Aren't SIPP & ISA a Home Country Bias?

Kind of theoretical here, as I can't think of an easy way to prevent this with the current banking system.

​

We go to great lengths to ensure our money is invested in a diversified, worldwide, balanced and weighted portfolio - to avoid having a home bias. However, our money is totally tied up in the financial future of our home nation in the form of SIPPs, ISAs and our bank accounts.

​

As you should all know, Cyprus, an EU country had a bail in a few years ago - in which the government literally stole money from the citizens. Anyone with over €100,000 had part of their savings and pensions stolen by their government. This was illegal and unthinkable the day before it happened. Government changed the law, because they can.

​

Not really talking about Brexit, or the next 10 years... but if income inequality gets worse over the next few decades; people who aren't saving for a pension/ISA today realise how little they have in a few years; people get violent and protest; the poor target the rich and people end up getting killed on both sides; a few other European countries enact a policy in which they seize funds from the 'wealthy' (those with over £1m in pensionable assets) to give to those that haven't saved throughout the years to prevent any further wide scale civil unrest. This would likely prove a popular policy with the vast majority of the population that would stand to gain.

​

As I said, completely theoretical but it does seem like a weakness to have 100% of your money tied up with the financial future (and decision-making process) of just 1 government. We are already seeing today how feeble our system of government truly is.

Posted Jul 10, 2019, 10:45 AM UTC

79
verbify•

The levy was 6.7% for deposits up to €100,000 and 9.9% for higher deposits, was announced on all domestic bank accounts. Savers were due to be compensated with shares in their banks. The banks would otherwise fail, so I'm not sure if this is the government stealing the money - if there was a run on the banks, people could've lost almost everything. This is a bit like if UK banks were to fail - FSCS insures up to 85k, the rest would potentially be lost.

To be honest, this isn't much more than a bad bear market. In 2007-09, the S&P 5000 lost approximately 50% of its value.

If you want to diversify beyond the UK, you're welcome to setup bank accounts in other countries, and split your wealth that way. Fundamentally, you can't protect against every eventuality, and a run on UK banks or pensions seems unlikely.

5
emergepythonOP•

Savers were due to be compensated with shares in their banks. The banks would otherwise fail, so I'm not sure if this is the government stealing the money

​

If an individual or company had done this, you would be legally recompensed for theft. As I understand it, the shares were practically worthless.

​

Anyway, I don't want to focus too much on Cyprus. My point was simply that a similar thing had happened, and so it's not beyond the scope of a modern government within Europe to effectively 'steal' or 'use' pensions and savings from the citizens without their permission, to solve a political issue.

2
MrDarkn3ss•

Not an expert but my initial thought is that the benefits outweigh the risk. The SIPP and ISA and whatever else are all very good methods for saving. So whilst the risk you mention exists, the probability of it is slim, and thus not worth sacrificing the aforementioned saving methods.

4
istareatscreens•

ISA is probably OK. You can pretty much sell an ETF and transfer the cash to your bank same day and from there into your offshore bank, bitcoin, whatever.

SIPPs are more of a risk due to the lock in.

On a macro level you could potentially see the UK ISAs/SIPPs as a juicy future target for those EU nations that don't have a similar individual investing culture - assuming we are still in the EU at that time.

3
grizgalonfire•

Cyprus had no choice as it’s in the Euro. The UK has its own currency so can set interest rates, print money etc and don’t need bail ins. Alternatively, if you are really worried, hold crypto where no one knows you have it or how much and no one can take it from you!

1
emergepythonOP•

Yes, I guess in the future we will have some form of borderless bank account, that's stable (little to no volatility), and no government or institution can take funds from in a political crisis.

1
Doubleday888•

It is another form of concentration risk I guess.

It depends what premium you want to pay for the protection really. For a real financial meltdown some say you want physical precious metals and maybe foreign currencies. Or for more apocalyptic ones a shotgun and a lifetime of tinned beans.

Having accounts in different countries might help in the circumstances you outline, but you might have to pay the premium of effort, dealing with different taxes or regulations and losing out on ISA and pension tax advantages. Or you could get physical share certificates of foreign companies and lock them in your safe.

In general people think things are bleak and this feeling generally increases as you age. Our government may be feeble, but the economy fundamentally carries on.

The best option all around is for most people to continue to believe in it the system. That gives the most people a stake in making sure it continues. It could all collapse, and on a long enough timeline eventually will, but I'll keep playing the cards as they're dealt.

​

p.s. I wouldn't automatically assume that because something would benefit the majority it will get enacted. Very high tax rates on the top 5% of earners might benefit the bottom 95%. The majority support cannabis decriminalisation and the continuation of the hunting ban. Doesn't mean those things will happen. Even in a democracy power is much more complex than that.

1
emergepythonOP•

I wouldn't automatically assume that because something would benefit the majority it will get enacted.

​

Understood. However, this situation would be exceptional circumstances. If there are literally riots on the streets and violence between the haves and the have nots.

​

I have family members in their 30s on minimum wage, in mountains of debt, living with parents (who don't own their house), with zero savings, and no prospect of ever owning any assets. Doubtful they will ever have £1000 saved up in their lives. I don't think their situation is uncommon. I really wonder how the government is going to have the money to pay for all of their clothes, food, material wants (ie. iPhone of the day), along with their housing, and healthcare for decades - and keep them happy whilst they watch others enjoying a seven figure pension pot.

1
Doubleday888•

Yeah. I don't know really.

But if we've ordered society so badly (and as before it's those with the most who tend to have the biggest say on how things are run) that the only way to stop bloodshed on the streets is to tax the rich /appropriate assets retrospectively then it's probably a price worth paying if you are rich.

I'd rather not rely on bread and circuses, or totalitarianism, but if those are the only option we need to be trying to change things now.

Maybe spreading your accounts internationally might help you avoid this.

Personally I'm more concerned with issues that will have effects beyond national borders. Climate change, robotisation, ageing populations etc.

1