The Issues With White In Draft - M20

The Premise

I'm sure everyone can gather from the title alone what this post is about, but just to make everything clear...today we are looking at the possible causes for White being a mediocre color in Draft in most of the recent sets. Someone could argue that White had a good showing in Ravnica Allegiances since both Azorious and Orzhov were strong guilds, but both of those guilds were primarily carried by their other color and/or the multi-color cards available to them. For the purpose of this article, I'm looking strictly at the mono-White cards. If we look to the other guild set (Guilds of Ravnica), we see a similar effect. The Selesnya guild was very poor due to the weakness of both Green and White in the set, while Boros was still playable since it had very good multi-color cards and Red was stronger than both White and Green.

So how do we fix this issue? We could just sit and complain about it and hope that eventually we get another set where White's strengths just resonate well, but I've never been one to hope that complaining about something will actually invoke any change (something that I wish the gaming community as a whole would embrace more often). Instead, I'd like to take some time to look at what makes a color playable in Draft and then apply those fundamentals to the White color-pie to see if we can come up with a better strategy for designing the color with Draft in mind.

Diagnosing the Problem

In order to see where the underlying issue is originating, we need to take a look at two things:

  1. What makes a color strong in Draft?

  2. What is White doing differently?

Let's break down these points using a fundamental point for design: the Commons should fit into the themes of the color and allow you to play a game with a certain plan in mind.

Taking a look at the White commons in M20, we can see that this is only the case for some of the cards. When looking at the four color-pairings in White we see that the color really wants to be attacking, whether that's in the air with White/Blue or on the ground with the three other pairs. In fact, if you look at the four Uncommon multi-color cards that have White, all of them are rather aggressive cards that want you to build up a board and attack your opponent. So naturally, we would want our commons in the set to support this attack-based plan since there aren't any obvious advantages given for stalling out the board or playing a control-heavy game.

With that in mind, let's look at the Commons available to White. We will start with the Creatures since they seem to be the theme for the color in this set:

https://i.redd.it/gvoj0vsg4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/6bcfxwsg4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/olwivwsg4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/8in36xsg4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/04q13wsg4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/pemo7xsg4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/vo73pysg4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/hvt67xsg4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/ykkhpysg4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/vv9sjxsg4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/jw0tjxsg4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/ir7zhxsg4zb31.png

There are 19 total Commons for White in this set and we can see here that 11 of those 19 are Creatures (Raise the Alarm is also technically a Creature, so we can say 12 are Creatures). Looking just at that metric, we would think that White's Creature-based strategy is well represented. However, once we look at the Creatures themselves we start to see the issue. Although a majority of the White Commons are Creatures, only 8 of them are actually good enough to support an attack plan. This leaves out the following: Battalion Foot Soldier, Daybreak Chaplain, Soulmender, and Yoked Ox. The stats on these cards don't help you attack, so they are useless if you're looking to get aggressive.

But wait, we just eliminated two 1-drops and a 2-drop from our card pool, which should be the most important positions for an aggressive deck! This is one of my largest issues with White in this set. The Commons don't actually support an aggressive plan in a color that only really has Aggressive or Tempo-based decks. You could argue that Yoked Ox and Daybreak Chaplin are ground defenders for the Blue/White Fliers deck, but once you play a game or two with that deck you would see that they aren't needed there either.

Lastly, the payoff Common (Squad Captain) is a little too slow since it costs 5 mana which allows your opponent too much time to find answers or play their own large creatures. If this creature had even cost 1 less mana it would have made a large difference.

Now let's check on the Non-Creature Commons:

https://i.redd.it/cw9idhxk4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/h7yvfmwk4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/nu9w7mwk4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/d5q3v5yk4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/3g52dmwk4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/kg6dklwk4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/qykqqjwk4zb31.png

https://i.redd.it/5uubhlwk4zb31.png

I'm going to ignore Raise the Alarm here since it is basically a Creature and was covered as one above. With that removal we have seven Non-Creature spells. Two of these spells are Creature removal, one is a sideboard option, and the last four are all focused on Creature augmentation.

For the two removal spells we have one premium removal and one clunky removal spell. I actually really like this dynamic, however the clunky spell in this case does not fit into the theme for White in this set since it does not help you attack your opponent.

I'm fine with the Disenchant in the set. Narrow sideboard cards need to be printed and at least they printed a good one. Though putting some lifegain on the card would have better supported the Black/White theme. 

