DM obstructs removal of player threatening violence over offensive comment. Utters an offensive comment of his own in the process.

TLDR: Long Post, offending remarks in large font below. Context and sequence of events in regular font.

Our group has been playing for three years, it has had its ups and downs, players have come and gone.

At the start of the present campaign last August it was down to only four of us, due to our fifth being busier with work. With three players consisting of 'Power Gamer', 'The Committed' the DM and myself. We were dependent on NPCs as encounters were balanced for 6. It wasn't as much fun as having players so we recruited two more, let's call them Diaz and Mindy. Power Gamer recruited Diaz and the Committed recruited 'Mindy' (whom later admitted she joined under a pseudonym) in February. Even our old player, 'Comedy Gold' was eventually able to come back to the table, first having been enticed to play the villain in a one shot I hosted while the DM was unavailable (worked out incredibly well).

Then the other week at some point (I didn't hear it, could have been taking my dog out or in the bathroom).

#Diaz joked that Mindy was trying to sleep with everyone at the table.

Understandably this was an inappropriate and offensive remark. I only heard about it having called Comedy Gold to wish him a happy Canada Day whereupon he related to me that Mindy was pissed at Diaz.

Returning home, Mindy messaged me about the situation. At first she said it was his lateness and unpreparedness at the table (taking too long to resolve his turn). I said ok, I'll talk to him about it and I did. He apologized and pledged to do better saying his anxiety makes it difficult sometimes. I said showing up on time would be a good start. Then Mindy mentioned the comment and I'm in 100% agreement and on her side that it's unacceptable. But unlike before it didn't stop there, she brings up a litany of unfounded complaints and ends it saying that Diaz can shove his anxiety card up his ass and she's going to punch Diaz and 'that's a fucking promise'.

Again, I go to Diaz and I explain the situation while not 100% sure if Mindy is being hyperbolic or if the facade is cracking. Diaz says he doesn't remember saying what he said (others confirmed it) but immediately agrees to apologize. I mention that Mindy is very angry at the moment and it's probably best to wait until she's more receptive to an apology. He does but she tells him to 'go fuck himself'. I talk to Comedy Gold again the following day who says Mindy called him, screamed at him over the phone and hung up on him, twice. I get in contact with the Committed who presumable knows Mindy longer than the rest of us because he recruited her and says to me that he told her to 'stop with the violence' and that he's tired of this shit.

I've heard enough, Mindy has got to go, I'm not going to host someone in my home who is acting belligerently and after joining the group months prior won't even give her real name. While Diaz is in the wrong for what he said, he admitted fault, pledged to improve his behaviour and offered an apology whereas Mindy was belittling Diaz's disability, screaming and hanging up on people over the phone and threatening violence. What wonderful way to spend Canada day after getting out of work early.

On Wednesday I message the group sans Mindy and explain unless there's a strongly compelling reason not to, I'm going to ask Mindy to leave the group. A short while later the DM posts:

So we’re just going to completely ignore the comment that precipitated the “threat of violence” you’re so concerned about? Given the context, I’m having a lot of trouble seeing Mindy as the guilty party here.

That said, it’s your right to invite who you want to invite. Unless someone else wants to step up and host on the regular, I suppose this is the end of the REDACTED campaign, as I outright refuse to kick Mindy out of the group over this, as is my right. Please govern yourselves accordingly.

I point out that threatening to leave hurts him [DM] the most considering how much he asserted he wanted to run it during the previous campaign. The DM accuses me of emotional manipulation.

IDK, I think it's a hollow accusation considering threatening to leave when you don't get what you want is pretty close to the peak of 'Mt. Emotional Manipulation'. He's uttered such threats before at various instances during the previous campaign. When he doesn't get what he wants he nags, he undermines, he throws fits, he mopes and reminds us how close he is to rage-quitting. Anyway, getting off track.

The process gets more heated, I'm losing my patience with the DM downplaying Mindy's behaviour.

The DM says... #> That’s easy to say as a straight white male who, again, isn’t the only girl in a roomful of guys she barely knows

At this point I'm stunned because what the DM is saying isn't any different than if I were to tell the DM (who is homosexual) that the only reason he thinks something is because he's gay. It would be entirely unacceptable given how belittling and degrading it is to say that. I tell the DM that he's out of line and doubles down.

He says he's going to get 'Mindy's perspective and get back to us, never mind that four people are giving him a congruent account of events, the fifth, Power Gamer, being out of loop.

At this point Comedy Gold suggests a detente before it gets even more out of hand. For me it's late and time to sign off so I do. The next day Mindy quits the group, DM cancels this week's game in favour of a cooling off period.

