r/canada•
[deleted]

Tips to Canadian redditors who oppose Harper's bill Bill C-32 (from a redditor who's worked on Parliament Hill reading & replying to constituent correspondence)

I think it's absolutely great that r/Canada seems to be getting engaged in opposing Harper's DMCA (Bill C-32). The front page is currently littered with posts of people who are writing to the minister (Tony Clement) responsible. While I applaud the thought behind writing to the minister, I think it's important to give some maybe not-well-known tips to r/canada based on my experience:

-Writing to the minister is an absolute waste of time (sorry to burst the bubble of those who took the time to do this). The minister is the sponsor of the bill. He cannot reverse himself and oppose his own bill nor will he likely be willing to offer an amendment to his own bill since that would show that he realizes that his bill was incomplete or ill-conceived. Even though the bill is ill-conceived, the best Clement can do is accept an amendment from another MP as "friendly" to the bill which means it gets incorporated into the bill without a vote.

--Writing to anybody in cabinet is an absolute waste of time. Cabinet ministers are almost always bound by the government whip and thus couldn't vote their conscience unless they resigned from cabinet. The last person to resign from cabinet in order to vote against the government was Joe Comuzzi three years ago and he did it basically because he's ridiculously Catholic and wanted to vote against gay marriage.

-Writing to your MPs, on the other hand, IS a good use of your time. I've seen a couple of commends on reddit suggesting that writing your MP is a waste of time. I strongly disagree with this. I can tell you, from the perspective of somebody who worked on Parliament Hill and read through this stuff, we definitely do talk to our MPs about the letters they're receiving. Furthermore, MPs genuinely want to know if the quantity of mail they're getting on a subject is in the dozens or thousands range and on which side the prevailing opinion seems to tilt.

-If you do write to an MP, you should take the following into account:

a) Writing to an MP who doesn't represent your riding is usually a waste of time. The first thing I'd do when reading mail was to look at the postal code of the sender. If it wasn't located in the riding, I was basically told to pitch it out and not bother reading it. The sole exception to this was when I worked in an opposition MP's office who had a critic portfolio. In that case, he wanted to hear from everybody on that particular subject regardless of whether they were in his riding or not.

b) Make sure there are no obvious grammatical or spelling errors in prominent places. I'm not talking about misspelling the word "sesquipedalian". I'm talking about obvious and little things which suggest to a reader whether you're a serious player or not. As a general rule, if I saw a person who, in the opening line, wrote something like "Their's no reason to support this bill. Your not going to support Bill-X, are you?", I'd still reply to it just as anybody else, but my likelihood of mentioning it to my MP basically drops to zero.

c) Using a pre-written script which has been used by hundreds of other people to send to the same MP is still better than not writing at all, but it's not as good as writing something yourself (even if it's short). A short, personally written letter will get 10 times the impact as a long, drawn out cookie-cutter mass-produced letter which the staffer's read hundreds of times before.

d) Hand-written letters have at least 20 times the impact of typed letters. If you really want to drive your point home, take the same amount of time you'd normally take to type a long letter and instead write a short, personalized, handwritten letter.

e) Following your letter up with a phone call may be annoying in most other circumstances, but on Parliament Hill it does get the point across that you're a serious player. It also occupies more of the staffer's time so if you can increase your prominence in the staffer's mind, your chances of being mentioned to the MP increase dramatically. Keep in mind, getting mentioned to the MP is basically the victory every letter-writer should hope for. Think about it, if you're elected and a staffer you employ felt it important enough to mention some letter that an engaged constituent wrote, you're going to listen. You might not change your mind, you might not change your vote, but you'll definitely be interested in what the constituent has to say since it made such a large impression on your staffer.

The key thing to remember about this game is that many of these MPs may personally be opposed to DMCA but they might not think it's a big issue. Letters have by far the biggest impact in these types of people. It doesn't try to change their mind, it just provides an incentive for them to step up their opposition to a bill which they already oppose but might otherwise have been willing to let sail by because you can't swing at every pitch just as you can only send out so many press releases in a given day and you can only put so many arguments in your stump speech.

