"The dev enjoys playing the game" as a defining characteristic of roguelike
Yay, a discussion about what defines a roguelike, everyone's favourite topic.
In a video from roguelike celebration (a conference about roguelikes) the 3 developers of Rogue mention quite early, that they wanted to enjoy the game themselves, and that the randomness, procedural generation and need for item identification are decisions that were made because of this. Since I started thinking about developing a roguelike (long time ago without action :-D), this has been one of the main factors in how I though about the game and it seems to me that the same can be said about most of the roguelike ideas.
I understand it's quite vague definition build on even harder to define characteristic (fun), but maybe trying to define roguelike with a list of "scientifically observable" facts and features as Berlin interpretation tries, is a wrong concept. I don't want to say that "The dev enjoys playing the game" is an all encompassing definition and if there is a game that the dev does not enjoy plaing it can never be a roguelike, yet I think it could serve as a good guide. I think that the intention to enjoy the game one wrote himself/herself can be felt in many games.
Do you plan on creating your game in such a way, that you would enjoy playing it? Do you play your roguelike if you already made one? Do you think this is a futile goal that will never be reached, but should be attempted or not attempted and given up on?
Posted Jul 30, 2019, 10:41 AM UTC
I am primarily creating my game for my own needs. By that, I don't expect it to ever gain a big audience if it will ever reach a releasable state. Basically, it is an amalgamation of ideas I like in other games and such ideas which I would like to see in other games.
This could, of course, change if the game would get some fanbase at some point. But I will only think about that if it ever happens. I don't plan ahead for it.
To be fully honest, though, I do get the most fun out of it by actually developing the game, not necessarily by playing.
Oh yeah, a whole new level to it.
Still release the game some day, at least on itch.io for example. So someone can bump into it and get inspired.
I will release it at the point where it feels right and where it has some more value than being just one another generic implementation of the same genre lacking original ideas. And I would be very happy if I ever reach that goal.
... but this might take a few more years (or decades :D) given the amount of time I have for development.