You can count your true friends on one hand, but how do you choose?

I've seen lots of posts recently with people talking about how they didn't know who their closest friends were until they saw who visited them in the hospital.

I feel like that's an unfair qualifier. There are plenty of different kinds of friends. I know people who probably wouldn't visit, but would be the first to have my back in a fight. Or others who'd call and talk for hours if I'm having a bad day. They're not less of a friend, they're just different, and I consider them all among my best friends.

Anyway, after seeing the hospital thing as a dominant theme in 'best friend determination' here on Reddit, i was wondering if there were any other interesting approaches?

Posted May 21, 2010, 9:13 PM UTC

514
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
penguinsarecooool•

The reason the hospital visitation is a criteria for "best friend determination" is because the hospital usually signals some kind of life-threatening problem. Visiting is a bit generalized because you're not taking into context the reason for the hospital visit. If I was in something like an accident though, I'd like who I consider my best friends to be there.

I suggest other criteria, aside from yours, includes friends who look out for your best interest. A generalization, yes, but sometimes you need a third party to determine what is the best thing for you. You may be clouded by first-hand judgement of what is the right step to take. The lines of the "right step" has to be related to the types of consequences in the eventual decision you take. Some, or even most of the situations have clear rights and wrongs, and it is in these situations that BEST friends can provide a logical solution.

2
engineeringstudentOP•

You make some very good points. I like the idea of who is looking out for your best interests, never looked at it that way before. As for the hospital thing, I do understand it, I just thought people were taking it a bit too seroiusly

1
duckwizzle•

Can you please link me to one of the hospital threads? It sounds like a fun read because I was in the hospital in December with a collapsed lung and thought about who my real friends were.

1
engineeringstudentOP•

It was never the main idea of any of the threads, just mentioned in passing. This is the most recent one I can remember.

1
DarthContinent•

The ones that are willing to be in the same room with me... and pull my fingers on that same hand.

1
switching•

They are the people who you could forgive for pretty much any stupid, careless, shitty, bonehead move ... and who would do the same for you. I find almost alway we share the same moral code, so it is easier for us to trust each other.

1
[deleted]•

I've got 2 people I trust completely and I would call friends. Perhaps there are a couple more under that tier but generally, I have two best friends for life.

1
engineeringstudentOP•

For life? You're either young, or lucky. My best friend from high school and I went our separate ways when we left for college. And now that we've just graduated, it'l probably happen again with my college roommate.

1
[deleted]•

Well, it's kind of funny because both my best friends have the same name. I grew up with one. We had dance class together as 6 year olds but we didn't start to be close till high school. We had a huge falling out and a few years later, we made up. She's my angel archetype. She's the one that keeps my ass in line and is the litmus test of whether something is a good idea or not.

My other best friend is someone I've known for almost 10 years and we hit it off right away and had all these crazy adventures moving state to state and raising hell together. She's my devil and convinces me to do stuff that I normall wouldn't do. She's me with less inhibitions and she knows exactly how to get me topless in a bar full of midgets in Tijuana without me knowing. But we also had a big falling out and a few years later, we made up.

That seems to be the test with me. My friends are all people that despite our growing pains and fights, we are always there for each other. Both falling outs were very intense but whatever got us together, was always there and I can only assume it's always going to be there.

1
SardonyxGem•

Honestly? None. Half of the people I consider close friends have never met me, and the ones that know me or knew me before I moved across country don't talk to me enough to care. Friends come and go no matter what in life.

1
oxywebguy•

I have been told I am a little bit different when it comes to the friends category. I seriously have at least 15 people that I would consider CLOSE friends. Friends that would let me stay on their couch for a month if I needed. Friends I could call at 3:00 am from the middle of nowhere and they would jump out of their bed in a second if I needed them. Friends that have been there for me, but I have also been there for them! I am a bit of an outgoing guy though, and have been single for the last 6 years, so I think I have just been building friendships instead of a relationship.

1
[deleted]•

I don't think I have any specific criteria. You just know. I have three really close friends.

Friend 1 (a guy... I'm female) will always understand me more completely and thoroughly than anyone else does. We get each other entirely. He is a calming, steady voice of reason in my life who can always make me smile, and makes me want to be a better person. I trust him completely and have a tremendous amount of respect for him. Our friendship is as natural as breathing, but in some ways, it's also a lot of work and, at times, very difficult, but it's so worth it. I don't know how to put it into words. It's unique and like nothing else I've ever encountered. We have been through a hell of a lot together.

Friend 2 (also a guy) is someone I love to hang out, have fun, and joke around with. I know if I ever need something, he's there to help, but there are some aspects of my life that I just don't share with him, some quirks of my personality he doesn't get, and some issues we will never agree on. Sometimes he does things that annoy me greatly, but we get over them. He's kind of like a brother.

Friend 3 is sort of like the female equivalent of Friend 2, like a sister who will always be there and do anything to help me and my family, whom I have a lot in common with, but who doesn't really understand some aspects of who I am. She gets the important parts, though.

1
Badlaundry•

Hypothetical situation:

Your fiance turns into a raging bitch just months after your marriage, big messy divorce, home's sold in the settlement, bitch wife sent your boss lies and partying pictures to get you fired.

Does [Friend] allow you to sleep on his/her couch indefinitely?

OR

Would you let [Friend] stay on your couch indefinitely? Assume they're working towards independence.

There you go.

1
Dannick•

One of my qualifications:

If they asked me to do something I didn't agree with without being able to tell my why, only that it was important, would I do it?

1