Adults who read YA fiction are objectively more stupid than Trump voters
Posted Aug 7, 2019, 7:07 AM UTC
Posted Aug 7, 2019, 7:07 AM UTC
I know of only 3 Trump voters, but while I wouldn’t necessarily call them smart, they are all vastly kinder and more ethical people than anyone I know who voted for Hil dog
honest and brave admission
Western culture is in deep decline but Harry Potter and Hunger Games while they're hardly appropriate for adults to read (other than to share an experience with their own children) they're hardly dumber than what passes for adult entertainment (action movies based on comic books which are literal picture books, duck dynasty, zombie soap operas, police hero procedurals)
superhero movies are for kids/teens not adults
I agree if we're being prescriptive but not if we're being descriptive
no, the original target audience is teens
shut up bitch
u'r being retarded
sure but let's remember that from time to time, a really great popular movie event does occur. Mad Max: Fury Road and Blade Runner 2049 spring to mind.
> popular movie event
> 2049
come on man we all fucking wish
It did well! It just happened to cost a lot too. But a sequel is in the works, that's the only thing that matters. And that the sequel is also strong.
But a sequel is in the works, that's the only thing that matters.
!!!! Did not know that! hell yeah brother
the fact that adults are retreating to art that's similar to what they normally consume, but has an even lower bar, is what truly has convinced me that culture is in deep decline.
i'd like to imagine that adults with normie attitudes/beliefs/tastes would, 90% of the time, engage w/ normie media, but then when they get bored try something not-for-children. guess i idealized adults, lol
[deleted]
Nope. Adults that read at all are smarter than most adults because that's how dumb adults are.
I continue to believe that with YA novels you might as well be scrolling through twitter, at least you learn things online
no, and frankly the beating up on YA fiction and drawing analogies between it and events is just a meme you uncritically received from twitter and it made you smarter rather than dumber. You're expressing an opinion to signal membership in a particular community rather than saying anything useful or meaningful about the world. I read the first two Harry Potter books and I didn't need to read more, but they're well written and capture some of the mystery of being a child and the feeling of navigating the hidden world within the world, the caprice of social institutions, and familiarize readers with tropes that draw upon the broad history of western folklore etc. They're not books for adults and they don't approach social or inner life with the same sensitivity or nuance as the best literature but they're not empty calories either.
People beat on adults who obsess over HP & other YA fiction / put it on a pedestal and don't really read anything else.
It's fine and fun for kids.
It's cringe when adults act like it's some extremely novel allegory for the current state of affairs or act like there are lessons or themes to be learned from HP that aren't exhaustively covered elsewhere.
This is more defensible but it's still too much probably. The US has no real mass literary culture for anyone but children so if you're drawing on literature as a shared reference to communicate about the world it's almost necessary to draw upon children's literature because most americans stop reading completely once they get out school. As such I see the phenomenon as a symptom of a greater disease.
it's too bad we can't all be as stunningly smart as you Gordon
Agreed.
This thread has so many closeted Harry Potter fans in it it’s not even funny. Great nerve touching, OP.
Harry Potter is aesthetically Steam Punk Lite and also, most of the magic in the series is used to basically do chores/domestic labor which is fulfillment of an unimaginative and perverse liberal fantasy: your house gets cleaned and you never have to talk to an immigrant woman.
they also just have slaves though
I recently read "Among Others" and "Kafka on the Shore."
They're almost the same story but one is YA, and the setting (UK vs. Japan) is different. It seems empty to me to claim that people who read "Among Others" are vapid and dumb whereas people who read "Kafka on the Shore" are smart.
Honestly, I have respect for the people who still read at all. Most of the people I know are functionally illiterate.
murakami isn’t highbrow. he’s the literary equivalent of cookie dough and i love him.
murakami is middle-brow defined. someone who reads the guaradian, because it's more continental than the NYT, yet doesn't really read much fiction, would absolutely eat that shit up.
don't get me wrong, i've read several murakami novels and actually enjoyed them. but anyone who mentions murakami right away when you mention literature are aspiritonal middle-brow dumbasses
Murakami is trash though
no he's good even if he wrote the same book like 5 times.
nonsense
Well there's also a lot of seemingly highbrow literary fiction for adults, who can't deal with the complicated worldview and morally ambiguous characters of YA novels.
I don't care what people read or what they like. I'm just glad they read but the problem arises when your hobby becomes who you are. People are( at least should be) more complex than just liking Harry Potter but a lot of people let their hobbies become their personality. I will accept a person who wont shut up about Harry Potter before I accept a person who wont shut up about the Office/Friends.
decent take
Equating your bullshit pearl clutching liberal hysteria to Harry Potter situations is the gayest shit on earth but it’s still a great story and a massive, complete world.
it's a tightly plotted seven book children's series, with well-drawn characters, muddled themes and a botched ending. the fact that it is a genuine cultural phenomenon means that it's necessary reading if you are a kid or if you have a kid, but--while I'd hesitate to interfere with anyone's enjoyment of a thing--it's not good art, dude.
