"The dev enjoys playing the game" as a defining characteristic of roguelike

Yay, a discussion about what defines a roguelike, everyone's favourite topic.

In a video from roguelike celebration (a conference about roguelikes) the 3 developers of Rogue mention quite early, that they wanted to enjoy the game themselves, and that the randomness, procedural generation and need for item identification are decisions that were made because of this. Since I started thinking about developing a roguelike (long time ago without action :-D), this has been one of the main factors in how I though about the game and it seems to me that the same can be said about most of the roguelike ideas.

I understand it's quite vague definition build on even harder to define characteristic (fun), but maybe trying to define roguelike with a list of "scientifically observable" facts and features as Berlin interpretation tries, is a wrong concept. I don't want to say that "The dev enjoys playing the game" is an all encompassing definition and if there is a game that the dev does not enjoy plaing it can never be a roguelike, yet I think it could serve as a good guide. I think that the intention to enjoy the game one wrote himself/herself can be felt in many games.

Do you plan on creating your game in such a way, that you would enjoy playing it? Do you play your roguelike if you already made one? Do you think this is a futile goal that will never be reached, but should be attempted or not attempted and given up on?

Posted Jul 30, 2019, 10:41 AM UTC

6725
CrocodileSpacePope•

Do you plan on creating your game in such a way, that you would enjoy playing it?

I am primarily creating my game for my own needs. By that, I don't expect it to ever gain a big audience if it will ever reach a releasable state. Basically, it is an amalgamation of ideas I like in other games and such ideas which I would like to see in other games.

This could, of course, change if the game would get some fanbase at some point. But I will only think about that if it ever happens. I don't plan ahead for it.

To be fully honest, though, I do get the most fun out of it by actually developing the game, not necessarily by playing.

31
_escaronOP•

To be fully honest, though, I do get the most fun out of it by actually developing the game, not necessarily by playing.

Oh yeah, a whole new level to it.

Still release the game some day, at least on itch.io for example. So someone can bump into it and get inspired.

11
CrocodileSpacePope•

I will release it at the point where it feels right and where it has some more value than being just one another generic implementation of the same genre lacking original ideas. And I would be very happy if I ever reach that goal.

... but this might take a few more years (or decades :D) given the amount of time I have for development.

1
Kyzrati@GridSageGames | Cogmind•

I've always create my games first and foremost for my own enjoyment, and consider myself lucky that there are enough other people who enjoy the same sort of games I do :P. (I also play a fair bit!) That said, once you go from hobby development to commercial, there will also be a lot of focusing on other player needs as well as responding to their experiences and desires. But I don't think that excludes it from the "roguelike as enjoyed by dev" category, since this is more or less the same direction any larger roguelike project takes once it has a following, hobby or not. Not to mention improving the game and expanding it in different directions so that even more people can enjoy it grows the community, which in turn benefits everyone playing, since having people to talk to can be another fun facet of roguelikes :)

Anyway, in the end though I do think that the developer enjoying what they're making is often at the foundation of what a good roguelike is, a project of passion. (Though of course for some people the goal of that passion is not necessarily to play it, because a number of devs are in it just for the ability to bring a new game/world to life, or stretch their dev muscles and work on one for architectural reasons.)

(Back in 2014 I also wrote a bit about playing your own game as a dev here on my blog, when I was working on Cogmind's pre-alpha.)

9
_escaronOP•

That said, once you go from hobby development to commercial, there will also be a lot of focusing on

other player needs as well as responding to their experiences and desires.

Of course I never meant to exclude any other players from the game's focus. I think that some very experienced players can be even substituted for the developer, meaning that roguelikes that focus on giving the dev a good experience can still give good experience to someone who's been playing it for a long time already. Experienced player knows all the systems (almost) the same way as developer does). But focusing on new players is important if you want people playing your game, that's a no brainer.

Anyway, in the end though I do think that the developer enjoying what they're making is often at the foundation of what a good roguelike is, a project of passion.

True, that's why I find it interesting that it has been ignored by all of the roguelike definitions one can find around on the internet. Again, not saying it's the only thing that defines a roguelike game, but a good one should be aiming for it at least.

3
Kyzrati@GridSageGames | Cogmind•

True, that's why I find it interesting that it has been ignored by all of the roguelike definitions one can find around on the internet.

I don't think it's really related to the definition of a roguelike at all, it's merely a coincidence because traditional roguelikes are almost all indie/hobby games, and you're describing the vast majority of indie games here :P

4
_escaronOP•

I thought that indie games are mostly about commercial success, at least that's the feeling I get from GDC talks. :-D

However I know 0 indie developers so I can't really argue about this.

1
Kyzrati@GridSageGames | Cogmind•

GDC talks are not very representative of most indies! They're quite a small minority, but yeah if you're looking at a conference by full-time professional developers in both the indie and AAA world, obviously monetization and sustainability will be big topics :P

If you look at communities of developers, however, you get a very different picture.

