taebaegiHOME Enthusiast•

I appreciate that people are concerned about what these kinds of games can do to people, but I'm personally still of the belief that this game is not going to do anything to people that wasn't already there. If you feel like lines are being blurred then you can put down the game and not pick it up. This game does not blur my feelings of the real BTS with the BTS World charicatures. It's similar to how I feel about fanfiction and this game is basically BTS in a fanfic as a game lol. This is not the real BTS and no amount of fine tuning to make them seem as real as possible is going to convince me of that. These are pieces of data with BTS' name, face, and super flanderized idol personalities attached to them and the relationships I'm forming in this game is not relationships I'm forming with the real BTS.

I was initially a naysayer myself about this game but I've played this game every single day since launch and I'm loving it. I'm not loving it because I'm BTS' manager and I can coo over getting to interact with them, I'm loving it because it involves strategy to pass levels and I can collect things, e.g., cards. And tbh, the solo stories are actually pretty interesting and I'm very interested in progressing in them to see what happens next. The only problem I have with this game is the manager and if you eradicated them from the game, I would honestly be singing very high praises about this game. The manager is fine for the main story, but in the boys' solo stories? The manager is just completely unneeded. I also think the microtransaction aspect is more dangerous than the "blurring the lines between fan and friend" aspect.

96
Consuela_no_noI’mUrRed_HOMEless_hobi_hobi_hobi_jams•

”I appreciate that people are concerned about what these kinds of games can do to people, but I'm personally still of the belief that this game is not going to do anything to people that wasn't already there. If you feel like lines are being blurred then you can put down the game and not pick it up. This game does not blur my feelings of the real BTS with the BTS World caricatures.”

Agreed.

19
justacolorSope Reunion Tour 2019•

Also agreed. The game is far from being convincingly real. C'mon... It's cheesy. But it's fun in some ways, so I keep up with it. But to call it line-blurring and a possible problem in that way seems to go along the same lines as calling video game violence a cause of real-life violence. Like, get out of here.

15
staysinthecarRock Jin is my Religion•

yeah, once you get past the cringe and the "heart-fluttering" moments (lol jin wants to make me rich!! THAT MADE MY BROKE ASS ARMY HEART FLUTTER! but i still won't spend a dime on you, game!) it's really just a game that you have to grind and put the work in to unlock levels and get more content. =/

2
xylhynne•

I agree. I was initially worried that Y/N syndrome (You know those people who thinks they’re in a fanfic) will be much more delulu but it was quite tame.

There are few instance that it has blurred lines but not enough for you to feel it was real. Mystic messenger is more real than this.

I love the collecting cards part. Hate the super gated solo stories. I love RM’s story the most. Now, that you mentioned it, yeaaahh the manager x artist relationship in the solo stories are so forced.

1
wishawishado you, bangtan•

The last sentence sums up one of the main goals of the industry. Learning to play the game (of being an idol) while also inserting their own earnestness is a difficult but rewarding line for both artist and fan, I think.

I’m playing the game, though. I tap the screen as fast as possible through actual stories, often having flashes of ??? or jawdrop moments, but I am invested in FINISHING and ACTUALLY GETTING EVEN ONE DREAM 4/5 STAR CARD C’MON.

29
elbenne•

I have begun to believe that there is only one 5star card, three 4star cards and only the myth that there are any more than that. The game is actually really enjoyable except that we're chasing those damn unicorns. 😨

18
BraveryGalEnglish is hard, practice English•

The moment when you saved 200 gems for a bulk draw only to gain a bunch of 3 star cards... The struggle is real in this game 😂

18
elbenne•

I haven't had the self discipline to wait that long and told myself that they were lying about a guaranteed big card coming for the 200. And ... it really is a lie? Or sometimes it is and sometimes it isn't? 😵😂😂😂😵

4
BraveryGalEnglish is hard, practice English•

In the end, it's all about luck 😂

6
winterchestnutsNo Bias Noona•

I have four 5-star cards ^^;;

1
elbenne•

I don't like you anymore. 😛

4
winterchestnutsNo Bias Noona•

we don't talk anymore like we used to doooooooo~

2
crossparallelOPlet us light up the night•

Learning to play the game while also inserting their own earnestness is a difficult but rewarding line for both artist and fan, I think.

I think you're really into something here. Perhaps any attempt to ignore the nature of BTS and ARMY's relationship would be disingenuous, so they might as well play all their cards, while making sure to remind us that we can only know the persona - as u/elbenne pointed out, the timing of BTS World's release after Persona only makes us more aware.