Lastly, the four Creature augment spells are lackluster overall. Let's start with Inspired Charge. This is a great card, but it gets almost no support from the other White Commons. There is only one White common that makes more than one Creature with a single cast (Raise the Alarm) and as we mentioned, most of the 1-drop and 2-drop Creatures are too mediocre to see play. Next we have Moment of Heroism, which is a perfectly fine combat trick and I'm not going to be down on printing a card that works with White's mechanics and helps to support its themes. This one actually hits the mark even if it is a lower powerlevel of a card in general. Finally, the two Auras, which leave much to be desired. Glaring Aegis is a completely confused card. It gives the Creature a large Toughness boost, but it also taps down a Creature to help the Player attack. I would say that this card is not only a failure in this set, but it also kind of fails as a basic design. The last Aura is Angelic Gift which does give a relevant ability, but with the inherent downside that comes with being an Aura, it doesn't actually seem very appealing. I'll talk more about how these could have been improved later.

The Remedy

Now that we know what the largest issue is with White, we can take a look at how this problem can be fixed moving forward. In the current sets, most of the cards are playable, but when we look at the White Commons in this set I would consider at least 8/19 (a conservative number) of them to be below par, which is nearly half of them. This issue stems primarily from a lack of focus on the theme that the White decks are trying to support. In M20 in particular, this seems like it should have been much easier than normal to have a unified identity since all of the White-based decks are looking to be somewhat aggressive. However, several of the Common slots ended up being devoted to defensive Creatures and clunky spells that open you up to card disadvantage or just don't work with White's strategy of attacking.

To help with these issues I would suggest the following changes:

  1. Allow White to have a stronger identity as the color with the most powerful early drops.

If we look at some of the most successful Common White creatures in past sets we will see that Healer's Hawk stands out above pretty much all other cards. That's because this Creature had a decent baseline that we were happy to augment with other spells. I would like to see White get a larger focus on pushing Combat Abilities onto their 1-drop and 2-drop Creatures and I would even like for some of them to have two abilities like Healer Hawk. This would further separate White from Green as it would emphasize an early game strategy for its ground-based decks.

  1. If a set is going to have a go-wide strategy in White, then White needs to have more than one Common card that supports the engine of the strategy (ie. making more than one Creature with a single spell)

In M20, White only has Raise the Alarm at Common and then has the payoff of Inspired Charge. It would have been nice if there was a 3-drop or 4-drop Creature that came into play with an extra token, such as Paladin of the Bloodstained from Ixalan.

  1. Put less emphasis on Enchantment-based augmentation and start adding in White-only Equipment at Common.

Ancestral Blade is one of my favorite cards in this set from a design perspective. It fits perfectly into what White wants to be doing. I'm not saying that card needed to be Common, but White needs better augmentation options that aren't just one-shots at Common. Imagine if Angelic Gift was an Equipment instead. This would allow you to constantly make your newest threat into an evasive threat instead of just losing 2-for-1 to removal. I am really liking the idea of colored Artifacts being the new norm and I want Wizards to push harder into that idea as a way to bolster White's Equipment sub-theme. We could even have Equipment with harsher White costs to further prevent them from being used as a splash in other decks. This would also support my first point better since the Equipment would allow you to run more of the smaller creatures as you would have ways to make them better.

The way I see it, White is supposed to be focused on Combat, especially through traditionally trained Creatures such as Knights, Soldiers, and Warriors. Making these Creatures utilize Equipment and Combat Abilities would fit with the theme for this color and push it toward a more unique play-style than where it currently sits.

Conclusion

Tell me what you think! Do the points I have look like steps in the right direction or do you have other choices you would make? I don't assume I have all the answers, but I feel like these changes could help White get a stronger identity. Currently the color feels like it is being pulled into too many directions and some of those directions just aren't very useful (namely healing, combat tricks and Auras). It's fine for a few bad or sub-par cards to be in sets, but loading up a single color with nearly 50% useless cards seems excessive. When a new draft format comes out I want all of the colors to be playable since that means the format will have more depth. Unfortunately, White has consistently been on the low-end for quite some time, which makes this dream less likely. With M20 in particular, White had one good strategy with Blue/White Fliers, but the other three color combos are among the worst archetypes in the set.

Posted Jul 23, 2019, 3:39 AM UTC

4635
Loading comments…