Alright! I respect your decision. (customer service A+)

So I've been using my (wired) pixel buds on my commute since I started a new job in May. I've had my P3 since October and before that it was the 2xl.

This past month I've noticed the phone struggling to charge and get a connection to my earphones. I've heard all about the problems with the port degrading over time so figured I'd see what Google had to say about it. The good news, ports are covered! The bad news is that any cosmetic damage means you have to get it fixed prior to sending it back, just so they can send you a brand new phone regardless. (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻

I'm beyond frustrated right now, I don't want to spend $200 getting a back panel fixed just get a brand new phone for what's effectively a defect.

The best part was the final part of the conversation with support. I don't think consumer loyalty is high on their priorities.

https://i.imgur.com/WiIOLpi.jpg

Posted Aug 8, 2019, 5:33 AM UTC

421
cdegallo•

I feel like you're misrepresenting the situation. They can't work on broken glass because they can't disassemble, work on, and reassemble without further cracking the glass. So they can't guarantee delivery of the phone in a similar state it was in/without further damaging it. They also shouldn't be doing a warranty exchange because you'd be giving them a broken phone and getting an intact one back.

This is how virtually every manufacturer works. Yes, there are exceptions that people have been given in some places, but those are exceptions.

12
navjot94Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

Exactly, Apple would handle the situation the same way. You have to get the screen fixed first and then they can fix your issue.

4
aRandomNameHereOP•

You know, I would have been completely fine with this explanation had they not led with the fact that they would replace the phone and not fix it.

The entire explanation is that I need to fix the glass on the phone so they will then be able to replace it which makes me wonder what the point is of fixing the glass in the first place.

0
cdegallo•

To keep people from defrauding warranty service by using it as a free accidental damage protection program.

3
aRandomNameHereOP•

that makes me curious to know how many people would accidentally damage their phone then go out of their way to further damage it in a way that it would be supported by warranty

1
cdegallo•

It only takes one shitty person exploiting a system to ruin it for everyone.

2
SnowBliz•

I feel your pain. My Pixel 3 has phone call audio issues and camera issues, but they won't fix it under warranty until I get my screen fixed... The screen damage does not affect functionality or usability at all, and fixing it is like $200-300.

I guess in my case their decision makes sense though. Due to my screen damage, they probably can't open up the phone without possibly further messing up my screen.

But that last part of your conversation, how do you think they should have responded?

5
LucasMarten•

If they needed to repair any internal physical components I can see how a broken screen would prevent that given that the screen needs to be removed to access the internals

3
aRandomNameHereOP•

"we don't want you to feel dissatisfied with your experience with Google, let me escalate your case to a specialist and hopefully they can help you more"

The twitter team had that immediate reaction after I was like "wtf m8?"

-1
gatorsrule52•

Do you have insurance on it? If not, I honestly would have said the same thing. Don't you think it would've been far more productive to ask for an escalation rather than make a passive agressive comment? That's not how communication works if you want it to be effective...

It was fine customer service since he gave you a solution to your problem. Gather the money and get it fixed, then get the port replaced or maybe the place you go to can do it at the same time.

It works like this with any manufacturer. If you don't have insurance, physical damage supersedes any other defect so that has to be solved first. I doubt a supervisor could even help.

Even if you got an iPhone and a similar issue occured, they would tell you the same thing if you didn't have AppleCare.

3
c0meary•

Unfortunately this is pretty par for the course in cellular and most electronics. Despite what you want repaired being a manufacturer defect, the device also shows signs that void what can be replaced under warranty. I absolutely hated having to tell people that for a job I used to have.

Even worse was when the same device would come in for the same defects but the MFG hadn't deemed them a defect yet. You'd have to charge these people a warranty repair fee when you knew damn well it wasn't their fault. Not to mention once it became a known defect and they brought it in again and this time it's free... the industry does its employees no favors.

3
Metalnakls•

Same charging problems though

2
ThestarmoopsPixel 3 XL :pixel3xlblack:•

My charging is fine, but my audio connection is super sensitive through USB C, like if I touch it it'll stop playing audio.

Google said I can send my phone back and get a refurbished unit, but I have to wait for them to get it first, and then wait to get the replacement. Not to mention god knows what could be wrong with the refurbished unit.

1
DSCarter_Tech•

If it's refurbished, then nothing will be wrong with it. It will be in better working condition than the phone you have. Take that deal.

Yes, the rep's response at the end was super weird, but the remedy offered was completely appropriate.

2
birdvsworm•

This sucks and I feel for you but this is actually a pretty hilarious Customer and Rep interaction. This is one of those things you'd see in a handbook of "do-not's" at a call center or Customer Service job. Good luck with your phone! I respect your decision!

2
AntiqueTech•

Just ask them to put a crack in the new one before they send it....even trade.

2
pbanj_•

They refused to fix my wife's bootlooped Nexus 5x because the back camera had a crack that they had refused to fix prior because it wasn't in the way of taking pictures. I contacted LG, told them the phone was bootlooped and how Google wouldn't fix it because of the camera. They said that shouldn't matter as the bootloop was a device defect and 5 min later I had my shipping label. When my 5x eventually bootlooped I didn't even bother to contact Google and just contacted LG.

1
el_n00bo_locoBlack & White•

Did you pick up a wireless charger as a temporary solution?

Also, I have doubts you get a new phone when all is said and done. It will likely be a refurb.

1
Sirius401Pixel 2xl•

My dongle worked 10% of the time

1
tomelwoody•

Well, you cracked the glass so could have dropped it. They're not going to and I wouldn't expect them to do anything warranty wise.

1
Metalnakls•

They have zero quality control and don't care. Only reason they will do something is when a lawsuit comes.

0