I disagree about the botched ending, and while I’m certain that people with better taste in art and literature are put off by it I’m happy to enjoy it.
Every problem is caused my magic...then solved by magic. Which is completely arbitrary and with no rule or systems and isn’t explained. It’s gay and shitty fantasy.
[deleted]
Nah Eragon is also gay. Tolkien and Le Guin has far superior magic that was rare and had more impact when it was used, and was more mystical. Something akin to divine intervention. Harry Potter’s magic is common and trivial.
[deleted]
Sounds autistic to me
Guilty as charged
I'm extremely proud of the fact that I stopped reading the first one after the first chapter when I was 14 because it was clearly trash
but it’s still a great story and a massive, complete world.
Harry Potter is the literature equivalent of those North Korean tours. They're amazing as long as you dont know any better and never question or think about anything regarding that world.
What does a better job of fantasy world building? Maybe Tolkien but those fucking books suck they are boring as shit it’s a bunch of dudes describing walking around.
Only Hogwarts is cool. The greater world is shit and barely fleshed out.
Libs get out, read the Sam kriss piece
it’s okay to read for fun
Patrician Clinton voter checking in.
i'm assuming this includes houellebecq
The Elementary Particles is one of the best novels written while i was alive (1991+).
I liked submission, if only because it was a good view into the right-wing mindset (at least for the right-wingers skeptical of liberalism).
should i read any of his other shit?
why are you asking people if you should read things
ok, i'll put the question in a form your babby brain can understand:
i intend to read another houellebecq book at some point.
QUESTION (!!): which of them should i read next?
i don't care what you read, pick one, faggot
Read the Red Rising series on vacation recently. Guess I have to bow to my MAGA betters now.
I read it too, I thought it was fun.
That’s probably the best way to describe it. Makes for a decent Baby’s First Class Consciousness intro.
super fresh take there lol
People are reading the Bible.
so what do you think we should do with these stupid people u/NegativePositive? death camps? summary execution? forced labour? re-education camps?
I personally don’t believe people who I consider less intelligent than me should be punished.
ok so what should we do to try to bring them up to speed.
My reaction to claims like this is always “we can’t be like the libs and tell people what they’re allowed to enjoy” but then I actually meet a YA fiction reader and am reminded this is true
I don't want to grow up, I'm a YA fiction kid.
this is incontrovertibly true. unironically: disagree at your peril
literally the only YA readers worth forgiving are writers trying to break into a surging market who are forced to read this shit to get an idea of what sells. for them...well, while i wouldn't do that shit myself, i totally get it. so ur cool
Clearly OP is not well versed in YA fiction and has no idea what they're talking about. The genre is deemed young adult because the main characters are young adults, and therefore more relatable to young adults, not because the books are easier to read or less dense. It covers heavy topics just the same as adult fiction. Trump voters are stupid for supporting a racist and general dick of a president and ignoring his overall shittiness. There really is no comparison.
lol...YA and literary fiction might both "cover heavy topics" but YA certainly beats you over the fucking head with how you're supposed to feel about it
not a good take
Trump guys usually have better taste than libs just because they’re braindead morons who think old=good which means they end up liking or pretending to like a bunch of great stuff instead of liking Harry Potter and Marvel
hmmm. taste isn’t just what you like, it’s why you like it.
I don't understand taste that way. Taste is kind of a binary: you like something or you don't. Like you like something and you're not really sure why you like it you just intuitively do. Taste as such is mysterious and by trying to analyze your own taste you can try and identify the forces that govern you.
Taste is what u feel in ur brain after u eat food lol
sorry but this is a bad take. it's sad that we tend to know way less about why we feel certain ways about the objects and pursuits we're devoted to, than we do about the objects and pursuits themselves.
Speaking of YA, did you just lift a line from Infinite Jest without attribution?
It wasn’t really a take, I was just trying to define taste. It’s intuitive, it’s a sensibility. Rationalizing why you like something comes after the work of taste has been done. Subjectively, taste occurs as the tautology “I like it because I like it.” I think it’s easier to explain the taste of other people (he likes Marvel movies because he’s a man baby faggot) than your own. Once you start to intellectualize your taste and let these rationalizations change it, your taste becomes more like an affectation (I pretend to like Marvel movies so my brother won’t think I’m an asshole) than a pure expressionof desire. Though rethinking it, maybe I’m conflating desire and taste, and taste is something like desire equipped with the blinders of self image.
[deleted]
[deleted]