13
elbenne•

The author points to the game's disclaimer which says that the game isn't about real people, when it obviously is. It's based on Bangtan's experience. But when we chuckle over that, we also need to be reminded that this is the rub ... Cuz it is and it isn't based on reality ... there's been fact and fiction, people and persona's, all along.

And so they remind us with a teeny reality check every time we start to play. They're not being disingenuous ... or deceptive ... just, maybe, a bit tongue in cheek ironic. 😲 (And maybe the lawyers made them do it as well.)

9
moonieeee399Let’s have a partay, a partaytay•

This was a really well written article and hits p much every fault I have with the game to a T, though her point about the gendering only being ‘she’ is outdated so it’s ‘they’ now. I’m at 6-14 so nearly done with the main story and on chapter 2-4 in the AS

The last line about person and persona hits really hard. We’re in a kind of era where the members are keen to show the differences between their BTS selves and off screen selves, like Namjoon’s ‘Kim namjoon or RM’ line in Airplane p2 and JK’s comment saying that ‘Jungkook of BTS shines bright but Jeon Jungkook is insignificant’ but at the same time the whole BTS persona they put on is being increasingly marketed to the fans and blended in with them and it’s just a bit odd

27
crossparallelOPlet us light up the night•

It is odd. If we take a step back, the tension with their stage persona and their role as idols become a central conflict in their story - but reducing the lives of actual people, even artists, to a story is uncomfortable too. Something that needs to be noted though is that while coming out now, BTS World has been in the works for years, while songs like Fake Love and the direction the Map of the Soul series seems to be going in are newer developments. One could hope that BTS now would not agree to go with something like BTS World. Then again, isn't another BTS game in the works?

15
moonieeee399Let’s have a partay, a partaytay•

Not really, I’m at 6-14 and past the initial few chapters they just seem to roll with the whole kpop thing which I do find weird in itself. And that is true too, this game has been in development since probs before DNA. Yes there’s another BTS game in the works but that won’t be out for ages probs

7
crossparallelOPlet us light up the night•

I meant the bigger story of the rise of BTS we are writing together, not the story in the game. Sorry I wasn't clear.

5
moonieeee399Let’s have a partay, a partaytay•

Ahhh I see

That’s v true

3
elbenne•

I want to think about this a bit more but it seems to me that the timing of Persona's release ... just ahead of the BTS World launch ... could not have been better

The author is stating that the game reinforces our feeling that we actually know the members when we probably know much less than we think/feel and probably no more than we should ...

A parasocial relationship has, indeed, been formed between us ... one that developed from the members public BTS persona(s) through all that content ...

But, with the prior arrival of the album and all the discussion of Persona that came with it ... BTS has made a move to ensure that people have a greater sense of distance ... before diving into a game that might have made us feel even closer.

In other words, the author is right ... but with the Persona release, BTS has chosen to highlight the para-social aspect of their ARMY relationship instead of allowing it to intensify through the game interaction.

The game launch was probably delayed for many reasons. Perhaps this timing was one of them. Or it was a fortunate accident.

Edit. Most of us realized that we don't and shouldn't know the members as if we really were close friends but the discussion about persona has reinforced that and, I think, it's also helped us to see all of our relationships in that same, much clearer, light. It's been an educational and useful discussion for us all to have.

20
asmolbirb•

I think this article is a good dive into how BTS World utilizes parasocial relationships, but I’m not convinced that escalation is the right word. I’ve never once felt that the characters in the game were the real BTS because they’re very obviously 1-dimensional caricatures of their onstage personas (much less their real, complex, private personas). Even in the phone calls, the voice acting feels wooden and stilted at times, not at all like how I’ve heard them speak in interviews, VLives, etc.

As much as this game claims to put the player in a manager role where they can get close(r) with BTS, ultimately I feel that we haven’t actually been given any more info than we started with. Conversely, the game developers have incorporated a slew of inside jokes that only work because we’re already familiar with them. The game itself has never been about “getting to know” BTS for me because they’re not giving me anything I didn’t already know. Even the unlockable photo content is nothing spectacular, and definitely not something I’m likely to revisit; there are photos of Jin at the airport in 2016 that I look at more often than anything in this game.

And so my focus has shifted to collecting cards, beating the quests, and getting achievements, because at my core, I am the type of gamer who likes to see the numbers go up. I’m not denying that the appeal of this game is that it’s about BTS, but I don’t think the point of the game is BTS. Even on r/btsw, most of the discussion is about gaming the system and figuring out card stats, not about the stories themselves.

