Looking for a commuter car. GDI vs PI vs Dual Injection

Hello all. I'm in a bit of bind. Can you help?

So my current vehicle(2006 Blazer) is getting long in the tooth. It's been trooper but if anything major goes out in it's probably going to be thousands of dollars to repair. Looking to buy a affordable commuter car that won't test my mediocre garage skills. I can change my oil. I can change my brakes. Taking off the head and fussing around the block? Not so much. The family mechanic is getting too old to fix our junkers and local mechanics are only 2 steps above telemarketers in integrity. I'm not poor but I'm not necessarily well off either. This will be a significant purchase for me.

Being doing research as I hear various myths and bullshit on the internet about new cars and lamenting for reliability of yesteryear. I tend to keep my cars forever. So how bad can it be?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=66C4YIiwRbM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xrLNDgrIw3U

Basically I don't won't to screw with GDI unless a specific brand/design can prove they've dealt with carbon deposits. Without having to delve into aftermarket solutions such as catchcans and cleaning kits. Any recommendations? On the other half of the question is what cars in the entry-level tier still use either port injection or dual? Google hasn't been very clear and even reddit's search results aren't too clear.

My research points to Toyota Corolla with dual injection, the Kia Forte/Soul with port injection. Any other options?

TL;DR Want to buy a car for the long haul. Apprehensive in potentially buying one with problems after 50k, 100k, or more miles. Halp. Thanks for reading this far.

Posted Jul 30, 2019, 9:17 AM UTC

34
HarvickAudiFordfan•

Modern cars are very reliable Compared to your Blazer. Don’t let anecdotal stuff dictate your decision.

Many cars are adopting dual injection. My Audi has it, many other VW products include it, Toyota has it and I believe Ford Ecoboost engines are including it as well.

3
mgobla•

Most VW products don't have it.

1
mgobla•

Good choice, I always advise against direct injetion only cars.

Regarding Forte / Soul only the 2.0 147hp engine is port injetion. The other engines aren't. The new models use a new, unproven (new for the brand) CVT transmission.

2017+ Hyundai Elantra is offered with the same 2.0 147 hp engine and a conventional transmission. New 2019 Veloster too (older not).

Toyota Corolla is very durbale, Camry too. Corolla Hybrid, Camry Hybrid and Prius even more so.

The Honda Civic base model is still available with a 2.0 152 hp PI engine. Stay away from the 1.5 GDI turbo on other trims.

The Ford Fusion has a 2.5 PI base engine (Hybrid is PI too, stay away from other engines and other Fords) and is offered with huge discounts: https://www.cars.com/for-sale/searchresults.action/?mdId=21175&mkId=20015&page=1&perPage=50&rd=99999&searchSource=SORT&sort=price-lowest&stkTypId=28880&zc=60606

If you want a manual transmission there is another option from Ford though: Fiesta with the 1.6 120 hp PI engine, offered with huge discounts for ~$12k (stay away from automatic Fiesta, horrible transmission issues, also stay away from other engines)

Chevrolet Spark, probably the most reliable current Chevrolet, offered brand new for $10k (discounts).

1
BjDrizzle69•

I've seen plenty of Di non turbo cars do fine at 200k. No mechanic though just a enthusiast.

1