Posted Jun 3, 2010, 12:08 PM UTC

422151
RunAwayPancake•

Speaking as a redditor who works in a correspondence unit for a Federal Department what canadianleftie said is completely true.

Do not write directly to any Minister. (Unless he or she is your MP). Write to your MP or better yet go to your MP's constituency office and talk to them/their staff directly. Having an MP write on your behalf to a Department will pretty much guanrantee you a response and will generate further copies that will be sent to the various policy centers for consideration.

Never use profanity in a letter and don't be beligerent. It's the quickest way to get your letter sent to the black hole that is Records.

45
senae•

What if you're in Clements riding, though? It's been stated that he can't change the bill himself as it would basically invalidate the bill, so would a good alternative be to write the neighboring opposition MP's?

10
RunAwayPancake•

That is true. But remember with Canadian Parliament a bill has to go through 3 readings in the House and numerous committee hearings to change/discuss before it goes to Senate for the rubber stamp and then becomes law. I'm not sure at what stage this bill is in.

Here are a few things you can do.

  1. If Clement is your MP you can go to his riding office and express your displeasure with the bill and say "You're my MP and you've lost my vote because of this bill". This is a great tactic if used en-masse. Won't change the current form of the bill but it will put pressure on him as MP's are very sensitive to the mood of their own constituents.

  2. Find out who the opposition MP's are for Industry and write to them explaining your displeasure for the bill.

  3. More of a long term thing: The current batch of conservatives are old and stodgy and don't fully understand the "Information Age" and what this bill could potententially mean for the internet and digital media. In a few years when the Liberals re-take power they may rescind alot of these things the conservatives have introduced.

But also bear in mind that bills go through alot of revision when in committee. That's actually where the nuts and bolts are discussed as committes call in and interview everyone (experts, industry leaders, public, academics) who could be affected by a law and truely tease out all the potential pitfalls that could unleashed. So this bill may undergo alot of changes before it becomes law.

12
laurelrusswurm•

This one is just begun at first reading.
I have a bone to pick with your take on the situation. Age has nothing to do with it: Moore is a young pup.

The Liberals are unlikely to save the day since their Bill C-60, tabled during their last minority government, was far far worse than Bill C-61. Both Liberals and Conservatives do the bidding of big business, apparently even when the big business isn't Canadian big business. We need to USE the fact that it's a minority government, and most especially not allow EITHER Conservative or Liberal majority in the next election.

4

There was a TED talk posted not long ago about how to write an effective letter to a politician. I can't remember the exact details but it went something like this:

  • In the first paragraph thank the person for their work as your representative and try to show a little bit of respect.

  • In the second paragraph inform them of why you are writing and try to give a different perspective. In this instance we should all include information about how copyright can be damaging to consumers.

  • In the last paragraph include some information about yourself and what kind of influence you have. Politicians are influence peddlers and if they receive a letter from someone who can potentially impact 10, 20, 100 voters then they are more likely to pay attention.

  • Finish by thanking them again and encourage them to contact you should they require more information on the topic.

Does anyone have information on how to actually mail a letter to an MP? Someone told me you don't have to actually put a stamp on the envelope?

10
thnkfrsttypscnd•

You are correct, sending letters to your political representative is free, Canada Post will always deliver it. But, be sure to mail your letters to their Ottawa office, not the local office, as that rule only applies to letters sent there.

9
ZulbanQuébec•
8
mattbin•

I met with my MP last year about an issue and not only was I surprised at how positive the experience was, it also helped me get to know his office staff a little. My MP's office has since followed up on a couple of other issues for me when I've asked.

I think you really can make an impact by showing you're committed to an issue, and willing to become informed and discuss it calmly and rationally.

