Aknot•

I've soldered VGA contacts onto CAT5 cable a couple of times. It does not have the correct impedance for a VGA cable but it works (sometimes better if the three "color"-grounds are soldered together). But you do sacrifice a number of pins and that might hinder the computers attempts at detecting the screen kind and setting the correct resolution...

8
rantAccountOP•

Yeah, I'm not able to go above 1024x768, and that does pose a small problem... I'm going to give this a shot for a few days and either double up and use 2 CAT5's for all VGA connections.. or just buy something off the shelf.

My original problem is that the hole in the wall between my bedroom and my living room is too small to fit a VGA plug through and the distance is approx. 9m from the computer to the TV. And obviously, since I don't have a drill - I chose to go CAT5 ;-)

1
DrIntelligence•

If you have the money, I would just invest in a good drill and go to town. Its bound to come in handy sometime sooner or later.

1
rantAccountOP•

Yeah, but that's too easy.... :p

My next plan is to set up a wireless configuration. Since I have a few wireless routers lying around - I'm sure I could break them open, find use for the antennae and hopefully figure something out.

2
DrIntelligence•

I like your moxy. I'm getting ready to bust open my only one soon. Those D-link 604 or 524 or whatever it is from 2002 just don't cut it anymore.

1
VWftw•

Now do DVI.

4
LightShadow•

Not DVI, but I was looking at this HDMI solution.

5
Korbit•

not hard, you would just have to use 2-3 ethernet cables instead of 1

2
rantAccountOP•

Yeah, I've come to the conclusion that having that many wires is a simple necessity and I might as well buy a proper shielded cable if I want to go that far.

<fingerscrossed>My next plan is to go wireless</fingerscrossed> :-)

1
name_censored_•

Fantastic hack! I could have used something like this a few weeks ago, but I'm definitely going to save this article in case I need it again.

The only trouble I can see is that CAT-5 can get away with being thin and long because it uses twisted pairs, and this hack uses all 8 wires for data. This means you're bound to get interference, especially at high resolution/refresh (if you've ever used a cheap-and-nasty non-shielded/non-ferrite-beaded VGA cable, you'll know what to expect). Wouldn't it be better to do this hack with dual CAT-5 cables wired for twisted-pair transmission (though this would massively increase the difficulty of the project)?

3
redjelly3•

We use this system for hundreds of projectors around campus without any problems. It's a commercial solution, but I'm guessing that they do the exact same thing as in the link. I know most run at 1024x768, but I'm pretty sure we have higher resolution as well.

1
name_censored_•

Are you sure it's not Video over IP? OP's hack is nice for a home user (who's much more likely to have a long run of CAT5 than shielded VGA), but I can't imagine this being done on a large scale because

  1. It'd need dedicated cables (it wouldn't be able to use existing network wires)
  2. It'd need a full cable run for each client (you couldn't just use one trunk to connect distant buildings/rooms/clusters)
  3. It wouldn't be able to work with network switches or network routers
  4. It'd need a graphics card output for each display
  5. The signal would irrevocably degrade over distance/proportionally to EM, so even a modest-sized campus would be too big for a single server
  6. At some scale, it'd be cheaper and easier to write a software solution once than to build hundreds of these boxes (two for every display) and buy and run hundreds of cables (one for every display) (plus two VGA cables for every display).

Of course, video over IP requires a large backbone, careful QoS management and a client computer on each display (probably something like this bad boy.

1
hab136•

You can solve all of these (except the degradation) by using the existing wiring, and just hooking it in to a VGA repeater in each building instead of the existing switch. Just mount the repeaters above the switches, and move the cables.

If you use several CAT5 cables and use DVI, no degradation.

But yeah, streamed video is probably a better idea over large areas.

1
redjelly3•

You're probably right. We used to have some extra adapter laying around, but I can't find them anymore to confirm. I do know that we have some pretty specific QoS and gigabit down to our wall jacks.

1
rantAccountOP•

I tried, but am not able to go above 1024x768...

1
Xeracy•

I do event production with a focus on video projection and while a 50' VGA cable is kinda expensive, its durable, especially in a production setting. However, vga does have a glass jaw: its 15 fragile pins. I try to keep those plastic caps that come with new cables but i still have bent pins that have ruined cables. Now while a RJ-45 connector is less likely to be damaged when dropped or transported, the fragility of the plastic release tab, lack of proper strain relief on the wires, and the lack of RF shielding in cat-5/6 make it even less desirable and just as likely to be damaged.

