Hate Anna. But sympathize with her. Looking for healthy discussion :)
I will lead with I have hated her the entire series. Her behavior bothers me and she seems highly reactive, hypocritical, and nosy. I have wanted her out every single chance we've been given to vote her.
However, I really sympathize with her last night. It seemed to me she reacted out of being blindsided and fueled by actually watching it happen before her own eyes. I would love to say that in the same situation I'd react calmly and have an adult conversation instead. But who knows? When you're in there and its happening in your face and you feel the burn in your heart I think tensions would run high as well. I never thought I'd feel bad for Anna but there is something about seeing the hurt in her eyes that really tugged at my heart strings. I don't think it was childish of her to react like that. I think it was spiteful as in she wanted to inflict the same amount of hurt/humiliation she was feeling. Yes, she's awful. But when it came to her feelings those seemed genuine to me. Can't be easy feeling like you're on cloud 9 only to get your heart broken immediately after. It just wasn't expected. (I still want her voted out, but I feel bad for the girl).
Not giving Jordan a pass here but I do think it was damned if you do and damned if you don't for him. The respectful thing would have been to talk to Anna and end things but I get he wanted to secure his connection with India first. That obviously backfired. His actions were muggy and on the selfish side. He wanted to take the plunge with the least amount of splashing as possible. Its self preservation and avoiding Anna the heartache if it turns out to be nothing. I get it. I don't like it. But I get it. I don't stand by his actions after. She is clearly upset with you and you have been caught. Own up to it and deal with the fallout, be accepting. To try and twist it on her when she didn't do anything to him (Anna sucks, but she is acting the EXACT way she has been acting from day 1, so these weren't deal breakers when he asked her out) was a dick move. I rated him before but now I think he's shown his age.
My question for everyone is:
In Jordan's shoes, what would you have done? What is the best course of action here? We all wanna defend that he should've gone to Anna first (I know I do) but would you actually have?
In Anna's shoes, would you have reacted calmly or would the fire have taken over you as well and gone all scorched earth?
I'm genuinely curious to hear everyone's thoughts.
Posted Jul 24, 2019, 5:42 PM UTC
In Jordan's shoes - if I am to take him as being completely honest about his feelings and not at all faking it beforehand or now - I would realize that two days ago I liked Anna enough to want her to be my girlfriend and that these unsure feelings may be temporary. I'd stay with her until we leave the villa and if I still felt that way when we were back home, I'd break up. After doing so, if I still had feelings for India, I'd send her a message and try to gauge interest.
In Anna's shoes, I'd like to believe I'd be calm and probably would be calmer than she was because I don't know if I've ever gone off at someone like that. However, I'd be in such shock that I would have some kind of emotional reaction, most likely angry tears. If he tried to blame it all on me like he did last night or deny all responsibility then I'd have to walk away because I couldn't speak to someone like that.
I really like your take on this! Never thought of it that way. Thank you for sharing :)