I'm really glad you and CanadianLeftie are posting on this topic. Even as a reasonably involved citizen, I'm learning a lot from you guys.

1
mdoddr•

Why's the hole gotta be black?

1
OneTripleZeroBritish Columbia•

Haters gonna hate.

2
blocky•

There's these things in space where gravity... never mind

1
paraedolia•

Speaking as a redditor who works in a correspondance unit for a Federal Department ...

Part b) above -- Make sure there are no obvious grammatical or spelling errors in prominent places.

1
RunAwayPancake•

correspondance = French word for correspondence

My bad. I'm in Gatineau....thanks for pointing out though.

2
johnefrancis•

very informative, thank you. What is this "handwriting" of which you speak? Is this some sort of new Apple technology?

43
feyrath•

I think it's one of the myriad of fonts installed on your system. Keep looking, it's there somewhere. If you can't find it, use Comic Sans.

11
Hypobasis•

Eh, I don't think it supports flash, I'd go with Googles 'Printing Press', it's more open and there is a lot more freedom.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Spazsquatch•

Ohhh, I get it now. This is like an old school way to communicate using some form of ancient stylus and my keypeckers.

5
xenucide•

I'm in my 20's, and I prefer my handwriting (which is quite nice) to typing or printing. I used to spend hours in school writing, since I certainly didn't have a computer on me and I was at my most bored in class. I've got the laptop thing going nowadays, but I still prefer to do things manually when I have to put a lot of thinking into it. There are some things I just can't do with a computer (including but not limited to doodling in the margins).

1
blocky•

I'm 23 and my handwriting is barely legible. I can, however, type upwards of 100 words per minute.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

I can just imagine Apple iPaper now ... multi-touch, multi-user, multi-utensil and low power :).

Except that it'll only work with Apple iPencils :(

1
wrongnumber•

Also only cost x1.5 more!

1
monolithdigitalQuébec•

iPen. It's just like a stylus, only it costs $800 and can only write documents in a proprietary format that can only be read with iGoggles. Having said that, the buzz over it is amazing, the blogosphere can't get enough.

0
[deleted]•

I wish they taught this at school.

24
one37•

I still wonder how I managed to get out of high school without anyone ever showing me how to do taxes and the importance of managing your paperwork. I'm still working on this one.

11
[deleted]•

Wow I'm not alone. I did the Civics and Careers course mandated by the Toronto District School Board and it pretty much taught me nothing about real life.

8
razzark666Ontario•

I got 100% in Careers because the work was so painfully easy that many people just didn't do any work so in the last week our teacher gave us like 10% of bonus assignments so people who just weren't doing work could pass and those of us that had done work got a ridiculously high marks... I think 8 people out of 30 got 100% and many more got above 95%

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
porcuswallabee•

What?Civics course changed my life. I met one of my best friends in that class. The music teacher teaching the class wasn't especially interested in teaching the material which gave me and my buddy time to swear at eachother and debase eachother until we were good friends

3
[deleted]•

Oh it was great leisure and socialization time. It just taught me nothing about life as a Canadian citizen.

3
eberndl•

Completely off topic: one of my friends and I once sat down and made a list of "things you should learn to do while in high school"

Doing your taxes by hand was one, another was doing research to write a well informed letter of comment to government.

We also had something about designing and carrying out an experiment to determine the answer to a testable hypothesis,something about budgetting house-hold expenses, and participating in a physical challenge (run, walk, cycle, climb, etc) to raise money for a cause.

Cause wouldn't that be SO much more useful than learning the names of the different formations that a glacier creates?

7
DilettanteOntario•

Tell your school board this. Write a letter to the director of education. They do have an impact on curriculum, and they always value student input.

2
mikemcgOntario•

My grade eight teacher always spent ten or fifteen minutes every morning discussing politics with us and how to properly interact with our government. He was pretty bad ass.