Ultimately, there’s a lot of going nowhere in this article imo. In all honesty, the most interesting part was the point the author made about this being an escalation of self-insert RPF, and I think there’s a much more interesting discussion in that than in how BTSW might veer into sasaeng territory (which most fans noticed and decried immediately from what I saw). Talking about why people who are against RPF might be okay with BTSW, or having a conversation about the ethics and impact of monetizing fanfic while fans have been sued for doing the same (both of which could lead into a discussion of whether BTSW is truly fanfic in the first place considering it wasn’t written by fans for fans) would have been much more interesting than what the author attempted but failed to argue.

16
AdelaisVYoongi's tofu cheeks•

Conversely, the game developers have incorporated a slew of inside jokes that only work because we’re already familiar with them.

I think this is my favourite part of the game besides the card collecting. I'm fairly new ARMY so I'm still going through the backlog of Run episodes and BV and whatnot but things have popped up in the game where I'm thinking "what a bizarre thing to say, maybe it's an odd translation" and then a few days later I get to a Run episode and go "AH! Now I get the squirrel locked in the garden thing".

8
itsaterribleideaJinHit Entertainment Intern•

I’m on 6-15. I mostly just enjoy it as a card collecting game with the goal of completing sets. I don’t collect physical merchandise like photo cards so I suppose this is one way to do it.

After getting past the offputting start, I don’t think too much about the story now although I like Jin’s hotelier plot and Areum’s character was well-written. It was also the least stalkerish (at least y/n doesn’t follow Jin home).

I also want to add that I never confuse the in-game characters with the real BTS. Maybe it helps that the writing is so simplistic they seem rather like cardboard cutouts.

15
crossparallelOPlet us light up the night•

We've had this discussion at BTS World's launch, but I think it's good to revisit now that more people have progressed through the game. As someone who hasn't gone past the level where we got to hear Heartbeat, I can't comment, but I'm looking forward to reading your opinions. However much I love BTS and what we have together, it can be downright scary how effective their marketing is.

11
ladyvinaigrettecause of death:Yoongi's collarbone•

Personally,I am more invested in passing the stages and playing around with the card levels. I always go through the storyline conversations very fast (just enough to get the gist, mostly bc I am impatient by nature). The game is fun in a Temple Run sort of way, very mechanic. Sometimes the storylines make me stop and think, usually when they are outrageous like the birthday party scene, some moments when they were really down and doubting debut (it was a video where they stared at me/the camera with pained eyes - i am not made of stone!!!). But that's about it, from an emotional perspective I am personally very far removed and agnostic to it all.

20
NoelBlueRed:jksmile:Don't ignore someone 5 yrs older than you!•

Hmmmmm I feel is a very slight article that uses a lot of big claims without any experts or actual INFO other than personal experience and impression to back them up.

But it is clear that literally turning them into game characters further blurs this line between person and persona, in a way that is intended to bring fans even closer to their idols — all in the hopes they’ll shell out more cash.

I'm not quite sure that it is IS clear, as most of the assertions of the problems are not attached to research or backed up by more than multiple 'it's clear....' style statements without going into WHY it's so obvious this blurs the line. Give me numbers, give me interviews, talk to psychologists and social scientists - there is something very social media about the 'THIS IS A PRObLEM' style of information presentation sans actual clarification with details of why it is. How MANY people have this issue? How many people understand it's just a game and these aren't BTS?

Are we sure it's really an issue, or is this just someone finding it uncomfortable and *deciding* its an issue? The game is even more distant from Real BTS than Weverse and Twitter - it takes a certain mind or immaturity to decide this is really them. So many people have stated that concern, but where are the actual people expressing BTSWorld makes them feel closer to BTS? A whole section on Saesangs - do we have any indication at ALL that this game has enabled them?

Even using the Tamar example made me raise an eyebrow, as if we're going to talk about problems with fandom culture in general and how that reflects parasocial relationships with celebrities then we need to discuss the normalization of death threats (Which is highly screwed up) and how these very fringe but grossly common reactions are effectively utilized by naysayers to dismiss whole fandoms or, say, the extremely legitimate criticisms she has received as a journalist. That whole section was a weird insert - "and look! Fans JUSTIFY THIS BAD BEHAVIOR. That's so screwed up!" That's a social media behavior issue, and not the core discussion here.

I don't know, this just hits me like a well-edited Twitter "BTSWORLD IS EEEEVIL!" playing on emotions and presenting worst-case-scenarios thread without anything to back it up.

8
crossparallelOPlet us light up the night•

All very good points, thank you. For the record, more than supporting the article, the reason I posted was that I wanted more feedback - do other ARMYs feel like this too? I know I can easily separate fanfiction from my views of the actual members, which is the comparison u/taebaegi gave, but something about the game's existence makes me more uncomfortable than fanfiction or the usual fanservice do. I was hoping a discussion of the game would help me put that uneasiness in context.

