slow and steady anyways

2
Sh-tstirrer•

I was riding past a guy who did this with an alligator skin. He was skinning it when a random rescue mission came up so he took off his alligator pelt, put it on my horse, then took off with the stranger.

It's nice to be nice.

6
Fire_DemonOP•

Too true. A dying game it seems..

5
Disastrous_Sound•

That's very bizarre. I'm surprised greed doesn't override the fear of death in most people, especially since death has no consequence. Even if it's a trap of some kind, fuck it. You can bet I'm trying to grab the cougar and run the gauntlet to the butcher.

6
TomDogg213•

OMG! I just had the exact same deal the other day but with badgers!!! They run, sometimes duck down look at it, but never took the giveaway! SO weird.

6
LilacTurtle13•

I did the same thing outside of Blackwater. I had two cougars that I was trying to give away and everyone ran from me. I finally found a hunter skinning a deer so I dropped them both fairly close, waved and rode away. I'm thankful he didn't shoot me! I did get a friend request from him so now I have a new friend!

5
Fire_DemonOP•

Way to go! It's no doubt a welcome change of pace. Well done.

I tried to send a random friend request yesterday, to apologise for a brain fart on my part. I was travelling from McFarlane Ranch, going along the rail tracks toward Thieves Landing when i noticed a pronghorn carcass just sitting there. So i get off my horse thinking jackpot, free pelt/meat and start to skin. It was at that moment the hunter appeared, whom i hadn't even noticed on the minimap due to my sun glare covered tv. But it was too late. The skinning animation had started and so the hunter starts shooting. With me being in defensive though it's taking a bit of effort, but the shots have interrupted the skinning animation at least. I start to walk away but the bullets continue. So i spun, hit deadeye and dropped him with 2 shotgun blasts. :S lol Got back on my horse and travelled a distance to msg the dude and apologise for mistakenly trying to steal his kill. Msgs are set to friends only so i go to send a f-request.... and got disconnected.

3
mperezstoney•

I trust noone. Mainly because if I am playing i'm running a stranger mission. There's no need to approach me at all. Doing fine being the lone wolf. Thanks but no thanks. :)

4
TheSkuh•

Try it outside of towns and you have more luck. Most people are wary but if you walk slowly towards them with your hands full of carcass they usually, tentatively, give you the benefit of the doubt. I give things away a lot, and it is surprising how hard it can be sometimes. lol.

4
Fire_DemonOP•

Ha ha i felt like i was in need of a bell and a sandwich board!

4
Vlinder01•

The reason why I NEVER trust another player in Online is because I don't have good experience with them. For example, I am trying to do the "Ride 100 miles with a coach" award right now. I have stolen already 4 coaches, and drove only 20 miles.Why? Becasue everytine I meet a posse of at least 2 players they will destroy my coach.

I am not in a free roam mission or something, I am just driving it. Last time I even was heading into the mountains to avoid other players, but still it didn't work. I even was so kind to move around them when they where collecting pelts on the road. Result again: Coach destroyed.

4
commoncoitusy•

Aw man that sucks. My husband and I have a posse and will pick up randoms in one of those big coaches if they are in defensive.

We usually end up somehow killing the horses by running into and over stuff, or accidentally drowning them, but it's fun to have people along.

5
Fire_DemonOP•

Yeah that sucks, dude. Some people just can't help acting like asshats given the opportunity. PvE servers would be absolute bliss imo.

3
Lightfiretx•

I was riding down south of Blackwater one day when I saw a feller dragging a corpse from his horse. He was being playful it seemed, wasn't being aggressive to me at all. He gets off his horse to do something when I see a red blip on my mini map. Sure enough, a cougar comes out of no where and mauls the guy. Since I was fairly close and didn't react fast enough to help him, I was able to kill the cougar after the fact for him. He came back around, got on his horse and took off. When I got the cougar myself, I noticed it was a 3 star. So I decided I would pick it up and take it to him, since it looked like he headed towards Blackwater. So I did and dropped it at his feet once I found him, but he pointed his gun at me instead. I was like well..okay...and rode off. I didn't go too far but noticed the corpse was still on the ground via the map. As I start to head back to it after a few minutes, I see some other feller pick it up and take it to the butcher and sold it himself. All I wanted to do was give him the cougar that mauled him to death but I guess he wanted no part of it lol.

3
Fire_DemonOP•

Ha ha the bad guys of this game really have burned that paranoia deep!

3
deejayrivah•

I had loaded like 6 pig carcasses into a hijacked train at Flatneck Station, and while I was unloading them in Rhodes, a kind fellow took a photo of me holding a pig on the train. Then helped me carry the rest to the butcher. This kind of thing doesn't happen enough!

3
Fire_DemonOP•

Absolutely. I'd love to see PvE servers somewhere down the line but i won't be holding my breath..

3
xTheBlackKnightx•

Switch to defensive mode, then give away the cougar. You will be successful and might even make some friends, if you use a mic and not sound like a psycho. Valentine is not the best location to be friendly anyway. Social retards and CoD babies still abound in this game, although demograhics are completely different.

3
Fire_DemonOP•

I'm mostly a PvE player anyway so i play in defensive 99% of the time. I struggled a bit with the lack of lock-on aiming starting out but it's much improving by the day, and I'm winning way more if/when attacked. Yeah, Valentine is a bit of a try-hard magnet. I had been gonna try to offload the carcass at Saint Denis, but that's even worse for the kill-on-sight grief babies! Lol

2
mississippidew•

Just get on mic and make an announcement that you have a cougar carcass up for grabs, your location, and whoever gets there first can have it. Works for me every time.

3
FiremanMac811•

The fact that 11 people downvoted my joke just goes to show how thin skinned RDO’s player base is.

-5
Fire_DemonOP•

Joke you say? I remember seeing your rant about you purposely hunting/engaging Defensive Mode players.

"SOFT"

https://www.reddit.com/r/RedDeadOnline/comments/c11xox/soft

It's just a video game, dude. There's all kinds of ways to play! ;)

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
FiremanMac811•

I’ll shoot you if you’re blue or red on my map. Because that’s what heroes do.

-18
Fire_DemonOP•

Ha ha "heroes"? Really?!

8
FiremanMac811•

Yep. Pew pew pew!

-15
[deleted]•

[removed]

1