Alternate Use for Divination Spell
Divination spells don't tend to come up all that often in the games I play in or run. At least not the 'predict the future' types of divination spells I mean. Maybe it's just that they don't provide a lot of 'solid' benefit for the costs compared to say a detection (Detect Magic) or spying divination spell.
Sometimes the answer to a simple question isn't so simple such as 'will we prevail in today's battle against X'. Instead of a cryptic reply akin to a Divine Magic 8-Ball I think an alternative way to execute the spell is to say 'roll initiative'. Let the party 'fight' the battle as the resolution of the Divination spell to answer the PC's question. This has added benefits of being able to demonstrate unique abilities a monster may possess or particularly deadly surprises it has up its sleeve without the consequences of facing it 'for reals'. The spinoff benefit is if the PCs have a way to preview fights then the DM has the opportunity to turn up the difficulty by adding more elements to the encounter.
Posted Jul 14, 2019, 1:39 AM UTC
I feel like that would be a really high level divination spell though. Probably around 7th or 8th level at the lowest.
Compare it to the most powerful "premonition" divination spells available at the moment, Scrying and Commune. Both of these are 5th level.
Scrying lets you watch a target for a limited amount of time. But they have to fail their save and the save is changed depending on how well you know them and if you have something connected to them.
Commune lets you ask a three questions and have them answered by a deity or similar force. The best part about this spell is that it's a ritual, so you can cast it as many times as you like provided you have the time. But it doesn't always work if you cast it repeatedly. And it comes at the cost that the answers may be answered with half truths or vaguely if the deity doesn't like the question for whatever reason.
Being able to play out an entire fight before it even happens sounds like some really high level magic and way stronger than either of these two spells.