6
NoelBlueRed:jksmile:Don't ignore someone 5 yrs older than you!•

Oh of course! I figured/you're clearly into interesting, deep discussions, I think articles should be posted good and bad so we can discuss them and see how we feel!

It's interesting, I actually DO feel the discomfort in game when the MC does or says something cringy, but I just sorta glide past it, so I don't mean to dismiss that discomfort whatsoever. I'm a bit different, I actually get more uncomfortable with fanfiction that's too personal about the guys because it reminds me too much that it's about real people so that gives me more the willies as the MC in BTSWorld never crosses the line?

That's just preference, tho'! My quibble really is with article writer's suggestion that the game is downright dangerous in a couple of ways, which is different than cringiness in my mind.

For me, the fact that they use actual pictures as opposed to illustrations might be my biggest source of eye twitch, seeing them do those exaggerated facial expressions in the often cheesy storyline hits a bit too close to home. I hope the next BTS games has illustrations!!! And the weird line the MC straddles between 'somewhat realistic friend with RL job/personality/home' and 'magical creature who shows up to help and don't think too hard about it because it doesn't make any sense' also gives me whiplash at moments. (And yet here I am, still enjoying it! The brain is weird.)

Have you come to any conclusions/has it assisted with context?

3
elbenne•

I'm not having trouble with it and I'm feeling that few people honestly will. It's a game and despite the cute communication things, it looks and feels like one. The hook with the texts and chat room and calls ... is that they're funny ... not that they feel real.

3
taebaegiHOME Enthusiast•

I got tagged for this comment since you put my name haha, but I was wondering if maybe I can help put things in perspective! I also didn’t like the game at first and it made me pretty uncomfy, still does, namely with the manager outright stalking them in their solo stories lol. But do you know what specifically makes you uncomfortable with the game?

2
crossparallelOPlet us light up the night•

u/NoelBlueRed I'll just answer to both comments together, if you don't mind.

I think it's mostly the feeling that at one point BTS had to take the time and record everything for the game. The line between fanfiction and real life is one I feel uneasy to blur.

For me, the fact that they use actual pictures as opposed to illustrations might be my biggest source of eye twitch, seeing them do those exaggerated facial expressions in the often cheesy storyline hits a bit too close to home.

This, this exactly! But I have a hard time justifying why I'm so uneasy with BTS World while eagerly engaging with the Bangtan Universe, which while not as cheesy has some pretty disturbing content. The truth is that I used to feel uncomfortable with the alternative universe too around Wings era, when what were supposed to be personal songs got recontextualized in relation to the BU in the short films. I felt this especially strongly for songs like Stigma and Lie. But then I guess I got used to it, and the fleshing out of the BU helped untangle again the BU characters from the actual people. So what makes BTS World different?

I guess at least a part of it is the timing, as elbenne pointed. We've had so many discussions, during Love Yourself era and especially now after Persona's release, about authenticity. We're all grateful to have left certain stereotypes of the members behind. In a way I guess I have built another narrative in my head, one about us and BTS attempting to build a more sincere and equal relationship, that I can't easily let go of. The experience the game presents can feel like a parody of that. I know it doesn't need to be that deep, just my brain making silly comparisons. I need to think a bit more about wisha's answer about learning to insert earnestness into the idol game.

2
taebaegiHOME Enthusiast•

Hmm yeah, I suppose I can understand that. But I guess for me, I see them acting in this game no differently than I would them acting in an MV for the BU. It’s just them acting. Like I have no attachment or feelings to the BU and I see that much like a fanfic too. It’s just storytelling wrapped up in a different package. BU MVs is one package with storytelling, BTS World is another.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
elbenne•

Thank you (and u/crossparallel too) !!! And now I feel totally ashamed that I managed to read this whole thing without engaging a single critical thinking muscle even once. There is no data. There is no attempt to find data. The author has not even discussed similar style games and what is known or not known about them.

The thing is that it's simply, but well, written, apart from that, which adds to the feeling of disquiet for (1) ARMY player/managers already wondering about fan vulnerability plus potentially evil levels of fandom manipulation from Big Hit and Netmarble and (2) westerners easily frightened by the invasion of such fandoms (seen previously at comic-cons but not so much in music and K-cons).

So, seen through your clearer eye, this is just very slight but very alarmist. It takes a day for a new account to be allowed comment priviledges but I was going to go back to comment on the fact that they've already fixed the pronoun issue and, I heard, also the flirtatious language which people reported but I haven't seen for myself.