5
Del_Duio2Equin: The Lantern Dev•

I thought that indie games are mostly about commercial success, at least that's the feeling I get from GDC talks. :-D

Then you're talking to the wrong people, friend!

1
Del_Duio2Equin: The Lantern Dev•

That said, once you go from hobby development to commercial, there will also be a lot of focusing on other player needs as well as responding to their experiences and desires.

Yeah man, that's the shitty part. What was once good is now bad in seemingly everyone else's eyes. All of the sudden you get "What, no animations?! Make them!" or "What?! No game over tune!? Make it!" or "What, it's not 4K HD compatible for me to play on my Steam Controller whilst I sit on the shitter from the other end of my house??"

Still working on that last bit.

1
Press0K•

My only motivation for making a roguelike is that there are a lot of unoriginal roguelikes and the original ones usually end up with a lot of things to complain about: that's just the nature of trying something new, you're less likely to get everything right.

I think there's a rogurlike out there waiting to be made that I would consider "perfect", and I want to play it, therefor the best way to guarantee that is to make it.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=QHHg99hwQGY This video should be mandatory viewing for any game developer, digital or otherwise. Pretty much all roguelikes are guilty of failing in at least 1 of these 20 ways, usually many (20 points are summarized in video desc.). Even games that I consider extremely good like Nethack have some of the same enjoyability issues.

I may be picky, but anyone with free time can make just another roguelike - as evidenced by the tutorials here and things like 7DRL.

2
_escaronOP•

Wow, no small challenge. I've seen the video, I would say pretty much any game, not only roguelikes, fail in at least 1 point.

I may be picky, but anyone with free time can make just another roguelike - as evidenced by the tutorials here and things like 7DRL.

Many times people are just starting out, the probability that your first game will be legendary is almost zero. However, many don't make it to another game, and so it looks like everyone is just making unoriginal stuff. Plus the problem with being original is that you don't want to overdo it. If you do, no one will understand your game and relate to it.

7
Press0K•

Many times people are just starting out, the probability that your first game will be legendary is almost zero.

not enough machine learning

2
Del_Duio2Equin: The Lantern Dev•

Many times people are just starting out, the probability that your first game will be legendary is almost zero

Splurging on a good publisher makes a huge difference, which is why I never splurged on a good publisher lol.

1
_escaronOP•

I think that you still have to have something really good to make the publisher interested. Plus we're not talking a good game here maybe not even great game. We're talking a legendary game like Magic: The Gathering. I'm not saying you won't have a chance to ever make it, I just think that the possibility of it being your first game is really small. You have to level up killing goblins before slaying Morgoth / taking the Amulet of Yendor.

1
dethb0y•

I'd be super curious to hear what u/kevingranade thinks of such a thing!

For me, personally, anything i program i program with myself as the first "target audience" and then go from there, game or otherwise.

2
kevingranade•

Well FWIW I don't consider cdda to be a roguelike, so there's that :D

"Writing a game you want to play", isn't unique to roguelike, but roguelikes are (usually) explicitly positioned as a hobby project that does not require mainstream acceptance. I think roguelikes produced by the main roguelike community have a tendency to look inward a bit more than is typical in the games industry, focusing more on the creator's vision for the game and the world it is in rather than on things like market trends or focus groups or polling. At the same time, roguelikes can be positioned to have much closer ties to their player communities and therefore be even more influenced by the players than some other genres.

At the end of the day, if the person in charge of game direction doesn't enjoy the game being written, I have a hard time believing that they can keep development on target, so this should be a property of all games.

3
dethb0y•

At the end of the day, if the person in charge of game direction doesn't enjoy the game being written, I have a hard time believing that they can keep development on target, so this should be a property of all games.

Yeah that's a solid point, imagine working on a game you hated every day..it'd be awful!

1
Del_Duio2Equin: The Lantern Dev•

It makes it very tough to stay with and finish from my experience. When you have to will yourself to finish something for a long time it may never get finished. Plus that tends to be when all those other ideas for new games come floating around, trying to derail progress :D

1
dethb0y•

Oh man that's the absolute worst thing in my experience - i'll be working on something and then boom i'll have a great idea...that is a whole other thing.

1
Del_Duio2Equin: The Lantern Dev•

Do you play your roguelike if you already made one?

Yeah, actually just got done a little while ago lol. I play it a lot, it's probably my best game and my only roguelike and I'm happy I can keep myself entertained for this long with it.

You should always aim to make a game that you yourself would want to play.

2
AgingMinotaurLand of Strangers•

I think it's an interesting point, and that comment from the developers of Rogue immediately resonated with me when I first heard it. In practice, it does depend a bit on the game and its stage of development. My own project has had iterations that were pretty streamlined and which I did enjoy playing. The current iteration is a bit empty, awaiting more content, so I'm not having a lot of fun testing it. Development itself still continues to give some pleasure, though :)

1
stuntaneousC#•

I'd say it's much more common for the genre but not defining.

1