r/IdleHeroes•
peugi

How microtransactions in gacha games work psychologically

Discussion

Posted Jul 4, 2019, 7:20 AM UTC

5420
Juty_S518•

Here's the video he references a lot: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xNjI03CGkb4

You can see the various dynamics in action here in the IH reddit sub - the normalisation of spending in particular is doing a lot of DH Games' work for them. How many times has someone posted something like "just buy the monthly card and diamond card, then you'll get vip3 and it will unlock certain features; it's great value, only $30"?

Imagine if this game was $30 in the Play Store - it would have about 5 downloads, and 1 star rating. Now imagine it cost $5k to download - it would get laughed off the internet. Yet there are plenty of "vip6"+ players out there.

The sooner these mechanics are regulated the better.

I'm keeping my F2P wall well maintained!

18
minhtrung0206•

Shamefully, I was one of those who said “the anniversary card is amazing, you should get it”... and yeah I bought monthly card... and yeah, you are right; if this game costs 15-30$ in the AppStore, I would never buy it.

Dammit. I need help.

8
edtherobot•

This is great. Super interesting, and exactly how I have always seen these games. I used to have a lot of vices and definitely see how this game replaces some of those habits in what I see as a healthier way. I don’t think these games are terrible, I see gacha games as modern day collecting, it can be harmless. But the way the games industry is using the loot box mechanic is really unethical and needs regulating asap.

10
peugiOP•

You might be addicted and could need help. Watch this and perhaps you will stop spending/playing.

8
ForMoreThanJustME•

Whoa before you grab the pitchforks... Lay your arms down and remember this form of game isn't the worst scourge onto humanity. Whats wrong with paying money per month or through increments? I went with friends last week for drinks, do i get to go back next week and drink again for free? No, that was for the last time i was there. I payed for cable last month with channels I don't even know what they are (no really what is RFDtv?!?) and also with premium channels (HBO, showtime) does my neighbor who pays for basic get those channels or is my cable experience better?

Did you once pay for a game, keep it and play it all the time and never pay again? Sure, but those golden days didn't have online content. There was not cost to the developer, once the game left their warehouse, to them anymore. It had a fixed cost to them. Now when games ship there are extended costs of that game. They pay for servers and content creators to continue to make new content/patches.

The shareholder meeting the clips came from are NO DIFFERENT than any other share holder meeting. Here let me TL:DR them all for you. "Last year we made a ton of money! *cheers* This is how we made people give us more of their money than last year! *cheers* Let me show you how we are taking all their money THIS YEAR!" *standing ovation*" Companies all want your money. Successful ones try to innovate how to get more of it. Menus in restaurants are laid out so as you read them they get more expensive. That way they 'anchor' you into prices. "Damn, the salad $14?!!? Well, the chicken is decent price at $17. Fish for $20? thats not bad at all. Wait this place is kinda expensive but the steak is ONLY $22? I'll have steak, please". Super markets put the expensive items at eye level and generic down low where you have to bend and reach. Companies make you want to spend more money, its kinda imperative to their survival.

Do game creators make tons of money? yes, yes they do. Do they use very aggressive tactics? yes, yes they do. But on an individual level know your own entertainment budget per month and stick to it. If you have $15 for any entertainment that month/week remember a ticket to watch https://www.imdb.com/title/tt4199898/ , that real movie this summer, is the same as a monthly gem card. Plan accordingly.

There are those who cant stop when they HAVE TO STOP. But there are those same issues with any vice out there- drinking, gambling, shopping. Should we shut down all alcohol because drunks exist? Should be close all casinos because gambling addicts exist? No, that wouldn't solve the root problem. America as a country has tried shutting them down and it doesn't stop the core behavior only alters how it is exhibited. Its on the individual to recognize their own self destructive behavior and seek help to break those cycles. Micro transactions aren't the cause but the trigger. There are underlying social and interpersonal reasons why individuals cant stop even though its destroying them but its not because there is a button on their phone to take money from them.

4
peugiOP•

It is not about pitchforks but rather about knowing you “enemy” (DH, yourself?) and the tactics it uses to fuel you basic instincts. I am a spender too but it is defo better to be able to spend responsibly based on this information here than just give in to whatever is planned for you.

This is about control. Or, about recognising the lack of it. If this post helped even one person, then it served its purpose.

3
ForMoreThanJustME•

My response was of a different perspective. Not framing DH as the enemy but a provider of limitless services at a cost. A greater inherit import lies in knowing yourself and your limits; with the key skill being discipline. An acute and accurate sense of self awareness is the greatest skill.

