Planes can kill tanks in one hit, but AA can't kill planes in one pass.

Discussion

I get that AA used to be too strong, but now AA is too weak, and planes are too strong. A plane can drop a bomb and instakill any tank other than a full health heavy tank without them being able to do anything. The only defense against this is AA which can't kill planes fast enough to be a threat to them. When you pull and AA tank the enemy bombers will beeline straight at you to drop bombs because they know that you can't kill them in one pass, but that they can absolutely kill the AA. Static AA is in an even worse spot since it can't move.

So why not make bombs do a little less damage, and be able to tank less damage? Because right now they don't have to worry about anything other than other pilots, but if you don't have any good pilots taking fighters, then the enemy will just rain bombs forever. It's more fun to have a balanced game where ground is a serious threat to air, and air is a serious threat to ground, but right now that is out of balance.

Posted Aug 5, 2019, 2:51 AM UTC

8330
hawkseye17•

AA is extremely weak in this game.

20
klarcwgrizwald•

I just want the valentine ground tank to be able to kill a plane with one shell. I have hit over 20 planes in the last week all for 77 damage with that tank...

17
Mechatroniik•

You need to use AP shells. But... In Panzer 38T you need to use normal shells. AP shell make 37 damage. What a stupid,broken game. Sometimes I met with this:

https://gfycat.com/pl/definitivefantasticdwarfmongoose-battlefieldv

9
TheSausageFattener[*V*] Free_Burd•

Why the fuck does the AP shell deal more damage to a plane than the so-called default “HE shell”.

3
DlLDO_Baggins•

Wouldn’t AP just harmlessly punch a small hole and come out the other side IRL?

2
TheSausageFattener[*V*] Free_Burd•

Depending on the size of the round and velocity yes.

A lot of shells only arm after penetrating a certain amount of “stuff”. Its why HEAT and Shaped Charge, which are basically the premature ejaculation of tank munitions, can be stopped by things like cage or sheet armor panels (see: “bedspring” armor on Soviet vehicles to counter the Panzerfaust or Schurzen on Stugs, Panzer 3s, and Panzer IV

2
klarcwgrizwald•

I get that all the time and it is infuriating. I all but stopped playing infantry in this game because of the one frames general crap that happens with infantry play to discover that vehicles were an absolute after thought and just as if not more infuriating. I dont want to get started on the assault vs tank ridiculousness. I have good rounds but the single most maddening thing to me is maneuvering around fighting tanks to my advantage and not taking damage for the 30 to 45 seconds it takes to kill another tank and 1 lone assault that you cant hear sneaks up and im dead in 3 seconds flat. Even better, a TANK having to run away from one lone assault while trying to shoot them before they can catch up to your snail speed transmission and take you out with the wired dynamite that they can seemingly throw as far as a baseball.
It is satisfying to kill those assaults chasing you though. Also satisyfying to take a tank down as assault but that shouldnt happen unless 2 of them are working to take one down. I could go on and get into terrible vehicle spawn icons and bugs but said i didnt want to get started. Sorry.....

0
BananasAndSporks•

Ditto actually...staghound shell did about 50 as well.

5
ninjoman1•

I have killed planes in 1 hit in the valentine, i dont know if they are already slightly damaged as they get to me but it is possible to kill them. I find it easier than AA guns which literally do nothing. Also the spitfire at level1 is terrible at taking out other aircraft, takes me an eternity to level it up.

2
d_rek•

Buff the AA guns and then all the crybaby fly boys start whining about how air combat is ruined. You can’t win.

But in all seriousness AA needs a buff.

16
ShanityFlanity•

Air combat is already ruined though.

5
GodsTopWarrior•

I'd rather 1 portion of the game being a tiny bit weaker, while making the rest of the game 100x better.

3
ghunt81•

I really like flying planes but I agree- the AA in this game is terrible. You have to have 2 guns team up on one plane to have any chance of shooting it down. When I'm flying, even in a mosquito I can dive bomb an AA gun that's shooting at me and blow it up, and still have almost half my health left. Yet, if you get a fighter on your butt they can take you out in seconds. I'm not sure where the balance is.

