r/BadEconomics Runs for President

With the primary season entering into full gear, we’ve seen a lot of different policy proposals bandied around by the candidates. There’s always a place here for deconstructing the bad proposals, but the wide diversity of ideas pitched has me thinking: what would r/BadEconomics’ platform look like if we ran for president? I think we could put together a platform of well evidenced economic policy proposals of a sort that could command wide respect.

To that end, we’ll be creating the r/BadEconomics Economic Platform and taking submissions from all of you for policy planks to be added to it. Once we develop a substantial enough platform, we’ll list it in the sidebar and keep it up at least until the election is over. We’ll also update it periodically as additional submissions flow in.

If you want to add your policy proposal to the platform, here’s the procedure. Submit a new text post to the subreddit starting with “Policy Proposal:” followed by a succinct title for your proposal. Then, in the text of the post, explain the policy idea and make your case for it, citing strong economic evidence along the way. If the proposal survives the discussion in the submission thread and obtains the approval of the mods, it goes in the platform. Proposals that don't cite any economic literature will, in general, be marked as insufficient.

Note that we really only want economic policy proposals. We’re not going to be hosting big moral debates about social issues or foreign policy or whatever. It’s not that these things aren’t important, but they’re also not really our comparative advantage. I know that to some degree, that sort of thing will be inevitable, but do your best to keep it, uh, technocratic let’s say. Mod fiat will keep any extreme chicanery from entering into the final platform anyway.

So, let’s see what our economic platform will be!

Posted Jul 4, 2019, 7:57 PM UTC · edited

16864
Unknwon_To_All•

I'm assuming this is things that a lot of economists can get behind?

In which case a good start might be here

Also I would add Land Value Tax. And abolish all tariffs.

47
gorbachevOPMono Means One•

I'm assuming this is things that a lot of economists can get behind?

Yeah, think consensus policy ideas that have lots of economic support. You should be able to find actual econ literature supporting that the policy really does achieve its intended (presumably desirable) consequences.

That said, this thread is not the place to make or debate specific proposals.

20
[deleted]•

[removed]

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

4
SerialkMODFixing the climate with accounting identities•

This thread is not the place to make or debate specific proposals.

Please move the discussion in the Fiat or in policy proposal threads.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

-2†
[deleted]•

[removed]

7
[deleted]•

[removed]

4
IranContraRedux•

Still missing eliminating single-family zoning.

4
sack-o-maticfilthy engineer•

The econ FAQ mentions carbon tariffs being useful.

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
gorbachevOPMono Means One•

Please put policy discussion in proposal threads only.

1
gorbachevOPMono Means One•

Put policy discussion in proposal threads only.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
Jericho_HillMODEffect Size Matters (TM)•

Dibs on being the candidate.

41
Co60•

#Trousers or bust

24
Lorpius_Prime•

Why settle for anything less than the best?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
venuswasaflytrap•

Dibs on being the target of a smear campaign so that I have to constantly disprove baseless allegations, but the fact that I argue against them only makes the public's belief in them stronger.

7
Chranny•

I'll look forward to National Meme Day.

4
ZepperMan•

Yeah, IMO the policies needs to be tied to a specific name and should be decided on by a single person.

While an oligarchy is ideal, I think a single person being the spokesperson adds to consistency, granted they are consistent on their ideals.

-2
MambaMentaIity•

When you talk about economic policy proposals, do you only mean policies that the average person would consider to be within the realm of econ, e.g. taxes, price floors/ceilings, spending, et cetera? Or does this also extend to technocratic domestic policies that aren't explicitly econ but have been researched by economists, e.g. crime deterrence?

35
gorbachevOPMono Means One•

have been researched by economists

I think that counts. Your main limitation is that you need to cite economic evidence. So if the field thinks it is econ then, for our purposes, it is.

36
DeShawnThordasonGoolsbae•

Your main limitation is that you need to cite economic evidence.

