r/mensa•
Bitfroind

What do you think about IQ-Testing of children?

Where are the pros and cons? Is it a suitable tool for diagnosing giftednesd or underachievement?

Posted Jul 7, 2019, 3:26 PM UTC

37
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
ArminMazz•

The things I can come up with are:

Cons

  • IQ isn’t fixed until it reaches a peak in the 20s and since its a fact that everyone develops at different speeds it can be misleading to make a fixed plan according to IQ only. This is something that may affect potential developing abilities.
  • Informing about having a high intelligence could potentially create a narcissistic, anxious child. The anxiety is created by feeling that he or she must please and live up to the expectations of somebody with this intelligence. The youngster may feel a responsible, way larger than he or she can handle, which may ultimately lead to mental problems.

Pros

  • It can teach the child at an early stage of life that the feeling that he or she is different is not due to a ”defect”, but rather because of a diversity common in the human population. There will be strengths and weaknesses, like for everybody, and using this information one can make an attempt to alleviate the stress of the child.

I feel like it depends on how old the child is and how self-aware they are. Also the result depends on how the child has been raised.

”Are iq-tests a good tool to diagnose under-achievment/giftedness?”

It can explain underachievement but to understand the exact cause of the problems one need to discuss with the psychologist on how the different results on the tests may affect academical achievement. There’s also the possibility that there might be underlying mental disorders which the child won’t talk about, so this needs to be addressed first.

2

You always run the risk of creating an over sheltered shut-in who thinks he's superior to his peers on account of the test they gave him.

2
justcrazytalk•

I saw this young man yesterday, and he seems to be doing great. https://m.salisburypost.com/2018/11/01/this-is-where-i-shine-10-year-old-finds-a-fit-with-mensa/ He was tested and joined Mensa at age four. He gave an amazing talk at the Mensa Annual Gathering and demonstrated the robot he built and programmed. He also talked about how he plays with Hot Wheels with other kids, and his parents ensure that he is socialized.

1
TrippleThreatskrra•

Great article, however, I do wonder how they assessed him to be "profoundly gifted"?

1
justacotton•

People on the Davidson Gifted Issues forum use “profoundly gifted” to mean 145-150+ IQ sd15 so I’d imagine it’s just a typical test like WISC? Or then one of those stanford-binet ones that measure up to 180 something

2
gokartmozart928•

IQ is only one element. I'm high IQ but I haven't been a high achiever and I've been working on learning what I can do to improve. I'd recommend two things to look at "Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance" by Dr. Angela Duckworth and then look into Positive Psychology by Dr. Martin Seligman (U. Penn.), it's a system that's actually been used in school systems with significant measurable improvements in student performance. There are some pieces on YouTube and then they have a full course on Coursera.

​

Dr. Duckworth has studied a variety of groups including National Spelling Bee contestants and Westpoint students and she asserts that "grit" is twice as important as IQ and she teaches about how to help develop it.

1
[deleted]•

My main reason for having my IQ tested as a child would have been to show that I have a learning difficulty, and a somewhat spiky profile.

​

The trouble is that wouldn't have happened as someone who was in school from 1961-1975.

1