I guess I'll see what happens. I mean the cooling off period isn't going to be worth much if the DM insists on bringing up everything all over again. Or if he decides to make his 'feelings' the justification for his obstructive and insulting behaviour.

In the words of Will the Wise "Can we play D&D now?"

Posted Jul 7, 2019, 1:46 PM UTC

7322
AasimarHermit•

Frankly your group would probably be better suited without the DM and mindy, diez seems repentant and whether mindy accepts the apology doesn't matter as much as him fixing his own problem behavior so such incidents don't reoccur. I at least have a 0 tolerance policy for the oppression olympics because it totally shuts down any possibility of a conversation or friendly environment. That said this is more just run of the mill interpersonal strife that happened to occur with the hobby in the backdrop.

42
PotatoQuie•

No one gets to decide when other people should accept apologies. If Mindy didn't feel the apology was earnest enough, it's her right not to accept it. I don't have all the details, so I don't know who's right or wrong here, but it's possible you're being too dismissive of Mindy/GM's perspective, at least based on the way you wrote this.

19
ameliorates•

What? It is seldom acceptable to respond to an apology with "go fuck yourself." Per OP's account (which seems to have glossed over a lot of the granular drama), Diaz seemed receptive to the feedback on both occasions and responded appropriately. So unless his apology was "haha, sorry you're such a thin-skinned bitch" there's really no reason to respond the way Mindy did. She doesn't have to accept his apology, but that is appropriately conveyed with "I appreciate your apology, but I'm not ready to accept it yet."

As a woman and a gamer, I can appreciate how irritating Diaz's comment would have been. As a woman and a person, I still don't think that's justification for lashing out and escalating the issue. We can both hold Diaz accountable for his insensitive remarks and hold Mindy accountable for her inappropriate reaction. She doesn't get a free pass to threaten violence just because her vagina was offended.

35
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

This all started with everyone being on Mindy's side. Everyone made aware of the problem agreed that Diaz's comments were unacceptable, including Diaz. Why Mindy decided to behave with belligerence and make explicit threats of violence only she can account for however she has decided not to explain herself or apologize for her own actions.

Diaz can certainly still be held accountable for his actions, but he has accepted responsibility for his behaviour, pledged not to do it again and apologized. The person so offended by his behaviour that she engaged in unjustifiably hostile behaviour of her own isn't present anymore so I don't see what else is to be done over a 'first offense'.

As for the DM, he was informed of the problem by 'Comedy Gold' the same day I was and elected to spend the day getting drunk on a holiday rather than clean up a mess. I don't blame him for that, but I do blame him for dragging me through it all over again having to justify the obvious solution to an obvious problem that he neglected to deal with much less inform himself of the facts pertaining to same.

So no, no one is able to decide when another person should accept an apology but what usually happens is the the person who behaved poorly will apologize as soon as possible after being made aware of the consequences of their actions because it's the right thing to do. That's what adults do. It's as u/ameliorates explains, you don't have to accept it but responding with 'Go Fuck Yourself' isn't appropriate.

If you want details, feel free to ask, I condensed it for brevity's sake.

18
Chaltab•

> That’s easy to say as a straight white male who, again, isn’t the only girl in a roomful of guys she barely knows

I mean, the DM isn't actually wrong there. Mindy may be overreacting, but you admit yourself that you weren't there; you don't know the whole story and didn't hear all of what Diaz said to/about her. The fact that you consider this statement as offensive as telling the DM he only thinks a certain way because he's gay indicates you're not paying attention to how privilege is stacked in this sort of group dynamic.

19
Sovereign_PC•

Oh my god, shut up. Stick your privilege up your ass. Op was being entirely respectful in his text to the dm, and the dm responded with vitriol and an argument that is bullshit.

22
[deleted]•

There's 'overreacting' and there's 'issuing explicit threats of violence. There's being protective of one's personal information and withholding introducing yourself for a six month period. To be told objecting to that is due to being a 'straight white guy' is offensive and it's easy to demonstrate by reversing the roles.

To be criticized as holding an opinion in virtue of unchangeable characteristics about ones self such as race, sexual orientation or gender is offensive because it's belittling and degrading. You haven't adequately explained why is it ok for for one person to make degrading and belittling comments, you've only referenced 'privilege stacking in a group dynamic.' However, you're not really familiar with this group are you? I've been in it for three years but you're being judgmental within all of couple hours of the story being shared. Forgive me, but I doubt you have anything insightful to share.

18
Chaltab•

You're doing that classic privileged straight guy thing where you act like someone saying 'check your privilege' is an equal offense to discrimination, which is probably why you're getting the responses you're getting. That's all I'm saying.