Interstellar trade policy, it is!

45
lawrencekhooHolding all other things•
30
PureOrangeJuche•

What about policy regarding economists? Like mandatory 100k minimum wages, guaranteed admission to conferences in Hawaii, etc. Commonsense policy to protect our national interests and world thought leadership.

18
lorentz65Mindless cog in the capitalist shitposting machine.•

The real most popular economist proposals would be researcher access to high quality administrative data and implementation of firm level macro expectations surveys.

16
[deleted]•

Someone with more experience and knowledge should write a section addressing the gender and racial wage gaps.

14
Jerrick_TramLabor and Urban Economics are my jam•

The tricky part with this is the BLS breaks down occupation demographics by gender and race but wages for specific occupations (ex: survey researchers) are aggregated at the county, state, and national level; not by your given criteria. Without that information, we'd have to base it on gender/race preference of specific occupations (ex: engineering is majority male while nursing is majority female) and compensating wage differentials.

*Scratch that, they do for gender.

3
historymaking101Acemoglu has noahpinions, only facts•

Trade deals with foreign policy elements allowed?

5
gorbachevOPMono Means One•

I guess it depends on what the elements are.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
gorbachevOPMono Means One•

Please put all proposals in their own submission to the subreddit.

2
BespokeDebtorReading Comprehension Shill•

Oh shit I didn't even live up to my own flair

12
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
_InnocentBystander•

Would something like a mandatory paternity and maternity leave count or is that more social than economic?

2
sack-o-maticfilthy engineer•

I mean, a lot of "social" things can be described in economic terms using utility and future productivity of the child related to how the parents each have their own leave from work.

The hard part is making that explanation.

3
gorbachevOPMono Means One•

That can count yes.

1
DrunkenAsparagus•

When's this thing going up? I'll prolly have time next week for a post on unsucking the metro.

2
gorbachevOPMono Means One•

Whenever we have enough planks. We'll be updating it continuously though.

1
SnapshillBotPaid for by The Free Market™•

Snapshots:

  1. r/BadEconomics Runs for President - archive.org, archive.today, removeddit.com

  2. r/BadEconomics - archive.org, archive.today*

I am just a simple bot, not a moderator of this subreddit | bot subreddit | contact the maintainers

1
gorbachevOPMODMono Means One•

If you have any questions about this, please post them in this thread. We'll also be collecting and listing policy proposals that make it into the final platform here as well.

That said, please submit your policy proposals as top level submissions to the subreddit (with the "Policy Proposal:" prefix) instead of as comments in this thread.

1
[deleted]•

How do you distinguish between economic proposals and social issues? Say, on the subject of Social Security. What if I were to propose no longer making SS payments to wealthy individuals, and beginning to make payments to poor and low-income individuals of all ages (kind of transitioning SS from being a retirement program for everyone to being a redistributive, negative-income-tax-adjacent program.)

That's pretty clearly a technocratic economic policy, and one that you can make arguments about it being a more efficient welfare system than our current one in some limited ways. But it is justified on the grounds of morality, and is also pretty clearly a policy with major social ramifications.

6
gorbachevOPMono Means One•

Don't overthink it. Just apply an "I know it when I see it" standard and if people disagree with your judgement, well, the mob will let you know in the comment section. And if the mods disagree with OP and the mob, well, them's the breaks.

6
[deleted]•

Fair enough, thanks.

1
j8j8a8•

When will you complete this platform?

1
gorbachevOPMono Means One•

Depends on when people submit proposals!

1
Barbarossa3141•

I wrote a post on another subreddit a while back where I proposed a major overhaul of social security, can I repost that here as a policy proposal?

1
gorbachevOPMono Means One•

Yup

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
supahotfyah•

If anybody wants to do something on land use/housing policy, I'd love to collaborate!

1
eek04•

I am interested, though starting right now I'm likely to be offline for about weeks.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1