[Other] Cadaver dogs alert on human remains at campground where DeOrr Kunz Jr. disappeared

Other

If anyone is keeping up with this case, or has heard about this disappearance in the past, here's an update after a long silence on the case. DeOrr Kunz Jr. IS STILL MISSING 4 years after reportedly disappearing on a family camping trip. DeOrr's parents have long been suspects in the disappearance. (article body follows)

LEADORE, Idaho — A pair of dogs specially trained to detect human remains have alerted on an area in the Lemhi County campground where an Idaho toddler vanished without a trace nearly four years ago, according to a private investigator.

DeOrr Kunz Jr., 2, went missing during a family trip to Timber Creek Campground near Leadore on July 10, 2015. Extensive searches of the area have turned up no sign of the boy.

But on Thursday, North Carolina-based private investigator David Marshburn told KTVB authorities may have gotten the break in the case they have been waiting for.

Marshburn said he was asked by family friends and community members to take the case. He said he took his two trained cadaver dogs up to the Timber Creek Campground June 8, searching the area for about a week. He said he was accompanied by Lemhi County Sheriff Steve Penner during the searches.

It took some time for his dogs to acclimatize to the thinner mountain air, Marshburn said, but on the third day, both dogs separately performed "a hard alert" on a specific area of the campground, indicating the presence of a body or remains. The dogs have been trained only to alert on human remains, not a decomposing animal, he said.

According to Marshburn, his dogs are trained only with human cadavers, human bone and teeth so they only alert to human remains. He also added that the dogs are trained to detect remains up to six feet underground.

“Our dogs are cadaver dogs," he explained. "They find cadaver scent – human cadaver scent. So when they do an alert we are pretty confident that they’re finding remains of a human. But are we saying, or can we say it’s 100 percent DeOrr? No. Can we say it’s an Indian from way back? No. We don’t know what’s 100 percent there, we just know the confidence in our dogs that there is human remains of some sort there – it’s just, 'What?'”

The private investigator acknowledged the remains his dogs smelled could belong to someone other than the missing 2-year-old. But Marshburn stressed he was hired to locate DeOrr, and said he believes he has accomplished that.

"I feel it, the closure that everybody needed," he said.

Posted Jul 15, 2019, 6:20 PM UTC

14233
Usual_Safety•

What are we doing here folks? The Idaho news just recycling the same story, the cadaver dogs alert but with no results and claim success, the private investigator the family hired seems to be full of shit.

Thanks for posting this by the way, the last news cycle at the end of June made me angry.

136

It sucks, because it seems like what's being buried progressively more with every news cycle is that there is a little boy who isn't getting to grow up. I think it's easy to lose sight of the fact that these cases have human victims.

40
Ieatclowns•

"I feel it, the closure that everybody needed," he said.

Exactly! He's not delivered a body has he!??

29

Yea, they fired the last PI who concluded that one or both parents murdered him. Guessing they went out and got them someone with less credibility and perhaps a personal agenda.

2
toowduhloow•

He believes he's accomplished closure for everyone close to this investigation? Holy shit, that's quite the leap. That's like someone claiming to be an astronaut simply bc they can look up at the sky at night and see the moon. This P.I. is a certified Twat Waffle. That's as far as his credentials go.

45

The first PI thinks the parents are guilty, so they go out and get this idiot.

4
Doctabotnik123•

How reliable are cadaver dogs? At the risk of being callous, it's not outside the realm of possibility that someone or something else died in that vicinity. IIRC it's a huge area.

40
snarky24•

So, certified cadaver dogs do amazing work, but the point of cadaver dogs are for them to locate remains/evidence that can be recovered. They are a detection tool, and the dogs' indications should not be used as evidence in and of themselves.

I am highly suspect of anyone calling themselves a private investigator running so-called search or cadaver dogs, because there are stringent requirements for testing and certification of such dogs, and (at least in the US) to be legitimate you need to be operating under the auspices of a search and rescue or law enforcement team. Notice throughout the article they say "trained" dogs. They don't say HRD (human remains detection) certified dogs. Hmm.

57
NorskChef•

I'm listening to the Uncover podcast about the Cat Lady and the host was able to find a volunteer with cadaver dogs to accompany him on a lead. Maybe the PI owns the dogs but maybe be hired someone or found a volunteer.

6
snarky24•

I considered that, but the article said it was his own dogs, twice:

Marshburn said he was asked by family friends and community members to take the case. He said he took his two trained cadaver dogs up to the Timber Creek Campground June 8....

According to Marshburn, his dogs are trained only with human cadavers, human bone and teeth...

Hence, high level of suspicion that these are "self trained" dogs, not certified, and not legitimate. The vast majority of certified HRD teams will only ever go out on a search when their team is officially called in by law enforcement to participate in an active case. Part of the reason for this is because the legitimacy of their training and their accuracy CAN be called into question in a court of law, and so their training activities and searches need to be very well documented. Note that the PI says he was "accompanied by the sheriff", not that he was "called in by the sheriff".