10
NoMoreChillies•

i guess you didnt see the 400lb bomb bounce off German light tank video posted here before

8
SirFappington007•

I've had good success with aa, multiple instances of shooting down all enemy planes, if you aim right you can do a lot of damage. If you didn't do much damage, then either move from the aa or get on a different one. It's a good idea to not shoot them from far off cos all you'll do is guide them to your location while doing shit damage

4
Suyogya17:ps:Malevolent-Glare:hamster:•

You are right, aim at the engines and it’s a pretty quick kill. Skill is rewarded when using AA.

Same goes with Bomber gunner seat (upgraded), you can kill a Fighter in full health in 3 seconds if you aim at the engine.

4
SirFappington007•

Yeah I like to wait for them to line up with me to an extent (while they don't know I'm on aa) and then unleash hell. A lot of pilots panic when taking lots of aa damage and fuck up (I also think it's a good idea to prioritise those in combat with friendly planes. A tip for going against aa I've picked up is when your getting hit by it, start to fly low asap, it's easier to break line of sight if you fly low and also makes your return approach to bomb the aa guy less trackable. But saying that I'm no red baron

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3†
J-A-G-E-Rjager-lebensmude•

Tbh I think slot of this is people don't lead AA correctly either so they get spash damage not the full potential. I fly a bit and a decent player in AA will push my shit in.

8
ANEPICLIE•

A fighter, maybe. You simply cannot kill a bomber with one overheat of a single AA

5
papaburkart•

You're right. But I don't just hold the trigger until I overheat.

1
Beta1548•

Keep moving

Seriously. “Oh man I beep getting bombed sitting in the middle of a field and not moving”. It’s so easy to just drive around in circles; makes it almost impossible for them to hit you, or at least makes them have to be suuuuper good pilots to instakill you.

1
ghunt81•

Well another problem is the AA placements on many of the maps have terrible lines of sight, either being between/beside buildings (like Twisted Steel) or down in gun pits surrounded by sand bags (like Hamada). Probably somewhat realistic for how they would be placed to protect the gunner(s), but gives you a very small window to actually fire at passing aircraft. And if you're on a gun that is more exposed, you usually get sniped pretty quick.

1
Fools_RequiemFools_Requiem•

It's easier to aim and shoot the AA than it is to fly a plane and then survive long enough to find a tank and destroy it.

2†
Manofthedecade•

I spent some time on an AA gun this weekend in Fjell and Narvik just to get a good feel for the AA guns since I hadn't used them much.

Definitely couldn't kill a plane on a single pass. Best I got was about 86. The gun overheats too quick, and that was using a support engineer. Most of my kills were made in combination with a fighter helping out. Otherwise I'd get 35-55ish on a single pass.

But I had one game where a guy kept dive bombing at me. I'd be shooting him dead center as he came down at me. He won 6 out 7 times. I'd get 75-85ish dmg before I'd overheat and he'd get the last shots in.

Unless you're using the AA guns in the spawn camps, then it's useless anyway. The AA guns are otherwise placed in the middle of objectives and you have about a minute before you're sniped out of there - assuming you're lucky enough to have teammates doing defense around the gun.

AA Guns need a better zoom and a slightly faster projectile speed. Leading a target is a pain. Also wouldn't mind if hitting with an AA gun would spot the target. It's sometimes almost impossible to tell if you're looking at a friend or foe.

1
Akipac•

Not true I got a 77% damage on a Stuka that was annoying me. It didn’t kill him but I guess he freaked out and crashed so it did “kill him”.

1
Akipac•

But there was this one time a Stuka smacked me really hard (like 4% health left) then my PS4 crashed. That’s a surprise mechanic dice or Sony added.

1
CC_Sixteen•

Didn't they buff the AA recently? I can almost swear they did because when I fly I take A LOT more damage than I did previously. Enough where making one pass results in me having to evade and repair usually. Especially if the AA gunner is zeroed in on me specifically. I know that I've shot a few planes down with the AA when previously they would take a little damage and be too far away. Does the mobile AA (towed) do more damage than stationary?

0
byfo1991byfo1991•

Because hitting a plane with tank takes a lot of skill and let's be honest quite a bit of luck as well. It is a rare occasion and should be awarded. On the other hand, spamming AA on planes doing bombing runs is one of the easiest things in the entire game. So I do not have problem with this and I rarely ever play as pilot in BFV.

-4
labsx•

maybe you should stop firing when the plane moves in to make it harder to spot your location

-5
CoyoteWhite305•

How about we give AA an ammo count instead of infinity and the player actually has to manually reload the thing.

-5