r/singapore•
Caffae

Computer Science PhDs in Singapore?

I'm looking to do a PhD in Computer Science - currently an AI graduate. But I'm not really sure whether I should do it in Singapore, or even which uni in Singapore is good for research QAQ

I heard you should focus on finding a good advisor but also that the first year of PhD is a lot of literature review on the existing field so you can figure out what question you are interested in.

Would love to hear from current com. sci post-grads on what your experience is like.

Posted Jul 14, 2019, 7:13 PM UTC

3434
integrationengineer•

I did my post graduate studies in Computer Science and "droppped out" with a masters after 2 years.

I can't say what the job prospect with a PhD in CS looks like beyond academia or data scientist - but I think you need to ask yourself - why a PhD? This is a 4 - 5 year long program which requires substantial commitment, and will cost you hundreds of thousands of dollars in future income (the PhD program is free because you will likely get a scholarship with a living stipend). That's lost of income for ~5 years. And then lost of increments over your entire working career!

Back in my time, after your first year, you will sit for your QET (qualifying exams). There are two papers you sit for - for each you will attempt 3 of 4 questions. Each question is a long question that spans one area of Computer Science (i.e. Networks, Database, Programming Languages, Algorithms, etc) set back a domain expert in that area - 8 professors setting a question of their expertise (you are expected to pass all 6 you attempt). You get 2 tries. If you fail, you drop out with a Masters, so it's not all for nothing.

Prepare to do a lot of literature review. That will enable you to start your own explorative research, which would enable you to obtain new findings. This is the HARD part. You will fail hundreds of times before you succeed and the absolute worst part for me was not knowing when I would be able to come up with something that works. Unfortunately for me, I ran out of motivation before I did and simply quit (with a Masters).

29
SpectacularGeek•

simply quit (with a Masters).

May I ask what are the potential career paths (purely management or technical) that are opened after acquiring Masters, as compared to just bachelors?

5
integrationengineer•

I think that the degree awarded has little in influencing career paths. My research experience taught me problem solving.

In short, you could be in management or as an individual contributor no matter your level of education. As an example, a PhD could be an individual contributor (Data Scientist), or a manager (Data Sci Manager).

6
CaffaeOP•

Thats actually really helpful.

So do you decide on a specific domain you are interested in before you apply? Because the QET seems like a rather general exam...

Also how do you quit with a Masters? Is that like the default result of stopping your PhD?

3
integrationengineer•

The QET covers 8 major areas of Computer Science (I cited a few of them). You know in general what those areas are, and you have access to past year papers to see for yourself the level of difficulty those questions can be, so you are not completely in the blind.

However, there are no lectures/tutorials to prepare you for them. It is entirely self study.

To complete the Graduate Program with a masters, you still need to write a Masters Thesis (in research). The research bar for a Masters is a lot lower - you don't need any improvements or submit any papers or attend a thesis defense. The effort as compared to a PhD is way lower - it's just a matter of consolidating my findings and writing them down.

Hope this helps.

5
Polymath_B19•

Really comprehensive and honest answer, refreshing in the realm of Reddit

1
ComradeSg•

👍

1
pocketaces27•

If you really want to invest your career in a phd, i recommend trying to apply to MIT, Berkeley, Stanford. Don't waste your time in Sg universities.

21
WittyKap0•

This is the only real answer.

On top of that job opportunities are much better there in every aspect.

14
xolpxolpxolp🤯🥴🤓•

I think that's something that should be deeply considered by OP. A PhD is often a good path towards migration, and it's helpful to choose a country that has a thriving and robust academia and industry.

8
skatyboyno littering•

On top of that job opportunities are much better there in every aspect.

Yes, but you would compete globally and for those "research jobs", connections and research quality matter (hence, yes, Stanford would be much better than SG unis). Even then, not all MIT/Stanford PhDs end up working on Google Brain or "cutting edge" research. In fact, your average PhD grad who wants to join industry would end up being a code monkey at Google/Facebook/Amazon, albeit with a slightly better pay

(Source: did my internship in a Big 4 in the Bay Area, a lot of PhDs from reputable universities doing mundane stuff like ML tuning, something that doesn't need skills learnt from a PhD)

5
WittyKap0•

Agreed but you have a lot more decent startups to choose from and a lot more opportunities from US companies in general.

Even after taxes its probably much better than anything you can get in sg.

Fresh PhD: 230k USD in SoCal for a non-FAANG tech firm (very avg candidate) or 80-90k sgd for a postdoc role at NUS/ASTAR. 120k sgd in local industry if you are truly truly exceptional

All concrete substantiated salaries btw

8
skatyboyno littering•

230K USD is, ironically, also around how much you can earn after 4 years in the industry in Bay Area, which by the way, hires SG CS graduates (given H1B1, I have a lot of friends there from NUS/NTU).

