MIL asked me work out if her Magic The Gathering cards had any value. 18 unopened packs. Was about to start cataloguing them when I discovered unopened packs might be worth far more. Any advice?

Posted Jul 2, 2019, 8:04 AM UTC

Posted Jul 2, 2019, 8:04 AM UTC
Unopened is difficult to move due to the prolific amount of resealed products now in the market, personally, I'd take them somewhere to get them valued and properly graded ( for exact set) and then open them with gloves on, sleeve them straight away. There are some incredibly sought after cards in the original sets including in revised, like dual lands which are pretty easy to get but sell for 200 odd each for mint condition pack fresh.
Oh, ok good advice. I will look into that as well then.
If you want to get them off your hands, I'd recommend going to a game store that sells magic product. (you can find one here http://locator.wizards.com/)
They may or may not want to buy from you, but they'll be able to help you out a lot more.
Just found 1 pack of these on eBay for £177
FYI, yes the chance of them containing something worth a ton of money is there... the likelyhood of something good actually being in there is low. You would likely get more money selling them all unopened even individually than you would by opening them and selling what you find, some people will pay a lot of money for the chance at one of those cards being worth something amazing.
Yeah I’m definitely leaning that way. Will be my MIL’s decision but it seems like the most sensible.
18 x ( roughly ) £170 = £3000 ish. 18 x a chance of getting something = ??? Goodluck I'd be selling them.
sell unopened. even if you open them and find a rare card, it has to be in super mint condition for it to be worth anything and if you know how cards are graded, it's very very very difficult to get a really high rating, the card has to be basically perfect.
It’s a gamble because of the unknown cards inside. You can hit it big or meh. There’s a guy that opens old baseball packs on youtube that pretty interesting.
Maybe an MRI operator can get a glimpse of what’s inside without opening it?
I used to do this for a living.
Using ebay with anything other than a very established account is a risk and a half because the customer can refute the charges, claim fraud, or otherwise be a pain in the ass and you have little recourse.
A store that specializes in trading cards will pay you a (substantial?) fraction of what the packs are worth and will actually pay you.
It might be worth making arrangements with Star City Games (based out of Roanoke, VA) to meet up with one of their buyers at the next big Magic event in your area (they happen all the time, the game is huge). I would definitely get a couple of different offers from your friendly local gaming stores and compare those offers with what SCG will make and what you can get on ebay, and make a decision based on your comfort with the risk of online peer to peer sales.
Think of this like selling a moderately valuable painting.
Don't open them. You can search the pack without opening it to see if there are any rare cards. other than the Black Lotus, i don't know what cards are even rare these days though, so you'd have to research that yourself. The trick was to push the cards around inside the pack and you can just barely read the name of the card on the top edge because the white part of the package is not quite opaque enough to completely hide it. may have only been in certain revisions of the packs, but my friends used to search the packs in the store to find the packs with the rare cards.
if you are going to open the packs and try your luck, then do NOT let anyone touch them.
if those are before a certain generation of packaging, its easy to 'scan' the packs without opening them by shifting the cards around, letting you see exactly what cards are in each pack.
scanning the packs tends to slightly damage the edges of the packaging.
it would be easy to see the packs were scanned, probably lowering the potential "unopened" value.
put them all in a clear box and keep it sealed.
Unopened would probaly be worth more, as the chance of getting thoes super rare cards that are worth a lot is... Well... Super rare.
That said, they are actualy getting more and more expensive as the time goes on.
The longer the wait, the less of a supply the greater profits.
Well the rarity hasn’t changed since 1994. The same odds of pulling Underground Sea, Tropical Island etc now are the same as pulling a Mahamoti Djinn. They don’t become super rare because they have a higher value now.
Odds and rarity isnt the same.
The odds stays the same with each pack.
But as more packs are found and opened they become more rare.
Meh, revised. Open them.
Checkout " open booster " or " alpha investments " on YouTube. Seems they're probably worth more unopened... BUT if you do open them and find certain rare cards you could earn some serious money... It's just a gamble... goodluck
Sorry that's as long as they are genuine unopened as some of these can be " resealed " packs were people have already taken out good cards and replaced them...
I know you have no reason to believe me, but my MIL got these when they came out, as she loves collectable cards, so I personally know these ones aren’t resealed. I don’t know if that’s something that can be certified though.
To be honest I'd just sell them individually unopened.... Checkout eBay & amazon .. silly high prices for 1 pack, the chance of getting a card like " black lotus " or " mox ruby " are slim. Those cards sell for thousands... but the chance if getting one is really low
[removed]
I think you are right. If they sold for $200 each on eBay that would make more money than if I opened them all and found 6 of the top value cards for revised (according to www.mtgprice.com/spoiler_lists/Revised website). I bet the odds of finding rare cards like that in revised are much lower!