Noob-ish question regarding final amount after brew.

Did our third ever brew today, doing extract kits. We started with the “premium” kit from morebeer.com. It comes with a larger 8.5 gallon kettle and a wort chiller, things I knew we’d need pretty soon after starting. First two batches (the American Ale that came with the kit, and an Oktoberfest done with ale yeast) went very well, but both were kits from More Beer. Third kit we purchased from Adventures in Homebrewing as it was on sale. It’s a cream ale. The instructions were a bit different from the ones that came with the more beer kit. The main difference was in the steeping of the specialty grains. The more beer kits had a “if you have a larger kettle, start with 6 gallons of water, steep grains until you hit 170* or 30 minutes.” The AIH kit just had starting with 2.5 gallons water, steep for 20 minutes, do your whole boil that way, then top up with water to 5.125 gallons total. Well, I figured the more beer kits went just fine, in the end it’s all the same, right? So I started with 6 gallons, etc. When all was said and done, I went paying super close attention when we transferred to primary, but looking at the lines on the fermenter, I’d say we ended up with somewhere between 3-4 gallons, also our OG was low, Target was 1.052 and we were at 1.047. It also looks REALLY dark for a cream ale. Now, I’ll admit I got a bit rushed on letting the grain bag drain, so I don’t know if that was it or what, but something seems off. Anyone have any insight?

Posted Aug 5, 2019, 2:27 AM UTC

3311
Aye_Lexxx•

Just to be clear, your OG was low even though you only ended up with 3-4 gallons of wort in the end? That’s kinda weird, if I’m understanding correctly. 1.047 isn’t too far from 1.052 at all and I normally wouldn’t be worried, but that’s assuming a normal 5 gallon (or 5.125 gallon, whatever it is) post boil volume. You’d imagine the sugars would be more concentrated and yield a higher OG than expected after all that water had been lost.

Whatever happened with the gravity, though, I doubt it has to do with the steeping grains. They don’t contribute many fermentable sugars at all, although if they were steeped for too long they may have made the beer a bit darker.

As for the color, extracts always produce darker beer than grain does. Brewing a “normal looking” (i.e. light yellowish) cream ale is probably impossible with extracts. My beers are almost always darker than I want them to be, but that’s just how it be with extracts. :)

21
fizgigtiznalkieIntermediate•

This sounds like it was a partial mash kit as cream ale usually has flaked corn. You need to be a lot more careful with time, temperature and volume with partial mash, you had low efficiency. It will probably taste fine but the lesson here is follow the kit directions or ask here before you brew it. not a big deal, your beer won’t be super far off the mark but you’ll have a dozen fewer bottles.

9
Fracking_ToastersOP•

Thank you. This sounds about right. All of the kits I’ve done have been “partial mash” I suppose in that they have the specialty grains you steep, then add the LME. The others were various malts, this one was 1 pound of flaked corn, and a half pound of another malt (recipe’s not on hand at the moment.) I was wondering if it was absorption from the grains that made the difference.

4
Sluisifer•

The other kits you did were not partial mash. Those were extract kits with steeping grains. All the fermentables come from the malt extract in those, and the steeping only provides flavor. Typically roasted or stewed malts are used here, with no diastatic power, but also no need for conversion. No mashing occurs.

With partial mash, you actually perform a mash. This means that enzymes in the grain convert starch to fermentable sugar. Reaching and maintaining a target temperature is very important for enzyme activity.

https://byo.com/newbrew/partial-mash/

Was this the kit? https://www.homebrewing.org/assets/images/Recipe_Instructions_2019/k99-2716.pdf

If so, they don't call it a partial mash, but going by the instructions, that's what it is.

Oddly, with 6 pounds of LME, it's hard to see how you got an OG of 1.47 with 3-4 gallons of wort. The LME alone should get 4 gallons above 1.050. So perhaps you're off with measuring the volume, or maybe the hydrometer reading. Hydrometer readings are temperature dependent; you can only get a good measurement when they're at their calibration temp (room temp).

7
paraclete01•

That's an interesting kit. Why would they have someone use flaked wheat and maize without diastatic malt to provide enzyme conversion? Does the unconverted corn and wheat starch make it extra creamy?

I've had 2 brews when I started partial mashing where I was trying for 1.050 with 5 gallons and only got 1.040 with 4 gallons but I'm 100% sure my issue was bad crushing of grains at the store combined with bad sparge technique. When I borrowed my friends Cereal killer mill my next 2 brews hit 1.050 at 5 gallons perfectly.

From the info, my thought is that maybe not all the of the Liquid Malt made it into the initial 6 gallons combined with the rushing of draining the grain bag. I know how hard it is to drain those liquid malt cans if they're not soaked in hot water first and then rinsed with hot water. To go from 6 gallons to under 4 gallons during the boil is a lot of evaporation. Average is 1 gal per hour right? An extended or really hot boil would account for the darker color too.

Next time I'd make sure the cans were empty(assuming they weren't Toasters) and add 1 lb of crushed 2-row or 6-row or maris otter with the flakes and then put on gloves and squeeze the bag like it owes you money. I find it really hard to squeeze 170'F wort myself without gloves. 1.047 in 4 gallons can still be a great beer.

2
Fracking_ToastersOP•

That’s not the exact kit, but essentially the same one, just with the fruit addition. The OG of 1.047 was after temperature correction.

1
Sluisifer•

FWIW, I've found those corrections to be unreliable if the temperature is far off from the calibration temp. Like if it's 140 instead of 70, I wouldn't trust that corrected number.

2
kyonlionBeginner•

Just a thought, if you're using LME it could be that some extract was left out. Gotta really take a spatula to those cans, rinse it out with strike water a few times, get every last drop until the can is clean.

1
kharnynb•

If you used lme, did you dissolve it well enough?

1
t3hn1ck•

The AIH method is a great way to make terrible tasting beer. More Beer is more on par with how you should do a partial mash extract brew. I'll explain why.

For one, leaving the grains in the entire boil after steeping in the bag (if that is really what they intend) will pull a lot of tannins and other off flavors from the grain that will find its way in the beer. It's a lazy practice as well considering doing BIAB is similar but you are using more grains and you are removing them from the wort after mashing them. BIAB is as close as you can get to doing complete all grain brewing without having to buy into the equipment to do it efficiently. BIAB is labor intensive too, and a great way to go if you don't have the space or equipment for all grain.

Secondly, adding fresh water after a boil to top it off is a great way to introduce contaminants and bugs into the beer that can ruin the beer in many ways. You always want boil anything that will come into contact with the yeast before it is pitched, and you want to make sure you protect the wort while it cools to pitching level because bacteria and other wild yeast/bugs will thrive at lower temperatures. Hot wort at flameout will not be hot enough to completely pasteurize all of the water used to top off the volume.

Always start with a higher boil volume and boil it down to increase target OG. Add some adjuncts if needed, but not in excess so the beer isn't too hot from the alcohols or too light in body for the intended style.

-4
kharnynb•

Might also just have been bad dissolving lme, which will mean alcohol bomb....

Ps.biab is all grain, just not 3 vessel

1