In the US, everyone should be required to do civil or military service, at their discretion if they're fit for both, from ages 18-21. After that college or advanced vocational training should be free.

American youth are in great need of a sense of purpose and direction, as well as learning how to do work. Forcing everyone regardless of income or education to do a couple years of civil service or military service would benefit our population greatly, both in terms of direct benefits to the country, and indirect benefits by strengthening our population as a whole.

Posted Jul 14, 2019, 6:36 AM UTC

1135
Glass_bonesNo god or kings. Only man•

Forcing everyone regardless of income

There would be so many loopholes in this system for rich people it would look like swiss cheese, guaranteed.

11
PureGuava86•

The loophole is photoshopping yourself into a picture of your military unit.

Looking at you, University of SoCal.

4
RemoteProviderOP•

No, I'm talking about a system that includes everyone. No exceptions.

1
Naos210•

Yes, because having a ton of people in the military who don't give a fuck (and will likely not be of benefit to a lot of people) will for sure be productive.

4
Glass_bonesNo god or kings. Only man•

hypothetically might be a good thing, definitely won't happen though.

1
Liam_Neesons_Oscar•

That could never happen in the US. There would be exceptions.

1
NinjaNerd99•

Forced Military service is no longer necessary, or desirable.

7

Yeah, we aren't a tiny country. We don't need to force people in it.

2
vipin14•

I think a forced military service isn’t a good way to go the time between 18-21 is an important learning period and military work wouldn’t give much help to real life but I could see how the civil service could be helpful. I like the system but anything forced is just a no go.

3
Naos210•

No one should be forced, but I hope you're under 21.

2
RemoteProviderOP•

I'm just over, but I'd gladly put in my three years if this became law.

0
Liam_Neesons_Oscar•

If you didn't already, then no, you wouldn't have. You can still enlist now if you genuinely think it's the "right thing to do" across the board for everyone.

But you think you're special. Only other people should have to serve... you have more important things to do. You're the one they should be serving.

0
RemoteProviderOP•

Aww, cute - you don't think anyone can be different than yourself, and you project that on to others!

0
Liam_Neesons_Oscar•

That statement makes no sense...

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

Why should i be forced to go into a military that accomplishes nothing

2
UnpopularOpinionModsMOD•

Is this a Popular or Unpopular opinion? Please reply to this comment with either 'popular' or 'unpopular'

#Please do not vote on your own submissions.

Current Votes:

PopularUnpopular
05
1
_corsarius_•

Unpopular

1
darthskids•

unpopular

1
vipin14•

Unpopular

1
strawberryqueen01•

Unpopular

1
Liam_Neesons_Oscar•

Unpopular

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
_corsarius_•

Yeah... no one's in need of sense and direction

1
RemoteProviderOP•

Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, and Snapchat all say you're wrong.

3
_corsarius_•

Lol, so the argument boils down to "I don't understand the way the younger generations interact, so they must be doing it wrong."

1
BaathistYouth•

Are you retarded? Look at our levels of depression

2
_corsarius_•

So let's add PTSD on top of that, great idea

2
ByronicCommando•

The German system.

Also note how you mentioned "required military service", and everyone seems to have lost enough of their shit to completely gloss over your mentioning "required civil service" immediately afterward.

1
infinite_five•

Eh as long as it’s not forced military service and there are options for people, I’m fine with it. However, 18-21 isn’t a good idea. It should be like. A year, and it should be after summer is over post-graduation, not eighteen. I graduated a few weeks after I hit nineteen, so that wouldn’t have worked for me.

1
Noporopo79•

The idea of mandatory military service is everything democracy is trying to stop

1
Aspyr99•

71% of applicants of that age are either too fat dumb or drug addicts and are immediately disqualified from service.

https://www.theamericanconservative.com/articles/the-recruitment-problem-the-military-doesnt-want-to-talk-about/

Here’s the arithmetic: one in three potential recruits are disqualified from service because they’re overweight, one in four cannot meet minimal educational standards (a high school diploma or GED equivalent), and one in 10 have a criminal history. In plain terms, about 71 percent of 18-to-24-year-olds (the military’s target pool of potential recruits) are disqualified from the minute they enter a recruiting station: that’s 24 million out of 34 million Americans. The good news is that while the military takes pride in attracting those who are fit, educated, law abiding, and drug-free, they’re having difficulty finding them—manifestly because fewer of them actually exist.

1
levi345Obama was nice, but a bad president•

I fell like that's unnecessary and would just be a huge expense for the government. Places like isreal actually need stuff like this.

1
this_bruins_guy•

Lol hell nah I'm in service right now and there are already so many POSs amongst us I don't want anymore that are forced to be there

1
The_Tomahawker_Eat My Ass•

I do not agree. Do you not know how the Vietnam war went? People were being forced to fight for a war that they did not agree with. Several people were shot in an anti draft protest at a college in Ohio I believe. Drafting is the most stupid thing a country can do.

1