2
Dantheman616•

Yeah as someone who has come from other addictions I've surprisingly kept this under control, especially since I play castle clash as well and thats about one of the biggest gacha games out there. There is definitely a lot of psychology put into developing these games to push people to spend as much as possible but, I have to always remember that at the end of the day, is it really worth it in the long run? Yeah I enjoy the game and wouldn't mind, for the most part, supporting it. However when I see how they treat the f2pers who essentially make up the biggest group that contribute to the high player count it's off putting. I'll keep my vip0 and my hard earned my money for something that deserves it.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Dietorelle•

This is madness!🤯

1
CKRomulus•

Although I love this guys content, in the end we all have different disposable I come levels, so in summing up, it's truly only relevant to those who out spend there limits

-6
sualp12•

Oh fuck, did you just solve addiction?

10
ozymandiusz•

it makes me laugh. people (adults) who are addicted to loot boxes or microtransactions are simply weak minded or stupid.

"omg I can't stop spending money on pixels! pls help!" this is pathetic. I understand when it comes to kids but adults? it's a joke. if they are stupid enough to have problems with gambling then they deserve to be fucked by developers.

-11
peugiOP•

People are known to have destroyed their lives and lives of their close relatives over addiction of many sorts. This happens more often than you would think. Such is the nature of a human mind and we all have a preposition for it (even innocent-looking things like coffee, sweets and even carbohydrates like bread create chemical reactions in your brain that (can) lead to addiction).

When companies that sell you products abuse this well-know human flaw, it needs to be recognised, named and regulated. The affected people need to be helped, not mocked.

I would really apreciate if you stepped back a bit, thought it over and tried seeing this problem from another perspective.

5
ozymandiusz•

I know people can get screwd by addiction. I didn't deny it. don't start with coffe and bread because we are talking about loot boxes. It all comes down to not being stupid. kids are innocent, they know too little but like I said adults can blaim only themself. nobody stands right next to you and forces you to buy. it's all your decision. if you are over 18 and lose all money on pixels then by all means you are a mooron. companies abuse those moorons and make money of them. this is how it goes.

-7
eDOTiQ•

If you are over 18 and lose all your networth in the crypto bubble, maybe you deserve it.

3
ozymandiusz•

I agree. people who lost in crypto can blame only themself. their decision.

1
JarbingleMan96•

You sir, are toxic.

The only way I can make sense of your sick post is that:

  1. Your life is so meaningless that you have nothing better to do than spout ignorant crap on the internet (and make no mistake, what you said is breathtakingly ignorant).
  2. You are so disconnected from reality and human relationships that you actually believe that addiction is not a terrible thing that afflicts people and ruins lives.
  3. You struggle with addiction yourself and are coping with it through shaming other people
  4. Someone you love struggles with addiction and hurt you and so you cope by ranting on gaming online subreddits about how “it’s just a weak-mind” instead of dealing with you own pain/loss.

If it’s 1 or 2, I hope that you are downvoted into oblivion. If it’s 3 or 4, I hope you get support, and that you are downvoted into oblivion, since personal pain doesn’t justify being a toxic a-hole on the internet.

4
ozymandiusz•

why toxic? because I wrote "only stupid people can get into addiction to gambling'? facts: 1) everybody knows that going too far with gambling and loosing money is bad idea right? 2) so people know that and yet some of them still do it and they lose. I call them idiots. it might sound harsh but it is still true. It is like you see a field with mines, you know it is retarded to go through it and yet you still do it. is it wise? answer yourself. p.s. I have no problems with addictions :)

-5
iagorx7•

Doctor here. That same reasoning could be made to mock people addict to drugs like alcohol or tobacco. Just so you know, the World Health Organisation included addiction to video games in the last review of the DSM, which includes all the mental disorders recognised by psychiatrists around the world. And as you can see, in case you were using that as an argumento, it's an addiction that depends exclusively on the way your brain reacts to external stimuli and not the chemical effect that a certain substance has in your body.

And yes, that disorder includes teenagers as well as adult people who have a complex dopamine system in their brains that works exactly the same as younger people. And DH games and other companies are well aware of that and exploit it for their own benefit.

I suggest you make some research before banalizing with mental healt issues like that.

4
ozymandiusz•

tell me doc who makes decision on "buy it or not"? does anybody force you to do this? so who's fault it is?

and yes, I mock people addicted to alcochol or tabacco. why? because it is not anybody's fault but their own. you make your choices. it's your life. I can be drug addict or not. depends on what I chose.

1