4
1esproc•

What they should really be teaching that modern politics is smoke and mirrors. Nothing is done in anyone's interest except those of the politician. It is their career, and like fuck they're going to do anything to put themselves out of a job. Politics are about appearance, and rather than admit themselves wrongs these puppets will ride their decisions out the bomb bay doors and straight into the fucking ground to save face.

2
ReleeSquirrel•

When I was in school they tought it in history class. And a little bit in math class, but that was mostly 'cause my math teacher was a nut.

1
ChiftManitoba•

Can't we just riot instead? :)

12
[deleted]•

Yes, yes you may. There's a lot to be said for rioting, I just know more about letterwriting, so I figured I'd leave the rioting tips to somebody more experienced :)

16
[deleted]•

sorry to jack the thread, but which MP do you work for?

2
[deleted]•

I've worked for two MPs in the past but I currently am a consultant for the public sector and so I don't work on the Hill anymore. I am still however doing some small pro bono consulting work with one of the MPs I worked for but because of the nature of my work (I'm writing his/her stump speech) I can't disclose who it is except to say that if you read through my past comments, it's pretty clear that I have no love for any of the political parties but that I particularly hate the Conservatives and the Liberals. You can deduce from that what you will.

2
[deleted]•

so... vive le quebec libre, comrade?

2
gordonmcdowell•

A riot can be a terrible thing.

-5
mattgrandeOntario•

Terribly FUN!

8
gordonmcdowell•

Mel Brooks? Anyone? Anyone? ... <silence />

1
RedDragons•

There are not nearly enough riots, in which the phrase "Hey look its a nerd herd!" can be utilized. This could possibly be one of them.

1
swordgeekCanada•

So my MP is Jim Prentice. Guess I'm screwed.

8
MrG•

Sorry swordgeek, I see your Jim Prentice and raise you a Rob Anders. Royal Flush. I win.

5
TheUberDork•

Stephen Harper; you may tremble in fear that my MP spends even less time representing my wishes in parliament then both of yours combined.

5
swordgeekCanada•

You...might win this round.

The problem is that there are so many "winning" hands to choose from!

3
cecilkorikAlberta•

We're both in the same boat. I love this neighborhood, but oh, I hate this riding.

1
mattbin•

Prentice is one of the few MPs who's written back to me after I've written him as a non-constituent. He voted for the same-sex marriage bill in 2005 because (according to his letter) although he was personally opposed, the opinions of his constituents and his understanding of the constitution led him to believe that it was the right thing to do.

I haven't been impressed with him much since then, but I haven't read a letter anything like that from an MP, ever.

3
swordgeekCanada•

Interesting.

When the liberals were in power, he was fairly responsive. I wrote to him on two occasions, and he got back to me fairly quickly with a real response. I may have disagreed, but he at least was involved and thoughtful.
When the conservatives got in, he very quickly switched to form letters at best. When I wrote to him about Bill C-61 (when he was both my MP and the minister responsible), he didn't reply at all, other than a card saying "your letter has been received, and will be read eventually." A second letter on the subject got the same card, and then six months (!) later, a reply from the man himself, saying in effect, "The great and noble Stephen Harper is taking back this country from the liberals and the pirates, and anybody who opposes him is suspect. Besides, why are you writing to ME? Go talk to the minister responsible!"

Yep, he delayed his reply until a cabinet shuffle gave his portfolio away, and then claimed he never had anything to do with it.

2
mattbin•

I think you've nailed it: he was a different kind of MP in opposition from the MP he is in government. The fact that he'll be a frontrunner in the race to succeed Harper doesn't help, either. What a shame.

1
AmyGrace•

I got some really flaky reply from him about C-61 as well. It was more or less a long-winded, 6 month late version of him saying "I hear what you're saying, but you're wrong and I'm going to ignore you."

1
2112Lerxst•

I am also dissuaded to write in, I'm in Jim Flaherty's riding.