To be honest, I can't imagine not being able to tease and joke with my co-workers but if our ordinary language were to be dropped into this game where the sasaeng fears and screaming girl tropes reside, it might also come out looking pretty suspect too.

The game, apparently, isn't making enough bank from players to call it an unmitigated success so maybe that destroys the authors critique all by itself.

It made me angry, actually, that the game's success floundered under a wave of criticism from people who hadn't played (or not much) at that point. I was, shamefully, a part of that fuss but now that I've played into level 5 I just don't see that the kerfuffle was necessary.

The game is fun, fairly sophisticated and well produced ... and in my opinion it's pretty harmless.

Even (what people are calling) the 'stalkerish' aspect in the Other World is kind of tame when you consider that the manager is looking to see if he/she can still create Bangtan in a universe where it seems unlikely. At least that's how I'm seeing it. Considering how important BTS has become to so many people ... it's worth it to investigate and find out if it could still happen.

Anyway, I rather doubt that there will be many ARMYs who have trouble remembering that this is just a game. LoL. I think it's less of an issue than we have with the regular 'real' content.

It's just too easy for alarmists, xenophobes and antis to throw pot shots at Big Hit now that it's finally making real money after investing with relatively little return for so long.

5
_saks_•

I feel the same way. Only very obsessed people will get overwhelmed in the game like that. That's the way I see it - a game. And I see the "characters" in the game as that, not real people. I don't even connect them to the boys because this is just that - a game. They were "told" to "say these things". It's pretty unreal. And the stalking - how many games with characters are like that? We don't get too much into it because that's exactly it... a game. Or do people also believe in the boogie man? lol.

3
elbenne•

I agree that almost every single person will be safe ...

I only know one person who believes in the boogie man ... and it's cuz he watches wayyyy too many horror films for his own good :-)

1
staysinthecarRock Jin is my Religion•

That whole section was a weird insert - "and look! Fans JUSTIFY THIS BAD BEHAVIOR. That's so screwed up!"

looool i went to the twitter post she linked and i saw replies from fans not liking the whole death threats at all, basically nullifying her claim that Fans Justify Death Threats To Critics. so i was like ???

1
MnemosyneNL•

It took me a while to really get started with the game as I'm not a fan of this type of games. After unlocking 1-14 I was really excited and sooooo much content got thrown my way I got really into it. Then I realized how hard it was to actually get stuff to recuperate them in Agency, how hard it is to get decent stats on your cards and basically playing all levels 10 times a day to get flowers.....it can get tedious but maybe this is just not really my cup of tea.

My biggest turn off though: the Another Story seemed fun at first but they quickly escalate into cringy stalker situations and are even harder to clear than the regular story line -_-

I understand why people are concerned about this kind of content!

7
beckysmaJungkook's Mother-In-Law•

I don’t even read the conversations. I tap through them as fast as I can until it forces me to choose a response 😁

3
staysinthecarRock Jin is my Religion•

That also means it’s easy to overlook when things are going distinctly beyond a manager-client relationship. Kim “Jin” Seok-jin tells me he’s always thinking about me when eating. “It’s even more delicious that way,” he tells me. Suga buzzes my phone and I have the option to say that “the most handsome of them all” is texting me.

lol i guess this is typical Libra of me because these kind of flattering and flirting aren't really something i'd take seriously in real life tbh.

BUT MORE TO THE POINT OF THE ARTICLE: it does feel weird that it's rooted in reality (i wish they had gone more off-the-route/more fictional than using real bits + fictional elements tbh) but that's what it is, anyway. it's not as if it's the first one, too, other celebrities have also used their likeliness for their own stupid games (lol yes, BTS World is also just another dumb game! i enjoy it but i'll criticise it anyway). i think it's fine. they could have just signed off it if they didn't really want to do it. i'd like to think that consumers nowadays are also more savvier between what's the boys' persona on-stage and in real life so if you're a "normal" fan, then it shouldn't really make you think that you are their real manager and you are entitled to their Everything just because you play this game and patronize them.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
crossparallelOPlet us light up the night•

In the note about BTS World content, it was stated:

"Additionally, discussion threads that put the game in a larger context or use it as basis for a tangential discussion (example) that will be interesting for non-players as well will be allowed."

The article is a perfect example of this, starting a discussion on the effects of the game on parasocial relationships to BTS and how this works in the context of their marketing and fandom dynamics. On this basis, I'm asking for you to reconsider your decision.

6
hannahvioletMODshine, dream, smile ✨🐰•

Hi, we have decided to reinstate the thread due to its potential for discussion. Thanks!

5
crossparallelOPlet us light up the night•

Thank you so much 💜

4