So, to be fair, not much "gain" lah. In fact, OP would not earn that 4 years living as a PhD, as compared to someone who joins industry in the US, which can amount to around 300K USD in savings/investments (minus moderate living costs). Hence why most people say CS PhD is "not worth" the opportunity cost.

Unless OP can make it to actual research positions in those FAANGs, which pays up to 500k, I don't see how money should be the main factor.

6
skatyboyno littering•

But on the flipside, OP has to really live frugally. CS PhD outside of NUS (which offers things like industrial PhD or full time tutorship, with like $5-6k a month stipend) won't give that much of a stipend. Plus US PhD stipends are taxed, unfortunately and with places like you mentioned, the CoL would be worse than in Singapore.

If OP is really set on getting a PhD, money won't and should not be a factor. Also, while MIT/Berkley/Stanford have "brand names", OP should see which universities are strong at which area. I mean, for AI, those universities are leading, but for areas like theoretical CS or Programming Languages, those universities might not have a strong research team in those fields.

It seems that OP chose Singapore for a reason, someone who is dead set on a PhD would not look at SG Phd programmes first and would try other countries with better research groups.

3
CaffaeOP•

I chose Singapore because I live here :') but I'm looking at other countries because I heard that when looking for a PhD you should look at the research groups instead of brand name unis. Also SG has scholarships... ^__^

5
mikemarvel21•

Rabbit's Ph.D. Thesis Scene It's a fine sunny day in the forest, and a rabbit is sitting outside his burrow, tippy-tapping on his typewriter. Along comes a fox, out for a walk.

Fox "What are you working on?" Rabbit "My thesis." Fox "Hmmm. What's it about?" Rabbit "Oh, I'm writing about how rabbits eat foxes." (incredulous pause)

Fox "That's ridiculous! Any fool knows that rabbits don't eat foxes." Rabbit "Sure they do, and I can prove it. Come with me." They both disappear into the rabbit's burrow. After a few minutes, the rabbit returns, alone, to his typewriter and resumes typing.

Soon, a wolf comes along and stops to watch the hardworking rabbit.

Wolf "What's that you're writing?" Rabbit "I'm doing a thesis on how rabbits eat wolves." (loud guffaws)

Wolf "You don't expect to get such rubbish published, do you?" Rabbit "No problem. Do you want to see why?" The rabbit and the wolf go into the burrow, and again the rabbit returns by himself, after a few minutes, and goes back to typing.

Scene: inside the rabbit's burrow. In one corner, there is a pile of fox bones. In another corner, a pile of wolf bones. On the other side of the room, a huge lion is belching and picking his teeth.

(The End)

Moral It doesn't matter what you choose for a thesis subject. It doesn't matter what you use for data.

What does matter is who you have for a thesis advisor.

Source https://www.cs.hmc.edu/~fleck/parable.html

18
confused_cereal•

NUS graduate here currently doing a CS phd abroad. You haven't really given much details for what your preferred research area is, so its hard to give any advice at all. AI is quite broad --- it can range from purely applied areas like vision, speech, NLP (or some mix of the above), to "core ML", e.g., statistical ML, probabilistic modeling/inference, or to planning/decision making, or to more occult areas like ML-systems, fairness, privacy, game theory and whatnot. Research areas aside, you'd also want to ask yourself --- are you the type who prefers to spend all your time tuning, testing and debugging models, or the type who spends days staring at and deriving theorems, or somewhere in between?

Btw, first year is not necessarily a lot of lit review, especially for CS (and most definitely for most subfields of AI). It is often the case that the advisor has some vague idea of what you'd do (this is where your funding source matters), and thats where you start off. In some schools, you do lab rotations and participate in small research projects to discover your preferences. I heard this is/was the case for NUS a few years back.

Many redditors here are gonna tell you that its not worthwhile as far as monetary return is concerned, and well, they're right, for the most part, unless you're damn sure you can get into one of the big companies labs after you graduate. A PhD has never been about earning big bucks anyway. That said, you do have some very niche and marketable skills as far as research goes--- in particular, you'd have a much better grasp of critical thinking, writing and a *much* better foundation in whatever field you choose to specialize in. My (personal) take is that these will be very much in demand in future. Virtually all recruiters in respectable companies for research related jobs headhunt PhD students/graduates, even for "boring" jobs like tuning, and theres a good reason for that.

Definitely apply abroad if possible, barring any personal constraints. Even more so if you studied locally for your undergrad. NUS/NTU are decent, but not great...

Feel free to PM me for more details.

5
WittyKap0•

Just to second this.

