Noob-ish question regarding final amount after brew.
Did our third ever brew today, doing extract kits. We started with the “premium” kit from morebeer.com. It comes with a larger 8.5 gallon kettle and a wort chiller, things I knew we’d need pretty soon after starting. First two batches (the American Ale that came with the kit, and an Oktoberfest done with ale yeast) went very well, but both were kits from More Beer. Third kit we purchased from Adventures in Homebrewing as it was on sale. It’s a cream ale. The instructions were a bit different from the ones that came with the more beer kit. The main difference was in the steeping of the specialty grains. The more beer kits had a “if you have a larger kettle, start with 6 gallons of water, steep grains until you hit 170* or 30 minutes.” The AIH kit just had starting with 2.5 gallons water, steep for 20 minutes, do your whole boil that way, then top up with water to 5.125 gallons total. Well, I figured the more beer kits went just fine, in the end it’s all the same, right? So I started with 6 gallons, etc. When all was said and done, I went paying super close attention when we transferred to primary, but looking at the lines on the fermenter, I’d say we ended up with somewhere between 3-4 gallons, also our OG was low, Target was 1.052 and we were at 1.047. It also looks REALLY dark for a cream ale. Now, I’ll admit I got a bit rushed on letting the grain bag drain, so I don’t know if that was it or what, but something seems off. Anyone have any insight?
Posted Aug 5, 2019, 2:27 AM UTC
Just to be clear, your OG was low even though you only ended up with 3-4 gallons of wort in the end? That’s kinda weird, if I’m understanding correctly. 1.047 isn’t too far from 1.052 at all and I normally wouldn’t be worried, but that’s assuming a normal 5 gallon (or 5.125 gallon, whatever it is) post boil volume. You’d imagine the sugars would be more concentrated and yield a higher OG than expected after all that water had been lost.
Whatever happened with the gravity, though, I doubt it has to do with the steeping grains. They don’t contribute many fermentable sugars at all, although if they were steeped for too long they may have made the beer a bit darker.
As for the color, extracts always produce darker beer than grain does. Brewing a “normal looking” (i.e. light yellowish) cream ale is probably impossible with extracts. My beers are almost always darker than I want them to be, but that’s just how it be with extracts. :)