10†
[deleted]•

It's not 'check your privilege'. Someone I've sat across from for three years decided it was ok to be belittling and degrading in a way I would never fathom doing to him. So yes, it is offensive and discriminatory. You're doing the same thing now but given you're a stranger on the internet it comes with the territory.

29
Daggerfunk•

You're doing that classic Kafkatrap thing of dismissing a thought because it's coming from a person with immutable characteristics, trying to force compliance with circular reasoning.

Let's suss out a hypothetical scenario:

  1. OP checks his privilege
  2. OP arrives at same conclusion anyway, knowing it must be correct since his privilege has been checked
  3. DM tells OP to check his privilege again anyway, because he is a straight, white, cis male
  4. But OP has already checked his privilege

Under what circumstances do you believe OP can express the opinion that threats of violence are unacceptable?

Conversely, can you explain how, under your regime of looking at the world, a woman/LGBTQIA+/POC individual might ever be wrong and behave inappropriately, and simultaneously have that behavior correctly called out by a straight white cis male?

What threshold must that meet? Does the straight white cis male need to find a woman/LGBTQIA+/POC individual willing to commit to free emotional labor to do it on their behalf?

Please share.

28
WonderfulMeat•

I think as an 'insert our sexuality, skin colour and gender here' you don't have a right to an opinion in this matter.

Can you see how hypocritical this is? There's being aware of privilege and then there's being so woke that you turn right around to being a sexist, racist cunt.

21
[deleted]•

The funny thing is if the roles were reversed and he decided to take a screen shot and present it to my employers, friends and relations I could suffer severe consequences. But here some guy has crawled out of the woodwork to lecture me on privilege because I have the temerity to demand to be judged for my actions and behaviours the same way others expect to be.

21
CheshAmoeba•

I don’t exactly understand why the “real name” thing is an issue? Can you elaborate?

16
[deleted]•

Sure, 'Mindy' introduced herself in February and then later admitted somewhat recently (May I think) that it wasn't her real name. At the time I thought it was weird, but I didn't make an issue of it even though it had been months.

When she started making explicit threats of violence it became an issue because in the event the situation escalated further I would be unable to precisely identify her to authorities. You have to understand that in addition to written threats sent over messenger she was calling other players and screaming at them over the phone that she was going to hit Diaz. Moreover, because I had trusted her, she has access to the code to my building. What's still most astounding of all is why she escalated her hostility even after I had mediated with results including Diaz taking responsibility for his actions, pledging not to repeat them and offering an apology.

edit: Giving out my access code to the building is my own fault and I have since learned apparently I don't need to pay for a landline to have a phone capable of buzzing someone in so to my embarrassment it's a preventable situation.

27
CheshAmoeba•

I suppose my concern was that while there are reasons someone might use a fake name in bad faith - say they have a bad reputation in the local ttrpg scene - there are plenty of non-malicious reasons someone might not give their “real” name - say for instance they’re trans and don’t use their dead name.

Without the clarification and with the other unclear points people have also pointed out in comments, this story can read very differently.

13
[deleted]•

There's a case to be made for brevity, reddit does impose a character limit that I have run afoul of in the past when detailing the sequence of events and context of social drama at the RPG table.

8
SmilingBoi2468•

The moment race, sexuality, gender, religion or anything else is brought up in an unironic way someone has to go. If someone uses their identity as a genuine excuse to be an asshole then you clearly have no place in group activities.

15
wonkytonkcomp•

I'm not exactly believing this.

12
[deleted]•

It happened. I thought sharing it would make it easier to process and deal with. If it's all the same I'd prefer not to screen shot Facebook Messenger and use MS Paint to hide personal information, it seems like a lot of extra work. You can believe what you'd like.

19
Wilkin_•

I am reading this on my mobile and can not find the „remark in big font below“. So i have no clue what this is about. Someone is royally pissed about a remark and won’t accept an apology. So, how bad was it?

2
Bignholy•

" Diaz joked that Mindy was trying to sleep with everyone at the table. " is what got the anger according to OP.

" > That’s easy to say as a straight white male who, again, isn’t the only girl in a roomful of guys she barely knows " is what triggered OP.

I suspect OP either sanitized what was going on for the retelling, every person in the story is strawman-level thin skinned, or is a completely unaware "That Guy". Either way, I rather suspect we're not getting the full story on this one.

24
Wilkin_•

Thanks for clearing this up. And to be honest i doubt that i want to know the rest - this is just stupid drama, not a rpghorrorstory, has nothing to do about playing. This could have had happened during being out for eating a pizza together or going to the movies.

8