1
knucklehead2•
  • What about distributing pamphlets in their ridings stating that Bill C-32 would protect pedophiles and cyber-terrorists behind the flimsy technicality of a 'digital lock', and that Bill C-32 is only being introduced because media companies want to sell the the same product many different times and have made some modest donations to have the bill they wrote passed into law?

  • how about giving a seminar at the local seniors centre informing them they are potentially liable to a 1 million dollar fine and five years in jail every time they play a song from a CD on a stereo that unbeknownst to them violates the 'digital lock' by buffering the track into an unauthorized RAM chip? even worse, draining precious legal resources from our justice system to bankrupt honest people like them

would that be effective?

8
jeannaimard•

How about simply telling immigrants that they will no longer be able to watch DVDs from the country they come from?

1
shiduke•

What effect would a protest in a provincial capital have? Is there a least number of people needed to make it effective? Is it alright to do it in front of the provincial building?

5
hearforthepuns•

If you need to ask permission to protest, I think you might be doing it wrong.

7
shiduke•

Alright in the sense of useful, if that was not clear.

5
hearforthepuns•

My opinion based on zero experience in the matter tells me that the most effective actions are going to be economic. MPs don't care if a bunch of hippies (in their eyes) yell in the street.

1
thnkfrsttypscnd•

MP's care about one thing, being re-elected. Threaten their job and they will listen to you!

1
thnkfrsttypscnd•

Sure. The Conservatives did just that over a year ago when there was all this talk of a coalition. They arranged these artificial protests in front of every provincial capital building across the country. It was all artificial, mind you, but the media ate it up and people in the general public thought it was legit.

In fact, having a coordinated protest across the country in front of every legislature sends a message about how organized and passionate the protesters are.

There is no minimum number of people needed to make it effective, but the more people ultimately the more powerful the message.

2
cheek_blushenerQuébec•

so could someone please distil the bullet points of why you feel the bill is flawed? Anyone on the same page as Michael Geist?

5
universl•

As long as breaking DRM is illegal there's nothing gained from the bill except the legalization of things that are already practically legal. The most trumped up right they are granting you is the already legal ability to back up dead unprotected formats, like CDs. Wooo.

One of the things that really bothers me is that the bill makes it illegal for you to hold onto your recorded tv. What kind of fucked up policy is that?

7
freekillCanada•

My concern with the digital lock provisions is that it's a way of circumventing established policy. Take this for example: If you are currently an active cable subscriber, I believe currently it would be hard to make a case against you for downloading bittorrented television episodes because it could be argued that they are backup/personal copies no different than a VHS or PVR copy because you are a cable subscriber.

With the new digital lock provisions, downloading an episode of a television show would violate the locks in place on cable channels making your downloaded TV show illegal and allowing for damages.

Almost every piece of media people consume currently comes with something that could easily be argued as a digital lock. That makes virtually everything open for damages with the right lawyer arguing the case...

6
gollumullog•

The CBC article about this is very well laid out I found. http://www.cbc.ca/technology/story/2010/06/02/copyright-bill-clement-montreal.html

In my opinion the bill only really fails in the section regarding digital locks. I still am not sure how to word my position though, so waiting for some more info from michaelgeist.ca

I think that private use of breaking digital locks should be allowed, and the provisions that "encouraging, or promoting the breaking of locks" would be illegal as well, should be removed.

5
tpurves•

The bill is not terrible. Michael Geist makes some good points about aspects of the bill that are OK or better compromises than what was there before.

The issue is with the anti-circumvention provisions which trump fair dealings or any other exceptions. Everyone should go read Geist's analysis.

3
laurelrusswurm•

It IS terrible as long as anti-circumvention is supreme. Because it will negate all the supposed good things.

2
thnkfrsttypscnd•

A better piece of crap is still a piece of crap!

Yes there are improvements over the first bill, but really all they did was add a few carrots to placate the general public, then add some more sticks to their arsenal.