Stanford CS PhD is quite punishing with exrremely challenging quals or so I've heard.

You have to be on top of your game academically (meaning deep understanding) in a few different areas of specialization. On top of finding and securing an advisor during the same amount of time.

Some other schools have it a lot easier.

That said even if you flunk out you will have a Stanford CS Masters which is probably enough to get you into most any job you want

3
DiddlyDanq•

Comp sci with a masters graduate here. As others have stated, make sure you've researched what the actual benefits of the phd are before pursuing it in terms of job opportunities, salaries etc. A lot of post grads continue because theyre unsure what to do outside of acadamia and use it to buy more time at the cost of a lot of debt.

2
archchroot•

Sorry but what is an AI graduate? Are you a CS grad that specialised in AI?

1
CaffaeOP•

I have a bachelor's of engineering, but pretty much studied computer science focusing on artificial intelligence

2
archchroot•

Ah, so you must be one of those who didn't study hard enough to get to CS, but still wanted to pretend to be able to do CS, so you had to take engineering and constantly whine on your university's confession page on why you aren't allocated mods meant for CS majors, as an engineering major. Am I right?

-15
CaffaeOP•

not really...

4
WittyKap0•

What an insufferable dick.

In my time at uni CS majors were seen as those whose math was too poor to do engineering

3
archchroot•

Who gives a fuck about what happened during your time? Wake up. Mata don't wear shorts any more. Local engineers are no longer valued by their employers because it's just so much cheaper to hire foreign engineers. Unless you are the 5-15% of the university cohort that is really passionate about engineering, you are not there by choice. You are there because you are not good enough to be in CS, and cannot reap the benefits and the abundant amount of jobs that CS provides.

Downvote me all you want, go ahead. You can't deny that there is truth in what I am saying.

-4
yourstru1yEverybody just do your part•

OP isn't whining or anything. What happened to you? Are you ok?

2
hotsplat•

With your background in AI and Comp Sci, I would go into cyber and apply some of those machine learning and statistics skills to find threat actors in networks. Unis and national agencies will be throwing funding at you and you will be snapped up for big bucks once your thesis is done.

If that is your cup of tea, then I would shop around for a uni that has a good cyber/ai program.

-11
WittyKap0•

Edit: original comment was unnecessarily rude.

In any case, there are too many things that need to go right for someone to earn "big bucks" fresh out of school if they focus on cybersec AI. They need a significant breakthrough result and an organization with strong desire for that specific expertise as well.

Cybersec problem statements can be very specific and the overall job pool is too small IMO. Far safer to try other application domains unless you have a deep interest in cybersec

5
hotsplat•

Depends on your definition of big bucks I guess. I am hiring them in SG and that’s where I see the biggest gap. People with this skill combination are like unicorns so if you have some PhDs or masters in your back pocket with AI/Cyber background looking for a gig, I am happy to meet with them.

1
WittyKap0•

IMO it's easier for AI/ML trained PhD to pick up enough cybersecurity concepts by collaboration with domain experts than the other way around. Do you really need a unicorn guy experienced in both?

I myself have had some experience with scoping and assisting with cybersec AI projects. Usually once I hear the problem description and statements I can kind of assess whether a project is feasible or not even without the deep domain knowledge. I'm not sure how much value a unicorn expert would really be able to provide over a cross functional AI/cybersec team.

Anw short of MINDEF and other defense orgs who may be willing to pay big bucks I don't think that there is a huge market for AI/cybersec. I know that there are some consultancy and security firms trying to hire but I'll be very surprised if they are willing to pay big bucks for a fresh local PhD like you claim.

Let's quantify big bucks for discussions sake. I think total comp of 150k SGD for a fresh PhD, 200k with < 5 years experience can be considered big bucks. These are achieveable without focusing on cybersec specifically and building more transferable skills which include business domain knowledge.

Edit: If you are from a private company really looking to hire fresh local PhD at that rates then I apologize for my rudeness. Good luck with your search

2
hotsplat•

We should probably sit down for a chat to talk shop. I would love to hear more about your experiences in cybersec AI. It’s getting hard sifting through bullshit nowadays.

150-200k is on the high end. It’s quite unlikely I will make that offer unless the candidate’s research is in a related space we are working on, I.e statistical detection of threat actors in a network via anomalous subgraphs, and he proves he knows how to operationalise the math (or can run a team that does that).

Our previous PhD cyber math wizard guy made around US250k annual but he has published several papers and registered several relevant patents before joining us. He was then poached for 2x that by a technology company so yea big bucks is possible as a long term career objective.

To your question on cross functional teams, that’s exactly what we are running now. It is, however, a slow and mostly frustrating process.

1