Post-WAR Nicol Bolas Tribal, featuring all of the God-Eternals and Insect Gods.
Hello r/EDH, I haven't posted here in a while but I've been wanting a Nicol Bolas Tribal that's been adjusted to include the lore/cards from War of the Spark, and noticed there really aren't (m)any. I found a single "Most Flavorful Deck" but I wanted more mechanical adhesion than strictly running every character he ever ran into. I started this deck a long while ago and recently updated overhauled it and haven't been able to play recently, so I want to know if this is even viable or if I can squeeze more thematic cards.
I started with his cards, as well as most he was Depicted in, and culled down to some decent cards in his Associated and Referenced lists on the Wiki and his story. I then tried to support the themes of big spells, discard, mind control, card-draw, zombie tokens, and -1/-1 counters, some of which definitely got cut sooner than others. Below are the removed cards and why I hadn't used them, though do please tell me if I set aside a sleeper card or if it's worth trying to add.
Not using Depicted:
- [[Patient Rebuilding]] because it mills a single player 3 cards. I guess it's good for rez later but I already expect hate from mind-control and minor discarding.
- [[Crux of Fate]] because I'm not really using Dragons aside from the two versions of Nicky.
- [[Imminent Doom]] because it seems like very little payoff when you have to play the cards in CMC order for an effect like Bone-Sphinx Wand or the new red enchantment.
Not using Associated/Referenced:
- [[Command the Dreadhorde]] half of my creatures end up back in hand anyways, so I'd be doing more of what my Commander can do but with life.
- [[Imp's Mischief]] could be good, but wouldn't know what to replace.
- [[Open into Wonder]] seems decent to push through some beefy bois, but overall unnecessary.
- [[Throne of the God-Pharaoh]] because this actually runs a small suite of creatures, and unless Army of the Damned or Locust God come up, it's pretty much just useless pings.
- "Dreadhorde" Amass is only splashed for the good ones (2+ and effect) because goldfishing showed most Amass (see vanilla Amass 1) is not impressive in Commander. I included the hexproof leader [[Gleaming Overseer]] to keep the Army safer, and Menace works well with any
EternalsZombies I generate, but the others effect too few tokens to be of use. - and other cards that just seemed ineffective or overcosted even though "-Nicol Bolas" was quoted somewhere sometimes.
That being said, is there anything above that should be in the deck, or cards I missed in the plot of Bolas that would help? I tried restricting myself to thematic cards because Nicol Bolas is a very impressive enemy to build a deck for but I don't want to oppress my playgroup with super-control. Are there any cards in the list that should really be taken out because it's just awful (like perhaps [[God-Pharaoh's Gift]])?
Posted Jul 24, 2019, 6:13 PM UTC
I don't think you need to be using dragons for Crux of Fate to be good. It's still going to wipe the board of most things in a flavourful way.
But anyway, your choice! You can't fit every Bolas-related card in, so something has to go.
True, and I think it doesn't have too many true boardwipes at the moment. Might as well run [[Magmaquake]] or even leave flavor and go for [[Damnation]].
There is a Masterpiece Damnation with Bolas art.
Magmaquake - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Damnation - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call
In my Bolas tribal, I don’t like Magmaquake as it damages my own Bolases, which feels wrong to me somehow. My wipes are Crux, Hour, and Bontu’s, which I find is okay in a 60% meta
Yeah I recently swapped gate to afterlife for bontus