OCing Micron E-Die -- A.K.A. Sub-timings matter a lot for Zen2.
TLDR: Skip to table at bottom of post
So this is my adventure with a kit of Micron E-die that was ~$80 including tax. This is a new 2x8GB kit of Ballistix Sport LT, purchased directly from Crucial on July 26, and I spent much of my spare time since receiving it testing out different settings and timings.
Motherboard is MSI x570 Gaming Plus (cheap end of x570 for sure). CPU is a 3600x. Windows 10 1903. BIOS is most recent, but based on AGESA 1.0.0.3A. Most recent chipset drivers were installed.
For the purposes of finding memory differences and keeping the CPU from boosting differently on different runs, I am running at 4.00 GHZ all core for the gaming benchmark (this made run to run results MUCH more consistent.) AIDA tests were at stock CPU boosting.
I'm very happy with how this 2x8GB kit overclocks. Initally, I worked on DDR4-3600 testing and achieved 14-19-16-36 at 1.41v. Didn't have any real success above 3600 until I moved to 2T command rate.
In ~20 years of OCing, I've never run 2T command rate, but decided to try it, and glad I did.
DDR4-3800 settled in at 15-20-17-38 2T @ 1.40v
tRCD (read) does not scale with voltage at all. You can basically just scale it in the time domain to the new speed and and it's always the same number in time domain. As a result the sticks at XMP of 3000 may end up with lower tRCD, but I don't know if they will do as well with frequency/voltage?
Then I dialed in subtimings... Here are screenshots of each with Ryzen Master so you can see all timing and AIDA benchmarks
3600 -- https://imgur.com/VXz5Z4l
3800 -- https://imgur.com/AyH4FGc
Both have been validated 3600% coverage with HCI memtest, even though only the 3800 screenshot shows it. 3600 validated at 1.41v, but I put it up to 1.42 for extra margin. (Added 0.01v to the 3800 in my BIOS profile after this screenshot for the same purpose)
AIDA was showing a substantial improvement for 3800 despite the 2T command rate, so I wanted to see how it would work in gaming. I always set up new computers in a spare case as a testbench to play around with before making them my primary computer, so this has my 3rd string Radeon HD7850 paired with the 3600x. Not much to test that isn't going to have a GPU bottleneck. But Shadow of the Tomb Raider has an output that tells you what the FPS would be if CPU limited... so I used that. Settings were 1080p very high, but with HBAO and Motion Blur off.
Average of multiple runs rounded to nearest 0.5 FPS -- sigma ~2(MAX) ~1(AVG) <1(95%). I really wanted to tell the difference between 3600 tuned subs and 3800 tuned subs, so these are 10 runs each averaged. The delta between these is small, but consistent and repeatable. I haven't run a p-test, but I'd be really surprised if the difference was not statistically significant based on looking at the individual runs. Seems like a small, but consistent gain for the 3800.
MIN FPS removed due to lack of consistency / high sigma.
Reported values are "CPU GAME" results from SotR benchmark
| Speed | 3200 | 3200 | 3600 | 3800 | 3600 | 3800 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Timing | 16-18-18-1T | IF@1900 | 14-19-16-1T | 15-20-17-2T | subtiming | subtiming |
| MAX FPS | 170.0 | 171.0 | 183.0 | 182.0 | 187.0 | 189.0 |
| AVG FPS | 125.0 | 125.5 | 132.5 | 133.5 | 139.5 | 141.0 |
| 95% | 95.5 | 95.0 | 99.5 | 100.5 | 106.0 | 107.0 |
Analyzing this:
- DDR4-3200 is about the same at 1600 infinity fabric or 1900 (for SoTR... Obviously could be different for other games)
- About +6% AVG FPS and +4% for 5% lows in SoTR going from 3200CL16 to 3600CL14.
- 3800 2T with tuned subs is slightly faster than 3600 1T with tuned subs. So 2T command rate can be made up with IF speed and 200 MHz.
- Subtimings are HUGE. 6-7% on AVG FPS and on 5% lows... Overall a (slightly) bigger gain than 3200C16-->3600C14
- Overall gain from OCing memory in this title was about 12% (!) if CPU limited.
- You do not need super expensive memory to get big gains from tweaking your memory.
Subtiming tuning is a really big deal, but not all that difficult if you get HCI memtest and memtesthelper to validate. Pretty much anyone should be able to squeeze something like 5% FPS on CPU limits just tuning the subs. Sub-timings I tuned included only the following:
- tRC
- tRFC
- tWR
- both of the xSC_L timings
- tFAW
Leave plenty of margin on tRFC, it's known to be a bit of a slow killer to corrupting files if you don't leave margin (10-15ns or so.... ~15-25 cycles) Don't just bump up 1-2 cycles when it's not stable, bump ~15 or more.
Posted Aug 5, 2019, 3:21 PM UTC · edited
I recently learned, that tFAW and tRRD make such a huge difference in CS:GO and other Source Engine games.
I gained 40 FPS (~420 to ~460) on my R7 2700 in the benchmark map, just by adjusting them from the ridiculously high Auto settings (like 11-13 52) to 4-4 16 with my Samsung OEM C-Die memory.
Thanks for sharing!
Good catch.
What is your c-die oc? Would love to know as i have been eyeing in them since forever.
My best 2 4GB C-Die sticks out of the 12 I binned do 3660Mhz CL16-(17/21)-17-37-69 daily (stable) at 1.46V with my B450-I Strix and R7 2700 (trash IMC). I could probably get the primaries even a bit lower (tRCDWR and tRP seemed to have a bit of buffer), tighten the tertiaries, and lower the SOC voltage but for me, the effort is not worth it at this moment.
EDIT: I get 550 FPS in the CS:GO benchmark map with 64tick, affinity tweak, Windows 1607 LTSB, and 4.0Ghz CPU OC ;) I'm looking forward to getting a Vega 56, already ordered it but shipping from Germany will take a while... I'm GPU bottlenecked at the lowest settings with my current R9 280 @1150/1400 -_-
Damn, you are actually getting like 120 fps higher than me and i have a vega 64.
Provided i used a mix of low and high settings at 1440x1080 with a 1700x but still that is a huge improvement.
Mind you, that's NOT just the RAM settings. I use the affinity tweak w/ ProcessLasso from drax (here), and I have to use a very old version of Windows 10 (1607 LTSB N) so the scheduler doesn't mess with it. I also do all benchmarks with 640x480 and lowest settings, anything higher wrecks my GPU. When I actually get my blower Vega 56 (got a great deal for 219€ on Mindfactory), I bet I could hit the 580-600 range, since often in certain parts of the benchmark (especially in smokes) I get 100% GPU utilization. (even at 640x480)
At 1024x768 or higher it's pointless for me to do the benchmark, since my GPU gets tapped out, and I get like 400 fps tops at 1440x1080.
https://ctrlv.cz/7oDh - screenshot of full settings