Grain of salt, I do not work with LE/SAR dogs, so others who do/who have more info on this case are welcome to correct me. I work with detection dogs in the non-law-enforcement realm.

6
melp1010•

There's a docu-series on Netflix called "Exhibit A" that has an episode on cadaver dogs. The whole series is 4 episodes and discusses how reliable different forensic techniques are. Cadaver dogs are on episode 3 I believe.

Highly recommend!

56
SAR_K9_Handler•

Not even remotely. There is a small subset of conditions and dogs that are reliable, but in a case like this there is almost zero chance that any dog will ever find anything ever.

​

Its why I like live find, its pretty fucking obvious when I find what Im looking for. Easy to prove it works lol.

26
Usual_Safety•

Thanks for doing this work!

3
Koalabella•

In double-blind tests where the handler isn’t aware? Not very.

23
GaiusGracchus121•

Not reliable like almost all animal things. Doesn’t mean they can’t be useful, but there are problems with the handlers giving them false signals, the dogs themselves alerting to unrelated things, and just generally they aren’t half as good as people think.

9
Alekz5020•

Trained drug-sniffing dogs will often "alert" when they come across a woman on her period...

4

As someone who has worked on civil cases resulting from wrongful conviction, the honest answer is that cadaver dogs, drug dogs, bomb dogs, etc- they're just like humans. They want the stimuli of approval. You can get them to alert on anything- same as a human. Problem becomes compounded in that the dogs can't speak to clarify themselves or redact or otherwise.

​

I believe it was Scalia(fascist prick) who "gifted" us with the pithy USoC Opinion where "The nose knows..." came from. The nose is an animal, it can't talk to us.

​

In short, one person's opinion: not very damn accurate.

7
SpyGlassez•

Also, they alert, but it still requires a human to interpret that. The dog may not have a motivation to pin the crime on someone, but the handler might. So even if the dog alerts or fails to do so, the handler is still the one speaking. Training is just training ; it isn't critical thinking. And I'm not saying dogs aren't smart and can't be used. I have two good friends who owe their lives to well trained service dogs, one for allergic reactions and one for seizures.

4
radieldancliffe•

It is yet another tool used that is bollocks, just like polygraphs, psychics, forensic profiling, etc.

6†
JinkiesGang•

Closure? How is that closure? He is still missing. Am I missing something here? They found nothing. So, the dog alerts to an area and case closed? I’m not sure what happened to that kid, but it’s an odd story and the parents did it (he couldn’t have just wondered off never to be found, right?). What’s the going theory now?

28

That the PI was hired to take the heat off the parents and is enough of a scumbag to do just that. Meanwhile the original PI is saying they did it

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
GaiusGracchus121•

This is like the 8th time someone has posted this same, almost certainly meaningless news.

16
yezplz•

just came here to say:
FUCK DAVID PAULIDES
FUCK MISSING411

15
8bitdrummer•

Lol. okay crazy.

0
yezplz•

Calm yourself, David.

1
8bitdrummer•

Excuse you?

0
HoneysuckleHollow•

So are they now digging in the area the dogs alerted on? Was there any evidence the ground had been previously disturbed?

13
AndyWhiter•

I love dogs, but I have cadavers dogs. Because they ALWAYS alert and it ALWAYS leads exactly nowhere.

10
apriljeangibbs•

so are they going to dig it up?

9
Tangboy50000•

The PI saying the dogs had to be acclimated to the thinner air and that it could be an Indian from way back, let me know he doesn’t know shit about anything related to cadaver dogs. What a joke. I’m sure this prefaced him asking to be paid in full for his services.

8

Yea, almost certain that he “self-trained” the dogs, which pretty much means they’re not legit cadaver dogs. Also, sure that along with the up front payment came a promise to not look at the parents as possible suspects. Or maybe not to even look at suspects.

2
ohanaonyx•

Cadaver dogs have alerted in three different searches for Deorr.

However, Idaho is a vast wilderness of six huge parks , which cover much of the state. The ideal place to hide physical evidence.

The adults are saying nothing. Sadly, I don't believe this one will ever be solved, especially since the grandfather died on June 15 .

4
[deleted]•

I'm sorry but cadaver dog alerts aren't update worthy to me. If they don't result in something more, they're just vague possibilities. Hits are meaningless without finds because they bring nothing new to the table, they shine no light on anything and they can't be tied to the specific case. That isn't to say cadaver dogs are pointless, they can be incredibly helpful, but only when the search produces evidence.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Lainey1978•

So I take it nothing ever came of this?

1
Nughuffer802•

Youngster fucked around and got bigfoot'd.

Dingbat P.I., mountain west yokels, Maury show ass white trash drama...

This is one wacky game show boys. R.I.P little homie.

-2
corialis•

Cool story bro, where are the receipts? Oh wait, you have none.

-12