2
tracknod•

WTF company do you work for that uses 50' VGA???? Seriously??? Most switchers used today are 5 wire or DVI with the exception of the bottom basement pres pros or a DCS 200. If you are going to claim you do "video projection" on anything short of break out rooms where you are just hooking a computer up to a little casio or eiki projector you know that you will ALWAYS use 5 wire (RGBHV) or, for longer runs for truss rigged front projection where cabling is a concern, you use a Magenta or similar. With this, you have a max run distance with the receiver of just over 600m over Cat 5. This cable is then normally just tossed at the end of the show as it is more of a pain in the ass and time consuming to wrap it and QC it, than it is to buy a 1000ft of it. Remind me to never book your company for anything ;) LOL

edit: As for your bent pins in the VGA... use your damn tweaker and bend them back into place. Now as to plastic release tab being broke... Cut the damn cable and take 3 minutes to put a new end on it. (3 minutes includes going to the video work box on site and getting the tools BTW) Now was that so hard? Let me guess... You went to Full Scam???

2
Xeracy•

First off, to be clear, video projection is not my day job. Nights and weekends, I provide visualizers (R4 is our mainstay, but I am also working on some custom live content) for DJs at clubs and parties as well as lighting and sound. I have personally been amassing a video rig that, imho, is fucking sweet considering anything half as close from any video rental house would cost an arm and a leg. Don't get me wrong, I would love to spend all the money in the world on video equipment, nice cables, and 10k Christie projectors, but that just isn't feasible for ANYONE who is trying to do this (a) on a budget or (b) without the backing of a real rental company. When someone is talking about ghetto-rigging a video cable, I can ONLY assume that they are in the same boat as myself. Now, I would never use any so-called professional company that skipped pro-quality cabling for cat5 bullshit. I've seen it done, and its not pretty.

Second, my video source is my desktop computer, not a video mixer or dvd player or whatnot. I do use DVI when the runs are short enough (under 25' - 30') but again, DVI is more expensive than VGA and an adapter.

Third, Fuck FullFail, I saw that as bullshit from a mile away!

Fourth, sure i can unbend a pin if it happens once, but its just a matter of time before one of the important pins breaks off completely.

Last, my rig consists of three truss mounted 3.3k eiki's forming one wide display of 3072x768 via a Matrox Triplehead2go from my desktop computer (its shitty, but im saving to buy a new computer in the next month or two). check out some vids and dont start a pissing contest unless you are doing better for cheaper. http://vimeo.com/rebelproductions/videos/all.

PS, if you have an inexpensive method of edge blending and/or software keystoning, then I am all ears.

2
Xeracy•

http://www.dailytech.com/So+Long+HDMI+New+Standard+for+AV+Uses+Ethernet+Cables/article18902.htm

great, everyone thinks shitty cables should transmit video... fml

1
[deleted]•

I do media work as well and we use 50' VGA a fair amount, although we mostly go with 25' as a goto cable. The longest VGA I have ever done is a little over 150', and even that had minimal loss. That said, most of our stuff is quick and dirty last minute setup, and when we have the option we rent the 5 wire breakout cables. I use the Cat5 on occasion though, when it's convenient.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Toukakoukan•

If you linked one of these up to a hub, would you end up being able to replicate the output to multiple monitors out of interest?

1
Aknot•

No, it does not convert the signal, just uses a different connection... You could solder on a SCART-contact (for example) and use that wire but that doesn't mean it will work when you plug it into the tv...

1
rantAccountOP•

Aknot is right, but you could 'make' your own hub by soldering on a few sockets, and splitting the load.

You'll have to measure of course if your source can handle that many outputs. Usually video cards can't handle more than 2 monitors from the same source.

1
Toukakoukan•

Ah yes, I suppose a hub would replicate the signal digitally rather than analog..ally..

1
b0dhi•

Why don't they just make VGA cables out of CAT5 in the first place?

1
stillalone•

I don't think they want people to accidentally connect their monitor to their Ethernet network when it isn't really using a compatible "protocol". A more detrimental and likely problem would be people connecting their Video card to their routers.

1
b0dhi•

They don't have to use the same socket shape/type. Just use the same transmission method. I.e., CAT5 with a different shape socket. Same with USB, etc. Why not just make them all with CAT5 tech with different socket shapes and allow us to use long ass cables for everything?

1
name_censored_•

Why not just make them all with CAT5 tech with different socket shapes and allow us to use long ass cables for everything?

Cat5 cable is unshielded (thin) because it uses twisted pairs - it measures the voltage difference between each wire in the pair, and they're twisted together so that any magnetic interference will affect them both equally. VGA just uses shielding because it's simpler (cheaper), because the vast majority of runs are only a meter or two, and because the video cable is probably the noisiest cable anyway (so you want it shielded for other cables/devices as much as for itself). Also, ethernet will re-send on failed ECC (FEC) - it's designed to tolerate failure, but video isn't.

Besides, you can always use digital (DVI/HDMI/DisplayPort). The quality doesn't attenuate with lower signal/noise ratio (it just cuts out at some point), so as long as your run isn't too long/too noisy, you'll be fine.

3
1over6bil•

If you don't have soldering skills you can get adapters for $5/ea http://www.cecompass.com/vgavideoextenderviacat5cat6rj45cableadapterkit.aspx

1