The fact that a fair-use doctrine was still not added - instead they narrowly define certain explicit exceptions which any lawyer can argue around and is still trumped by the anti-circumvention provision - is enough reason by its self to oppose the bill, if you ask me.

1
thnkfrsttypscnd•

I work in government and routinely hear MPs refer to "The Facebooks" and the important need to send "Twitterers". There is no understanding around these hallowed halls of technology, how to use it or its consequences.

The Reddit community has the power to really wow these guys with minimal effort, computer coordinated advocacy campaigns using off the shelf, open-source technology seems real to these people. I'd be willing to work with anyone that has any ideas and wants to build something. Just reply here and we can figure out how to get in touch and make this happen.

5
ReleeSquirrel•

How long should a good letter to an MP be? I'm not sure if I should just declare my personal opposition to the bill, or go into details about what's wrong with it, or write a whole fricking essay about the problems with copyright reform and the technical nature of DRM and digital locks?

I figure in any scenario I'll offer to give a second and more personal explanation, due to the importance of the issue.

4
vsTerminus•

Everyone gets a case of the tldr's. Especially your MP.

Short. Concise. To the point.

Express your concern, state your biggest specific problem with it, and give a short example.

Thank them kindly and sign your name :)

3
ttoyooka•

This is a fantastic primer on democratic involvement that should be disseminated to all citizens across the country. Thank you.

4
adaminc•

Make sure if you write a handwritten letter to seal the envelope with a wax seal!

4
1esproc•

Be sure to tip your horsebacked deliveryman with a bottle of fine whiskey! For authenticity, do the hand off at night, preferably in inclement weather.

3
cecilkorikAlberta•

Actually, give him two, and have him give one of them to the MP along with the letter. That'll get some attention. It's not bribery, it's "lobbying".

2
[deleted]•

You joke, but if I'd ever seen that in my time on Parliament Hill, that would have totally made my day! I'd have made damn sure to mention at least the stationary to everybody I knew.

1
adaminc•

I have a wax stamper with my initials on it, I don't have any cool red wax though.

Maybe I will go buy a red candle, and then give Colin Carrie a piece of my mind. Wax and all!

1
ZulbanQuébec•

TED talk on how to interact with a politician. Very similar to what's been said here.

4
terato•

Thanks for the great tips. I'd always wondered why one would bother writing to the minister, rather than (or in addition to) your own representative, and it's good to know it's a waste of time.

3
mooky1977•

What if your MP is a cabinet minister? :( Mine is the douchebag Jim Prentice and all I ever get back is form letter style answers that come straight out of the Conservative policy book.

3
[deleted]•

Mail the opposition critics for industry. They'd love to hear from you especially if you have a story about being ignored by your Conservative MP.

2
Hypobasis•

So uh, Here's my MP. Because I live in the middle of nowhere, there's a good chance nobody's sent him an email about this stuff. Should I send him an email, or go with snail mail?

Hell, I don't even know what to say other than "I don't like this bill". I suck at this sort of thing.

3
kingtrewq•

Write out the other letters that redditors posted before and snail mail it to him. Since he doesn't get much mail, it'll seem like a big issue to him.

1
purelithium•

No shit, i went to high school in wingham!

1
Hypobasis•

I went to high school in Clinton, so much better than wing-ham.

1
thnkfrsttypscnd•

I agree with this post save for the first point. You should write to the minister responsible (Clement) and register your displeasure with the bill making sure that you CC his official critics (Liberal: Marc Garneau, NDP: Brian Masse). That gives the critics fodder to use against them.

3
RedDragons•

This is one of the most informative things that I have read on Reddit in a long time. Awesome! I see that my MP has multiple addresses. Ottawa and the local constituency. Which is the better location to send a handwritten message to?

3
[deleted]•

Either works. The constituency offices deal with constituents pretty much 100% of the time, so they're the obvious choice. They're also better if you want to arrange a meeting with your MP. However, the MP spends 5 out of 7 days a week in Ottawa, so writing here can be a good strategy too.

1