codeswinwars•

This is a lot of controversy for an idea that wasn't even original when Brawl in the Family made a comic out of it a decade ago.

22
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
DreadCascadeEffect•

People will upvote anything negative about Kotaku no matter how valid the point is because they're still mad about some made up stuff from Gamergate.

-3†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

16
litewo•

He probably never even played the level; it's been an idea since MM1. What a ridiculous controversy this has turned out to be.

15
nuovian•

He probably never even played the level

He hasn't - his profile doesn't show up on the list of users who've played Mario's Remorse.

9
theth1rdchild•

Are you telling me that gamers are easily manipulated into outrage over nothing

3
McSlinkslink•

Bet you didn't play the levels huh.

1†
Tlingit_Raven•

Did because it isn't hard to since the codes are out there. They are similar in that they both use a concept that has been around since MM1 was at most a few months old, and that's it. Layout, execution, everything else is different and is better in Kohler's version anyway.

2
McSlinkslink•

Both levels start with you outside the goombas house, makes you kill them, and even has you going to hell to kill them again. I'm willing to believe that the guy this article is crediting as the original isn't the first person to do it, but I find it hard to believe it was his own 100% original idea.

0
helppls555•

Is this a full blown controversy by now? Really? I thought if anything, MM2 would have a controversy about treehouses translation

0
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
Tlingit_Raven•

Nope, there is a reason this is being removed from all the subs it is being spammed in: the site has no proof and is obviously some no-name trying to break into the scene by exploiting gamer culture and it's love of outrage.

1
Kaiserhawk•

Man, what a prick.

-1†
TheVibratingPants•

Do I really need to say it? Fuck Kotaku.

This is just another item on a laundry list of scummy shit they’ve pulled

-3†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
tenswee•

This is not an original idea.

The kotaku writer in his article is clearly aware it is not original and is entirely sarcastic about it.

Whoever wrote this article is trying to make you angry for no real reason. Don't let him.

16
theth1rdchild•

no real reason

The reason is Kotaku Bad

7
MizerokRominus•

Don't hang an entire website or organization due to the actions of one person or even three.

0†
theth1rdchild•

I meant Kotaku Bad like EA Bad, praise geraldo

They're actually just fine

2
helppls555•

Why? Why do I need to "not hang" a website due to the "hate the article/writer and not the site" nonsense?

Its a fucking gaming website. There are thousands of them out there. Sorry not sorry, but I dont give a shit and nothing of value is lost. This type of internet objectivism would be much better placed on a topic of actual value, rather than saying "please don't dismiss this video game site because of this!"

I haven't read Gamespot ever since Gerstman was fired and they showed that publisher expectations are valued higher than actual critical consensus. Do I care what they did after? No I don't, I moved on.

-2
wobblydavid•

Yikes, dude. Holding grudges is not healthy.

1
MizerokRominus•

No, why hang the entire website, including the people that did nothing wrong, on the output of a person.

Hang that person and the people that keep them in that position/people giving them work. Hanging the entire organization is only going to harm the people doing good work there.

1
litewo•

The author of this article deleted it after it was shown to be highly misleading and libelous. Since this is effectively a dead link, the mods should remove this.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

-3†
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
[deleted]•

[removed]

-4
[deleted]•

[removed]

-7†
Klugenshmirtz•

Mods removed another post because you are not allowed to change the title.

13
[deleted]•

[removed]

2†